Download Now
Home Blog Page 237

Section 26 of CPC, 1908

0

This article is written by Tarini Kalra, a BBA-LL.B. student from Fairfield Institute of Management and Technology affiliated with Guru Gobind Singh Indraprastha University, New Delhi. The article discusses the institution of a suit under Section 26 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908.

It has been published by Rachit Garg.

Introduction

Have you ever wondered how a civil suit is filed in a civil court? Let’s make our basics clear first. The administration of civil proceedings in India is governed under the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC). Before filing a civil complaint, it is essential to determine the court’s jurisdiction under Section 9 and the place of suing under Section 18 of the CPC. The initial step of the procedure of a civil suit is the institution of the suit under Section 26 of the CPC. The present article provides a detailed study of the provisions of the institution of the suit under Section 26 of the CPC. 

What is a suit

The term ‘suit’ is not defined under the CPC, 1908. The Black Law’s Dictionary, 4th edition defines suit as “A generic term, of comprehensive signification, and applies to any proceeding by one person or persons against another or others in a court of justice in which the plaintiff pursues, in such court, the remedy which the law affords him for the redress of an injury or the enforcement of a right, whether at law or in equity.”  A suit is a civil process initiated by the filing of a plaint seeking to enforce civil or substantive rights against the state or a person. A suit results in a decree. There can be no decree without a suit.

In the case of Ethiopian Airlines v. Ganesh Narain Saboo (2011), the Hon’ble Supreme Court observed that the term ‘suit’ is a general term that encompasses all actions to be taken by a person to enforce a legal right that has been vested in them by law.

In the landmark case of Hansraj Gupta & Others v. Dehra Dun-Mussoorie Electric Tramway Co. Ltd. (1932), the Privy Council held that a civil proceeding is instituted by the presentation of a plaint. 

Suit under the Limitation Act, 1963

The Limitation Act, 1963 governs the laws regulating the limitation of suits and other procedures. An appeal or an application is not considered a suit under Section 2(l) of the Limitation Act, 1963. Section 5 of the Limitation Act, 1963, deals with the extension of the prescribed time frame in certain circumstances. It states that any appeal or application may be allowed even after the limitation period has passed if the appellant establishes to the court that they could not file the appeal or application during the limitation period. If the court is satisfied, the delay in submitting the appeal or application can be excused, regardless of whether the party is a state or a private entity. Section 5 of the Limitation Act, 1963, does not apply to suits. 

In the case of F. Liansanga v. Union of India (2022), the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that the authority to exempt delay under Section 5 of the Limitation Act does not apply to suits.

Section 9 of the Limitation Act, 1963 outlines the continuous running of time. When the cause of action accrues, the time runs out. It states that once a period of limitation starts, no subsequent disability or inability can stop it. It applies solely to suits and applications and does not apply to appeals unless the matter falls under one of the exceptions set out in the Act. Section 9 applies when the cause of action or right to petition the court exists on the date of the application.

Essentials of a suit

Parties to the suit

There must be at least two opposing parties: the plaintiff who files the suit for claiming relief and the defendant against whom the plaintiff files for the claim. There is no restriction on the number on either side. Every suit is instituted by the presentation of a plaint. A plaint must be filed by the plaintiff, a representative, a recognised agent, or an advocate for the plaintiff. 

Order I, Rule 1 of the CPC, outlines the joinder of the plaintiffs to the suit. All persons may join as plaintiffs if any claim to relief in a single suit arises from the same act or transaction or a series of acts or transactions alleged to exist jointly, severally, or in the alternative, or where any common question of law or fact arises. 

Order I, Rule 3 of the CPC outlines the joinder of the defendants to the suits. When any claim to relief is alleged to exist against defendants arising out of the same act or transaction or series of acts or transactions, or when any common question of law or fact would emerge if separate cases were launched against the defendants, all people may join as defendants in a suit.

A misjoinder occurs when a party to the lawsuit is unintentionally added. It is deemed a  misjoinder when a party is added but has nothing to do with the dispute. When a party to the suit is not added to the suit, then it is a non-joinder. Order I, Rule 9 of the CPC states that no suit shall be dismissed on the grounds of the misjoinder or non-joinder of parties. This Rule does not apply to necessary parties interpreted as non-joinder.

Cause of action 

A cause of action is the set of reasons on the basis of which a lawsuit is instituted in court. It is a set of facts or allegations that constitutes grounds for filing a lawsuit. It includes all the facts pertaining to rights and their infringement. Order II, Rule 2 of the CPC states that a cause of action is essential, and a plaint must mention the cause of action if it is to be instituted as a suit.

In the case of Rajasthan High Court Advocates Association v. Union of India & Ors. (2000), the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that the phrase “cause of action” had a judicially established meaning. It refers to the conditions surrounding the violation of the right or the direct cause of the conduct. In a broader sense, it refers to the conditions required for the suit to be maintained, which include not just the violation of the right, but the violation combined with the right itself. and summarised the phrase to all facts that the plaintiff would have to establish if he were to be traversed to maintain his claim to the Court’s judgement. The cause of action includes every truth that must be proven, as opposed to every piece of evidence that must be given to substantiate each fact.

Subject matter 

The set of facts or details about a movable or immovable property that gives rise to a civil dispute to claim remedies is referred to as the subject matter.

The relief claimed by the plaintiff 

Relief is a legal remedy available to the plaintiff for a violation of legal rights by the defendant. No remedy will be granted by a court unless the parties to the complaint request it. There are two types of relief: specific and alternative. Specific relief is governed under the Specific Relief Act, 1963.

