trespass

This article is written by Prerana Saraf, on property trespass.

Trespass

Trespass is a physical interference by a person in a property belonging to another person. It could be a tort of trespass when there is a direct interference with the peaceful enjoyment of the land in the form of unlawful entry, unlawful placing of things or inducing dangerous things or animals into the land or it could be a criminal act provided under Section 441 of Indian Penal Code, 1860 which defines ‘criminal trespass’ as ‘Whoever enters into or upon property in possession of another with intent to commit an offence or to intimidate, insult or annoy any person in possession of such property, or having lawfully entered and unlawfully remains there.’ Intention is an element as ‘mens rea’ is important for an act to be criminal. Punishment for the same is provided under Section 447, which includes imprisonment for upto 3 months; fine upto Rs. 500 or both.
The Supreme Court examined the definition of a ‘trespass’ in 2010 in Laxmi Ram Pawar v. Sitabai Balu Dhotre[1], in the context of Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971. The Supreme Court was of the opinion that, ‘A trespass is an unlawful interference with one’s person, property or rights. With reference to property, it is wrongful invasion of another’s possession.’
A person who unlawfully remains in the property of the other is also liable for ‘trespass by remaining on the land.’ This is when a person lawfully enters into another persons’ property but remains there even after the right ceases to exist.  There is ‘continuing trespass’ as well, which means that trespass by way of personal entry continues as long as the wrong-doer is personally on the land. Or, if he has induced a thing, trespass continues for as long as the thing is removed from the land.

Ingredients

It can be gathered that, the essential ingredients of a criminal trespass, therefore are:
1.Entry into or upon property in the possession of another;
2.If such entry is lawful, then unlawfully remaining upon such property;
3.Such entry or unlawful remaining must be with intent to commit offence, annoy or intimidate the person.
Also, the property has to be in actual possession of another person. ‘Actual’ means to the exclusion of all other people. It need not necessarily be in the possession of the owner, it could be with the tenant as well. Besides, the entry need not be forceful; it is enough if it is without permission. However, the owner needs to be diligent about a peaceful trespasser who is unaware of the title of the true owner since, if the owner does not assert his title within a prescribed period and trespasser is allowed to have peaceful, continuous possession, he acquires an absolute title over the land. The limitation period provided under Article 65 of the Limitation Act, 1963 for suit for possession of immovable property is twelve years.

This was observed by the Supreme Court in Nair Service Society v. K.C. Alexander[2] on the basis of which various propositions with regard to trespasser vis-a-vis a true owner were laid down. Some of the relevant propositions are mentioned below:

  • Unauthorized entry into another’s land will not have the effect of dispossessing the true owner. Such acts will lead to settled possession only when the true owner having knowledge of it, acquiesces
  • When the trespasser is not in settled possession, the rightful owner can re-enter and reinstate himself by removing the obstruction or unauthorized construction by using minimum force. Such action by true owner will be considered as defending his possession.
  • However, if the trespasser is in settled possession and such adverse possession continues for 12 years, the right of the true owner is extinguished.

Therefore, if the acts of the person in possession of a property are irreconcilable with the rights of the true owner, such acts of the person in possession would constitute adverse possession/settled possession against true owner. As a consequence, it is always advisable for the owner to approach the court for remedy against any kind of trespass if repeated notices to the trespasser go ineffective.

The owner or tenant of the land in possession of the property is entitled to remedies in the form of:

(i) Injunction – to restrain trespasser from causing any further damage
(ii) Damages – compensation for all the losses you have incurred due to the trespass.