Institution of a suit under Section 26 CPC

The primary step of civil litigation is the institution of a suit. The institution of suits is governed under Section 26 of the CPC, read along with Order IV, CPC. 

According to Section 26 of the CPC:

  1. Every lawsuit must be initiated by the filing of a plaint or in any other manner as prescribed by law. 
  2. An affidavit must be used to substantiate the facts in every plaint. The affidavit must comply with the specifications mentioned under Order VI, Rule 15A.

Order IV of the CPC outlines the commencement of a suit by plaint. It states that: 

  1. Every suit must be instituted by the presentation of a plaint to the Court or any official designated on its behalf. 
  2. Every plaint must comply with the rules outlined in Orders VI and VII
  3. A plaint is not considered to be duly instituted unless it complies with the criteria stated under sub-rules (1) and (2).

Order IV, Rule 1, must be read with Section 26 of the CPC in the extension of the law as provided in the Section. According to this regulation, a lawsuit can only be considered adequately commenced if it is delivered to the court directly or to a proper official designated in this capacity with a plaint or in duplicate. The requirements outlined in Orders VI and VII must be followed by the plaint.

Section 80 of the CPC, requires that a legal notice be served before the filing of a suit if the defendant in the suit is the government or a public officer. However, only some civil suits require serving a legal notice. In certain scenarios, advocates serve legal notice before the filing of civil cases to inform the defendant that the sender of the notice is making the final attempt to resolve the dispute. It is primarily used as a precautionary measure.

The procedural aspect of the institution of suits includes the following:

  1. Preparation of a plaint 
  2. Choosing the appropriate place of suing 
  3. Presentation of the plaint

Plaint – a necessary tool for the institution of a suit

A plaint is a legal document in which a plaintiff pleads to the court for restitution for any legal injury inflicted by the defendant. There is no strict format for drafting a plaint. Order VII, Rule 1  of the CPC, specifies rules about the particulars to be included in the plaint are provided. A plaint must include the following:

  1. Name of the court where the suit is filed;
  2. Plaintiff’s name, description, and address;
  3. Name, description and address of the defendant, as it can be ascertained;
  4. A statement to that effect is required when either the plaintiff or the defendant is a minor or a person of unsound mind;
  5. Facts constituting the cause of action and when it arose;
  6. Facts proving the jurisdiction of the court;
  7. Relief which the plaintiff requests to claim;
  8. If the plaintiff has approved a set-off or waived a portion of his claim, the amount allowed or waived; and
  9. A statement of the value of the subject matter of the suit for the purposes of jurisdiction and court costs, to the extent permitted as per the case.

Rejection of a plaint

Order VII Rule 11 outlines specific grounds for the rejection of a plaint. The grounds for rejection of the plaint are: 

  1. No cause of action is disclosed;
  2. When the remedy sought is undervalued and the plaintiff fails to update the valuation after being ordered by the court to do so within a set period;
  3. When the remedy sought is correctly valued but the plaint is insufficiently stamped and the plaintiff is requested by the court to provide the necessary stamp paper within a deadline determined by the Court but fails to do so;
  4. Where the statement in the plaint suggests that the suit is prohibited by any law;
  5. If it is not filed in duplicate;
  6. When the plaintiff does not comply with provisions of Rule 9.

In the case of Kavita Tushir v. Pushpraj Dalal (2022), the Delhi High Court rejected the application of a plaint stating that there could be no piecemeal rejection of the plaint. “Piecemeal rejection” of a plaint means that a plaint must be rejected as a whole, not partly.

Appropriate place of suing 

Section 15 to Section 20 of the CPC deal with the place of suing. 

According to Section 15, the plaintiff must file the suit in court with the lowest competency level.

Section 16 states that suits should be instituted within the local jurisdiction where the property is located in the case of:

  1. Recovery of immovable property with or without rent or profits;
  2. Partition of immovable property;
  3. Foreclosure, sale or redemption of a mortgage or charge upon immovable property, 
  4. Determination of any other right or interest in immovable property;
  5. Compensation for damage to immovable property;
  6. Recovery of movable property under distraint or attachment.

When a suit is filed for relief or compensation for a wrongful act to immovable property by a defendant or any other person on his behalf and the relief can be obtained through his personal attendance, the suit may be filed in a court within the local jurisdiction where: 

  1. the property is located;
  2. the defendant resides, carries on business or personal for gains.

This concept is based on the legal maxim “equity acts in personam” which means “equity applies to a person rather than a property.”

Section 17 discusses the jurisdiction of suits for immovable property located within the jurisdiction of different courts. When immovable properties are located in separate jurisdictions, the suit may be filed in any court within the local jurisdiction where any portion of the property is located, provided that the cause of action for both properties is the same.

In the case of Shivnarayan v. Maniklal (2019), the  Hon’ble Supreme Court ruled that under Section 17 of the CPC, the term ‘property’ might refer to more than one property. Suits brought for different properties can be brought in any court with jurisdiction if the cause of action is the same.

Section 18 outlines the place of institution of the suit where the jurisdiction of courts is uncertain. If there is uncertainty about the jurisdiction of the institution of a suit of immovable property between two or more courts, then a statement must be recorded to that effect by any of the courts if the court is satisfied with the uncertainty and proceeds to entertain or dispose of any suit relating to that property, and its decree in the suit shall have the same effect as if the property were situated within the local limits of its jurisdiction, provided that the institution of the suit is in a competent court with respect to the nature and valuation of the suit to exercise jurisdiction.

When a statement is not recorded pursuant to Section 18(1) and an objection is brought before an Appellate or Revisional Court that a decree or order in a suit relating to such property was made by a court not having jurisdiction where the property is situated, they shall not allow the objection unless they presume there was no reasonable ground for uncertainty as to the court having jurisdiction at the time of the institution of the suit and there has been a consequent failure of justice.

Section 19 deals with suits for compensation of wrongful activity to a person for movable property. When a suit is for compensation for the wrong done to a person or to movable property, the plaintiff has a choice as to the institution of the suit within the local limits of the jurisdiction where the defendant resides, carries on business, or works for personal gain, or within the jurisdiction where the property is situated.

Section 20 is a residuary provision of a place of suing. It deals with the institution of suits where the defendant resides, carries on business, works for personal gain, or where the cause of action wholly or partly arises within the local jurisdiction of the court. When there is more than one defendant at the time of the commencement of the suit, the suit can be instituted where any of the defendant or defendants resides, carries on business, or works for personal gain, provided that the plaintiff obtains leave from the court. If the defendants consent to the place of institution of the suit, then there is no need to obtain leave from the court. 

Presentation of plaint

Order VII Rule 9 specifies the procedures for admitting a plaint. It states that the court orders that the summons be served on the defendants in accordance with Order V, Rule 9, and that the plaintiff must submit as many copies of the plaint as there are defendants, along with the prescribed fee for serving the summons on the defendants, within seven days of the date of such an order. The plaintiff shall pay the requisite fee for the serving of the summons on the defendants within the time fixed by the court. When a plaintiff sues a defendant or defendants, the plaintiff must declare in what capacity the defendant or defendants are being sued in order to act in a representative capacity. In order to make these statements consistent with the plaint, the plaintiff may seek leave from the court. The chief ministerial officer of the court shall sign such lists, copies, or statements if he considers them to be correct upon investigation.

Jurisdiction of courts with respect to suits of civil nature

Jurisdiction is primarily determined by the following factors: 

  1. Valuation of suit;
  2. Territorial boundaries of a court;
  3. The subject matter of court.

The kinds of jurisdiction are mentioned as follows:

Pecuniary Jurisdiction 

The term ‘pecuniary’ refers to money. It empowers the courts to determine matters of monetary subject matter. A court has jurisdiction over those suits where the value of the suit does not exceed the pecuniary jurisdiction. Presently, the pecuniary jurisdiction of the district court is up to Rs 2 crore.

Territorial jurisdiction 

Each court has geographical boundaries outside of which it cannot function and exercise authority. The government alters these restrictions. The district judge must exercise authority within the district. The High Court only has jurisdiction over the state where it is located.

Subject matter jurisdiction

The power granted to a court to hear cases involving a specific subject is subject matter jurisdiction. The courts cannot hear cases whose subject matter falls outside of their jurisdiction.

Concurrent jurisdiction

Concurrent jurisdiction exists when two or more courts from different legal systems have jurisdiction over the same matter.

Exclusive jurisdiction

The power to hear a case before one court or tribunal is called exclusive jurisdiction. No other court or authority may deliver a judgement or decide the case or class of cases. 

Appellant jurisdiction

Appellate jurisdiction refers to a court’s ability to hear cases from subordinate courts. While exercising its appellate jurisdiction, the superior court may quash the lower court’s decision, order the lower court to hear the case again, order the lower court to take additional evidence, and make any other order it deems appropriate.

Original jurisdiction

The power of a court to hear or try a case in the first instance is referred to as original jurisdiction. Original jurisdiction requires that a particular type of case be initiated and tried in the lowest court in the hierarchy before proceeding to the next court in that hierarchy if necessary. Within the guidelines set forth by the law, a court with original jurisdiction may hear the matter, reach various findings, and issue orders.

Special jurisdiction 

The courts are granted the authority to hear cases of a specific nature. The Hon’ble Supreme Court ruled in Harshad S. Mehta & Ors v. State of Maharashtra (2001) that the special court has exclusive jurisdiction to adjudicate a matter, which is given to the Special Court by the act or the statute that established the court and not by committal.

Legal jurisdiction

In legal jurisdiction, all courts are administered by the law of the land, including statutes, precedents, customs, equity, justice, and good conscience.

Scope and applicability of Section 26

In a civil lawsuit, the burden of proof lies on the plaintiff. The plaintiff must establish that the accusations against the defendant are true and the defendant is liable for damages. A plaint must include all required information and supporting documentation. Additionally, the necessary court expenses should be included with the plaint. A small fraction of the overall claim or suit value is used as court costs. The Court Fees Act, 1870, and the Stamp Act, 1899 specify the required amounts of court fees and stamp duty depending on the type of suit.

Section 9 of the CPC deals with the jurisdiction of courts to try all suits of a civil nature except those suits in which the cognizance is not expressly or impliedly barred.

Suits expressly or impliedly barred

Suits expressly barred: 

A suit barred by a statute in effect is a suit expressly barred. A competent legislature may limit the civil court’s ability to hear a certain kind of civil suit, provided that it does so without violating any constitutional provisions and remains within the purview of the legislative authority granted to it. As a result, when a suit is specifically excluded by the law currently in effect, it cannot be filed.

Suits impliedly barred: 

A suit is said to be impliedly barred if it is prohibited by general legal principles. Based on public policy, even civil lawsuits are similarly excluded from civil court jurisdiction. A person who needs a remedy in a different form than what is provided by statute is therefore denied when a specific remedy is provided by statute.

Formalities after the institution of a suit

The beginning and institution of the suit before a court or such officer appointed in this regard are outlined in Order IV Rules 1 and 2.