Precautions and Procedure:

It is important for a person to be primed in order to handle an instance of trespass in their land/property. First and foremost, one has to keep his/her title deeds viz mother deed, conveyance deed, upto date tax paid receipt, khata from the appropriate authority ready. In case of agricultural land, RTC extract (Record of Rights, Tenancy and cultivation) and MR extract (Mutation Register) from concerned Tahasil office and Akarbandh, Tippani copy, and Phodi sketch from the survey department. All the aforesaid documents show that the person has legal title and is the rightful owner and has been in peaceful possession and enjoyment of the subject property.
Apart from having all these legal documents in place, in order avoid trespass and to be at a safer side one has to place either compound wall or barbed wire fencing around their property and exhibit his ownership with board stating ‘This property belongs to XYZ, trespassers will be prosecuted. (with phone No.)’ This helps one to declare that he has the undisputed title to the property with no objections from anybody including the trespasser.
In spite of all this, if the trespasser enters one’s land repeatedly even upon asking them to leave, or damages his board or compound, then one must go ahead and lodge a police complaint under Section 441 of the Indian Penal Code. You could also plead for interim relief from the court restraining the trespasser from causing any further damage. Interim or temporary relief can be granted at any period of a suit. It is granted if it is proved by affidavit or otherwise, that the subject property is in danger of being wasted, alienated or if defendant threatens to dispose of the property with the intent to defraud creditors.
Further, one can also file a suit for declaration of title, as once it is declared that you have the title to the property, the trespasser cannot transfer the property illegally.  It is also impertinent for you to know the particulars of the trespasser and make note of the instances of trespass. Details like the date, time, the number of times the person trespassed along with a photograph or video would add to your benefit.

These measures will help you eliminate the trespasser from your property.

[1] Civil Appeal No. 2789 of 2005.

[2] Nair Service Society v. K.C.Alexander, AIR 1968 SC 1165.

Did you find this blog post helpful? Subscribe so that you never miss another post! Just complete this form…

6 COMMENTS

  1. Hello, My Uncle registered our land on his own name without concern us or without knowing us. We live with my brother in same building which that land occurred. We don’t have trust on him. If in future he’ll tresspass on our house. So I want to know what kind of law applicable for this situation. Our house was on my name. But that land on my uncle name. We have fear if he give our children difficulty in future. Pls help me.

  2. I was made a tenant of a flat in the year 1992. Landlord says, tenancy was handed over back to him in 1999 by my late father alongwith physical possession. Thereafter we have trespassed in the said flat in 2003. He was in possession from 1999 to 2003. Hence date of trespassing according to landlord is 30/8/2003. From 2004 he claimed the possession of the said flat back from us as per a clause which was mentioned in the family Arrangement & to which Arbitration was going on. His claim in the said Arbitration was rejected by the Arbitrator to which he appealed in High court. There too he lost. He filed an Slp in Sc, final hearing of which was in January 2016. He again lost there. In between after losing in Hc he filed private criminal complain in 2006 for criminal trespassing. Police filed a report in 2010 as ‘B’ summary. Thereafter in 2015 further investigation order has been passed & police is investigating the matter.
    I need to know, landlord says i trespassed & has not filed a suit for recovery of possession of the premises. Infact he claims his possesson to the said flt as per one of the clause in the Family Arrangement. Does the time of Arbitration, Hc & Slp in Sc is excluded from the Twelve years or not? Do i become the owner if landlord says that i have trespassed in 2003 eventhough he would have claimed possession of the flat in Arbitration, challanged in HC & filed Slp in Sc?

  3. My landlords two major sons aged around 28 and 30, sneaked into terrace through my house in the night around 10’O clock and started drinking when I come to know, I confronted them after which they went back.

    Next morning when I complaint to my landlord he along with his sons and wife misbehaved with me and told that It is there right to use the stairs which goes from inside my rented accomodation any time they wish and told me to vacate the house.

    Can I file the complaint for this ?

  4. latest judgment on criminal trespass by supreme court with details be kindly made to my email id at an early date.
    Regards,
    dilip

  5. what will be the fine for tress passing and three trees are cut with four feet deep digs without permission
    and found another partly buildings in our places.

  6. Thanks for the note i just read

    My neighbor has a door on my rooftop he asks for money to close it is it fair

    The door has been their before i purchased the house

    I had no problems in the door

    But now he keeps abusing me for buying the house

    He says it was his first right to buy the house

    No one in the neighborhood seems to help me

    Coz

    Some political party people are in his relationship

    Cant say anything to police aswell
    He has a strong hold in police also

    I cant pay him the money

    I have spent all my money in the house

    Is their any way i can construct a wall without giving him any money

    Help me please

Leave a Reply to Yogi Cancel reply