The issue of summons to the defendant or defendants is covered under Section 27. A summons to appear and answer the claim is sent to the defendant on the day that is not more than thirty days after the suit has been instituted, and it is served in the manner specified.

Section 28 deals with serving summons to defendants who are residents of other states. A summons must be sent to the court in another state in compliance with the rules in force in that state. The court to which such a summons is conveyed must act as though it has issued the summons itself. The court must return the summons, along with a record of its proceedings, to the court that issued the summons.

When the summons sent for service in another state is in a language other than the language of the record, a translation of the record must be supplied:

  1. The translation must be provided in Hindi if the court issues the summons in that language;
  2. Where the record is in a language other than Hindi or English, the translation must be given in Hindi or English and delivered with the record.

Section 29 deals with serving the foreign summons. Summons and other legal documents must be produced by:

  1. Any Civil or Revenue Court established in India, regardless of where the CPC does not apply; 
  2. Any Civil or Revenue Court established or maintained by the Central Government outside of India, or
  3. Any other Civil or Revenue Court outside of India to which the Central Government has declared the provisions of this section to apply by notification in the Official Gazette can be delivered to the Courts in the regions covered by this Code and served as if they were summons issued by those courts.

Section 31 addresses witness summons. The provisions of Sections 27, 28, and 29 shall apply to any summons to produce documents or other material objects or to provide testimony.

Conclusion

Every right has a remedy, or “Ubi jus, ibi remedium,” which is one of the fundamental principles of the legal system. A plaintiff may file a civil lawsuit to obtain compensation for losses the defendant has caused. A plaint must include all relevant information and serves as the first step in the documentary process of the institution of civil litigation. However, the onus of proof is on the plaintiff as the plaintiff files the suit and states the facts and legal grounds. The plaintiff must convince the court and support every allegation made against the defendant by presenting the true facts and reasonable grounds for the institution of the suit.

Frequently asked questions (FAQs)

Can a suit be filed without any cause of action?

No, a suit cannot arise without a cause of action.

When can a plaint be rejected?

A court can reject suo motu. A plaint can be rejected at any stage of the suit but before the verdict is rendered.

Can a plaint be partially rejected?

A plaint cannot be partially rejected. However, in the case of Dr Sanjiv Bansal v. Dr Manish Bansal (2022), the Delhi High Court remarked that Order VII, Rule 11(d) of the CPC, 1908, specifies that a plaint shall be rejected where the suit appears from the statement in the plaint to be barred by any law, and Order VI, Rule 16 of the CPC, allows the court to strike out any part of the pleading at any point in the proceedings that appear to be an abuse of the court’s procedure or is inappropriate, scandalous, unreasonable, offensive, or harmful.

What is the remedy available for the rejection of the plaint? 

 A fresh suit can be instituted by the plaintiff under Order VII, Rule 13.

References

  1. https://districts.ecourts.gov.in/sites/default/files/judge%2Cfamilycourtworkshop.pdf 
  2. https://lawtimesjournal.in/meaning-and-essentials-of-suits/ 
  3. https://www.estartindia.com/knowledge-hub/blog/summary-suits-under-cpc 
  4. https://blog.ipleaders.in/draft-suit-points-remember/ 
  5. https://lawfaculty.in/kinds-of-jurisdiction-code-of-civil-procedure-cpc/ 
  6. https://www.writinglaw.com/types-of-jurisdiction/ 
  7. https://sherianajamii.com/types-of-jurisdiction 
  8. https://blog.ipleaders.in/an-in-depth-analysis-of-section-9-of-the-cpc/#:~:text=A%20suit%20is%20said%20to,than%20is%20given%20by%20statute.%E2%80%9D 

Students of Lawsikho courses regularly produce writing assignments and work on practical exercises as a part of their coursework and develop themselves in real-life practical skills.

LawSikho has created a telegram group for exchanging legal knowledge, referrals, and various opportunities. You can click on this link and join:

https://t.me/lawyerscommunity

Follow us on Instagram and subscribe to our YouTube channel for more amazing legal content.

Download Now

Section 112A of the Income Tax Act

0
Taxation Laws Act
Image source - https://bit.ly/33Z6yHv

This article is written by Sanjana Santhosh, a law student at Christ (Deemed to be University), Bengaluru. The article explains the concepts and intricacies of Section 112-A of the Income Tax Act, 1961.

This article has been published by Sneha Mahawar.

Introduction

Equity trading income is taxed differently depending on whether the gains were realised over a long or short period of time. Long-Term Capital Gains (LTCG) on shares and securities for which Securities Transaction Tax (STT) is paid were excluded until the conclusion of the 2018–19 financial year in accordance with Section 10(38) of the Income Tax Act, 1961. This provision was in place until the end of the fiscal year. However, due to changes made in Budget 2018, the Section 10(38) exception no longer exists. In addition, long-term capital gains derived from the sale of equity shares, equity mutual funds, and units of business trust that are in excess of Rs. 1 lac for a financial year are now subject to a 10% income tax in accordance with the newly enacted Section 112A of the Income Tax Act. These gains must be reported on tax returns. LTCG was determined as a result of Section 112A which was inserted by the Finance Act, 2018. This rate applies to gains on certain assets that have been held for an extended period of time. This article examines the application of Section 112A of the Income Tax Act, including a detailed analysis of each of the components that constitute tax computation under this section.

What is a capital gain

A capital gain is a profit that an investor makes when they sell a capital asset for a price that is higher than the price at which they purchased the item. According to the Income Tax Act, taxable income includes capital gains. When an assessee sells land that has been used for agricultural purposes, for example, they are eligible for a capital gains tax exemption because this is a unique condition that only applies to this type of transaction. The term “Capital Gains” refers to the profits or gains that result from the transfer of a capital asset. These profits or gains are subject to taxation under the heading “Capital Gains.”

It is possible but not certain that the asset is connected in some way to the assessee’s line of work or enterprise. Examples include land, vehicles, residential property, commercial property, machinery, jewellery, and buildings, among others. Included on this list are individuals who have rights in or in relation to an Indian firm.  

Types of capital gain

Gains on investment can often be broken down into the following categories based on the duration the investor has been in possession of the asset:

  1. Short-term capital gain: The profits generated from selling an asset that was purchased less than one year ago are considered short-term capital gains. For example, a sale of an asset that takes place less than 12 months after the asset was initially purchased is regarded as having short-term capital gains. These earnings are taxed differently from long-term capital gains. However, the duration of ownership for various kinds of assets may vary greatly from one another. When it comes to an inheritance, the idea of capital gains does not apply because there is no transaction that includes a sale of the inherited property. However, the inheritor will be responsible for paying income tax on the profit made from the sale of the inherited property once it has been sold.
  2. Long-term capital gain: Long-term capital gains are the term given to the profit made from the sale of an asset that has been held for more than three years and six months. The previous holding period of 12 months for immovable properties was increased to 24 months as of the 31st of March, 2017. However, this rule does not apply to movable assets such as jewellery or debt-oriented mutual funds, among other types of investments. In addition, certain assets are regarded as short-term capital assets if the duration of time spent hanging onto them is less than a year. The following is a list of assets that are taken into account in accordance with the rule that was presented earlier:
  • Shares of ownership in any company that is traded on a stock exchange that is officially recognised in India.
  • Securities such as bonds, debentures, and other similar debt obligations are listed on any of India’s stock exchanges.
  • Unit Trust of India (UTI) units, irrespective of whether they are quoted or not quoted. 
  • Gain on capital invested in equity-oriented mutual funds, regardless of whether or not the funds are quoted. 
  • Bonds with no coupon interest.

If any of the assets stated above are retained for an amount of time greater than one year, then they are categorised as long-term capital assets.

What is a long-term capital gain 

Only gains on investments held for more than one year are subject to taxation under Section 112A. In order to be subject to taxation under Section 112A, the duration of keeping the property must be longer than one year. The tax rate is 10% on any amount that is greater than the exemption threshold of Rs 1 lakh. Therefore, long-term capital gains that fall under the purview of Section 112A are exempt from taxation up to a limit of one lakh rupees each fiscal year. Gains that are greater than one lakh rupees are subject to taxation at a rate of ten percent, plus education cess and any relevant surcharge.

For instance, if a taxpayer’s yearly (net) long-term capital gain according to Section 112A is Rs. 1,50,000, then the tax of 10% according to Section 112A is calculated based on Rs. 50,000. (Rs. 1,50,000 – Rs. 1,00,00).

A resident individual or HUF whose total income, after deducting the long-term capital gains, is less than the basic exemption level; in this case, the long-term capital gains are subject to a reduction equal to the gap in income.

For illustration purposes, we will assume that a taxpayer has a total income of Rs 400,000 and that their net long-term capital gains under Section 112A are Rs 200,000. After deducting the value of the capital gains, the remaining income is a little over two thousand rupees, which is less than the basic exemption level. 50,000 rupees is the amount that the lowered total income is short of in order to fall below the basic exemption level (Rs 2,50,000 – Rs 2,00,000). The gains on long-term investments that are subject to taxation will amount to Rs 1,50,000. (Rs 2,00,000 – Rs 50,000).

A long-term capital loss would be incurred if there was a loss incurred upon the sale of long-term listed equity shares or units, as described above. Only a long-term capital gain can be deducted against a short-term investment loss. In the event that one has losses from some securities but gains from others, he will be able to deduct the losses from the gains using the set-off method. The only time taxes are applied to net gains is when such gains are greater than Rs 1,000,000.

Calculating long-term capital gain

  1. When computing the long-term capital gain tax outlined in Section 112A, the first and second proviso to Section 48, also known as the benefit of indexed cost of acquisition and cost of improvement, are not allowed to be taken into account. 

Indexation aids in reflecting the true market worth of an asset by accounting for inflation’s declining effect on purchasing power. It is common practice to refer to the purchase price of an asset as its “indexed cost of acquisition” when selling the asset. The term “cost of improvement” refers to the sum an assessee spends to enhance or replace an existing capital asset.

  1. Also, when Section 112A applies, Non-Resident Indians (NRIs) cannot take use of the advantages of indexation or calculating capital gain in a foreign currency. Only in cases where Section 112A applies does this regulation operate.
  2. The cost of acquisition for assets that were acquired prior to February 1, 2018, shall be the higher of the following: the actual cost of acquisition, the lower of the fair market value of such assets and the full value of the consideration received or accruing as a result of the transfer of the capital asset. In other words, the cost of acquisition shall be the greater of these two amounts.
  3. The method that should be utilised to determine the fair market value is as follows:
  4. The following formula should be used to determine the fair market value of any capital assets that were listed on a recognised stock exchange as of January 31st, 2018: The highest price that a capital asset was quoted at on a recognised stock exchange as of the 31st of January 2018 is the price that will be used to determine the fair market value of any capital assets that were listed on a stock exchange as of the 31st of January 2018.

If there is no trading of the capital asset on the 31st of January 2018, the asset’s fair market value will be determined by the highest price that was ever quoted for the asset on a date that was immediately prior to the 31st of January 2018 and was the day on which it was last traded.

  1. If the capital asset for which the fair market value is sought is a unit, but the unit was not listed on a recognised stock exchange as of January 31, 2018, then the fair market value of such capital asset shall be the net asset value of such capital asset as of January 31, 2018.
  2. In all other cases, the fair market value of an asset shall be determined by the amount that, in the case of an equity share that was not listed on a stock exchange as of January 31, 2018, but which was listed on a stock exchange on the date of transfer, bears to the cost of acquisition the same proportion as the cost inflation index for F.Y. 2017-18 bears to the cost inflation index for the first year in which the asset was held or the year beginning on April 1, 2001, whichever is later. This sum is equivalent to the purchasing price.
  3. In accordance with the terms of Section 112A, deductions claimed under Sections 80C to 80U and/or rebates claimed under Section 87A cannot be applied against the capital gain taxed as a result of those Sections.

Tax Computation on long-term capital gain under Section 112A

The factors below will be used to determine the amount of tax due on the long-term capital gain if the aforementioned four requirements are met:

Long-term capital gain in excess of Rs. 1 lakh taxable at 10% 

  • Gain on the sale of an asset held for more than a year is exempt from taxation if the amount is less than Rs. 1 lakh 
  • If the gain is more than Rs. 1 lakh, the additional sum will be subject to taxation at a rate of 10% (+ surcharge + 4% health and education cess).
  • Whether the assessee is a corporation or an individual, the rate of 10% remains the same.

Benefits of exemption limit in some cases 

The exemption limit is advantageous owing to the provision in Section 112A (2). Only citizens or HUFs with a permanent address in the country can receive this perk (may be ordinarily resident or not ordinarily resident).

Further, this advantage is only accessible if the individual’s adjusted gross income (after deducting the long-term capital gain indicated in condition 2) is less than the exemption level.

What does Section 112A of the Income Tax Act say 

An assessor must pay income tax on capital gains from long-term capital assets as described in Section 2 (29A) of the IT Act, 1961 at the rate of 10% under Section 112A if the value of the gains is more than INR 1,000,000. If the assessor has determined that he or she is liable for this tax and the conditions in this section are met, then this tax is due. Shares, debentures, and business trust units are all included in the scope of this clause, as are other securities that may or may not be listed.

Section 112A does not apply to the deductions provided by Chapter VI-A. If the conditions in Section 10(38) aren’t met, the exceptions of that provision will not apply.

Before the amendment of Section 112A

A long-term capital gain tax exemption was in place for the transfer of equity shares, units of equity-oriented funds, and units of business trust prior to Assessment Year 2018-2019 under the terms of Section 10(38).

After the amendment of Section 112A

Since April 1, 2018, income from the sale of equity shares, units in equity-oriented funds, and units in a business trust is exempt from taxation under the requirements of Section 10 (38). Income taxed as a result of the sale of equity shares, units in equity-oriented funds, or units in a business trust must comply with the provisions of Section 112A beginning on April 1, 2018.

Exceptions to Section 112A

Some of the areas that are exempted from the application of Section 112A are:

  1. There is no tax imposed on profits made from mutual fund investments.
  2. If Section 112 applies, then Section 112A is not relevant.
  3. Non-Resident Indians are not eligible for this offer (NRIs)
  4. Shares that are not subject to Securities Transaction Tax (STT) when they are transferred do not have to be listed on a stock exchange in order to qualify, and the International Financial Service Centre (IFSC) is one location that qualifies.
  5. Foreign Institutional Investors (FII) are also not included because the securities held by them are indeed capital Assets and there is no requirement of proving the same. 
  6. If the assesses prove that the securities held by him are capital assets and not Stock in Trade. 

Acquisition Cost (Capital Gains on or before 31 Jan 2018)

Acquisition costs subject to tax should be determined using a value that is greater than the lower of the asset’s financial market worth and the sales consideration. Gains in excess of INR 1,00,000 are subject to a 10% tax rate, whereas gains under that threshold incur no tax.

If the financial market worth of an asset is INR 5,50,000, sales consideration is INR 6,00,000, and the real cost of purchase is INR 5,00,000.

The taxable capital gain is determined as follows: 

  • Step 1: Take the lesser of the fair market value and the sales consideration, or INR 5,50,000. 
  • Step 2: Compare the value taken to the actual cost of purchase and use the larger number, or INR 5,50,000.
  • Step 3: INR 50,000 is the result when INR 6,00,000 is subtracted from INR 5,50,000; this is the amount of capital gain that must be reported and taxed.
  • Step 4: Determine Your Tax Bill: If you make an INR 50,000 profit, then your capital gains tax is INR 5,000 (10% of 50,000).

Note: Please be aware that any losses under this section can be carried forward and set off, after which the balance would be subject to taxation as per Section 70 through Section 80.

Adjustment for Rs 1,00,000 exemption

Gains in excess of Rs. 1 lac would be subject to 10% LTCG taxation under Section 112A.

In its frequently asked questions section, CBDT assured taxpayers that the tax calculator software would automatically remove Rs 1 lac from the overall capital gains amount.

To qualify for the lower rate provided for in Section 112A of the Income Tax Act, the following requirements must be met:

  1. Securities transaction tax (STT) was reported upon the purchase and sale of the company’s equity interest.
  2. These long-term capital gains would not be eligible for the deduction under chapter VI A if:
  1. The asset was not a security, 
  2. The STT was not provided at the time of disposal, and 
  3. The asset was not an equity-oriented fund or a business trust unit.
  4. The long-term capital gains tax owed under Section 112A could not be deducted from the Section 87A refund.

Conditions to Tax Capital Gains Under Section 112A

The following stipulations clarify the application of Section 112A: 

  1. The sale must be of listed equity shares, units of a mutual fund, or units of a business trust.
  2. Investments in securities should be used for long-term capital projects.
  3. Equity share purchases and sales are taxable events under the STT (Securities Transaction Tax). 
  4. In the event of equity-oriented mutual fund units or business trust shares, the selling transaction is subject to STT.

Fair market value 

The fair market value (FMV) of a product is the price at which it would sell on an open market if it were assumed that both the buyer and the seller have a reasonable level of knowledge about the asset, are acting in their own best interests, are not under any undue pressure, and are given a reasonable amount of time to complete the transaction. It is important to note that the concept of “fair market value” is not interchangeable with concepts such as “market value” or “evaluated value” since it takes into account the economic principles that underlie the operation of free and open markets. On the other hand, when people talk about an asset’s market value, they mean the price that it fetches on the market. Therefore, while the market value of a home may be easily accessed on a listing, the fair market value of a home is far more challenging to assess.

In a similar manner, the phrase “appraised value” refers to the worth of an item according to the judgment of a single assessor. This does not automatically qualify the assessment as being equal to the fair market value.

An appraisal is typically all that is required to determine a property’s fair market value in situations where such a valuation is required.

The phrase “fair market value” is frequently used in legal contexts since it takes a number of different factors into consideration. For instance, fair market value of real estate is frequently used in the process of reaching agreements on divorce and in calculating compensation for eminent domain taken by the government.

Additionally, fair market values are frequently applied in the process of taxes, such as in the process of assessing the fair market value of a property in order to claim a tax deduction following a loss caused by a casualty.

The highest price at which a listed asset was ever traded on a recognised stock exchange is considered to be the FMV of that security.

If there was no trading in the security on the 31st of January 2018, the FMV is determined by the highest price that was offered for the security on a date immediately prior to the 31st of January 2018, at a time when the security had traded on a recognised stock exchange.

In the event that an equity share was acquired as a result of a merger or other transfer under Section 47, or if the share was listed after January 31, 2018, the FMV will be as follows: 

Cost of the purchase x (The cost inflation index for the fiscal year 2017-18/the cost inflation index for the fiscal year 2001-2002)

How can one report a case under Section 112A 

It is possible to record long-term capital gains on a scrip-by-scrip basis using Section 112A which is included in the income tax returns for the AY 2020-21. The information that must be included on Schedule 112A includes the ISIN code, the name of the scrip, the number of units or shares sold, the selling price, the acquisition cost, and the FMV as of January 31, 2018. The specifics are required so that one may calculate the appropriate amount of long-term capital gains in situations in which the grandfathering laws are relevant.

The grandfathering rules were implemented by the Finance Act of 2018, which exempted long-term capital gains generated up until January 31, 2018, from taxation. When determining the cost of acquisition for specified securities that were purchased prior to February 1, 2018, we begin by taking whichever of the following two values is lower: the fair market value as of January 31, 2018, or the sale consideration. Then, we look at the difference between the outcome and the sale price, and we go with the higher of the two. A grandfather clause, grandfather policy, or grandfathering is a provision in which an old rule continues to apply to some current instances, but a new rule will apply to all future cases. Those individuals who are exempt from the new regulation are referred to as having grandfather rights, acquired rights, or as having been grandfathered in.

In a recent press release, the Central Board of Direct Taxes (CBDT) provided clarification that scrip-wise information is not required for the reporting of long-term capital gains from investments made after January 31, 2018. 

Case laws 

P.M. Kunhabdulla Haji vs Income-Tax Officer 1986 162 ITR 304 Ker

The court in this case referred to the case of Gita Devi Dhurka vs. Income Tax Officer & others [1977] Tax LR 722, and held that, Income Tax Act Sections 132(5) and 132(11) provide that if the property is taken during a search and afterward claimed by a third party, the Income Tax Officer must be satisfied as to the identity of the person against whom he intends to proceed u/s 132 before issuing a notice under Section 112-A. Therefore, if the Income Tax Officer has reason to believe, at the time notice is given under Rule 112-A, that the commodities seized do not belong to the person from whom they were taken, then he may initiate proceedings under Section 132(5) against the third party making the claim.

Rajesh Kumar Gupta, Kanpur vs Department Of Income Tax I.T.A.No.605(LKW.)/2010

In this case, with an individual tax status, the assessee benefits from dalali and commission income. The Station Officer of the Ganga Ghat Police Station in Shukla Ganj, Unnao informed the AO that on 6th December, 1994 they had collected ten lakh rupees from the assessee, Shri Rajesh Gutpa. In the end, Rs. 10 lacs in hard cash was seized in accordance with Section 132A of the Income Tax Act. During Section 112A proceedings, the assessee was asked to detail how he came into possession of the Rs.10 lacs in cash and from where he got the money.

The court held that the income reported by the assessee was all that was subject to taxation, and no further amount was due. This case did not meet the requirements for a penalty under Section 271(1)(c) of the Income Tax Act since the assessee had already revealed his ‘Income from other sources,’ which included the Rs. 10 lacs that were discovered in his hands on 7th June, 1994. There was no attempt to hide income or provide false information in the assessee’s income tax return for the 1995-1996 tax year because the return was filed on time. It follows that the AO’s sentence was unjustified, and the learned counsel, Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) [ld. CIT(A)] made the correct decision in cancelling it.

Conclusion 

Section 112A was added to the Finance Act of 2018, and it imposes taxes on long-term capital gains derived from the sale of listed equity shares, units of equity-oriented mutual funds, and units of business trusts. Gains that were previously exempt from taxation are now able to be declared on form 112A, as of the 2017–2018 fiscal year (AY 2018-19). Previously, under Section 10, sales of listed equity shares, units of mutual funds, and business trusts were exempt from the capital gains tax under Section 10 (38). Previously, long-term capital gains on the sale of Specified Assets were exempted from the application of the Securities Transaction Tax (STT), as stipulated in clause 38 of Section 10. The requirements of Section 10(38) have been superseded by Section 112A, and as a result, long-term capital gains derived from the sale of Specified Assets are now subject to taxation in line with the provisions of Section 112A.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) 

Will the taxpayer be subject to taxation on any capital gains that they make as a non-resident?

Yes, the TDS deduction will be applied at a rate of 10% for any non-resident Indian’s long-term capital gains earned, and this rate will apply to all non-resident Indians. The calculation of capital gains, on the other hand, needs to be carried out in accordance with the terms of the Finance Bill of 2018.

When figuring out long-term capital gains, will one be able to take advantage of indexation?

When calculating long-term capital gains on equity shares or other equity-oriented funds, one will not enjoy the advantage of indexation of the cost of acquisition because the cost of acquisition is not taken into account. In this regard, the Department of Income Tax has just recently published a clarification.

How can one determine the cost of acquisition for any investment that was purchased on or before the 31st of January 2018?

If the Fair Market Value (FMV) of the item on January 31, 2018, is higher than the actual cost of the item, then the Cost of Acquisition (COA) will be the FMV. If, on the other hand, the complete value of consideration at the time of transfer is less than the FMV, then the cost of acquisition of this investment is determined by either the full value of consideration or the actual cost, whichever is higher.

When submitting ITR, which pieces of information are required for compliance with Section 112A?

When you file your income tax returns for the assessment year 2020-21, you will need to fill out Schedule 112A as part of the process. This schedule will be of use in reporting your long-term capital gains in a scrip-wise manner. You will need to submit the following information in this section: the ISIN code, the name of the script, the total number of units sold, the purchase cost, the sale price, and the FMV as of January 31, 2018.

Can I set off a long-term capital loss from my income?

The answer is yes. However, you can only deduct a long-term capital loss from long-term capital gains. You cannot deduct the loss from short-term gains. In the event that you incur losses from some securities but realise profits from others, you are permitted to deduct those losses from the total amount of gains you have accumulated. However, you won’t be able to deduct this loss until the assessment year which comes eight years after the year in which the loss occurred.

Is compliance with Section 112A mandatory?

It is required that you complete Schedule 112A for the assessment year 2020-21 in order to provide information of each transaction involving the purchase, sale, or redemption of listed equity shares and equity-oriented mutual funds.

References 


Students of Lawsikho courses regularly produce writing assignments and work on practical exercises as a part of their coursework and develop themselves in real-life practical skills.

LawSikho has created a telegram group for exchanging legal knowledge, referrals, and various opportunities. You can click on this link and join:

https://t.me/lawyerscommunity

Follow us on Instagram and subscribe to our YouTube channel for more amazing legal content.

Download Now

Patent registration process in India

0

This article is written by Gautam Chaudhary, a law student at Chander Prabhu Jain College of Higher Studies and School of Law, GGSIPU. The present article provides a step-by-step procedure to register or file a patent in India. 

It has been published by Rachit Garg

Introduction 

Intellectual property in terms of patent law can be defined as something tangible in nature that is framed out of someone’s intellectual knowledge and innovative spirit. This knowledge and innovative spirit that an individual possesses acts as a source of livelihood for an innovator in the world of intellectual property rights and innovative industries. The creator of a particular invention may earn great wealth through his invention in the form of royalties if he lets companies use his innovation for which he issues a licence. The innovator may also sell his innovation for a considerable amount, or he may even start his own business, among many other options. All the above-mentioned riches may only be available to the creator if he registers his invention for patent protection. Therefore, the present article discusses why there is a need to register a patent in India, followed by exhaustive step-by-step procedures for the same.  

Patents in Indian Patent Act, 1970

Section 2(m) of the Indian Patent Act, 1970, defines a patent as “a patent which is granted for any invention under the provisions of this Act.” Now, from the mere reading of the above-given definition, it is clear that the meaning of patent is not explicatory.

Therefore, in an attempt to define the same, a patent is, in simple terms, an exclusive monopoly right that is granted to the creator or sole inventor of the invention. This right is only given to the sole inventor because he is the one who has invested his hard work, sweat, and capital into the creation of the said invention, which protects the invention from other competitors in the market by preventing them from selling, manufacturing, using, and distributing the patented technology or inventions.

As per the Indian Patent Act of 1970, a patent is only granted when a certain technology or product fulfils the following criteria, which are also discussed in depth for clear comprehension.

New or novel

For the grant of a patent in the Indian jurisdiction, any invention created has to be mandatorily novel in nature. The Act uses the term “novel invention” in relation to the definition. Therefore, it is necessary to first define the term ‘invention’ which is given under Section 2(1)(j) of the Indian Patent Act and elucidates that anything can be termed an invention when it is created through an inventive step, i.e., introducing technical advances to the existing technology and giving out a product or process that is capable of industrial use.

Now, on to the novel aspect of this invention. Section 2(1)(l) of the Act provides that an invention is said to be new or novel when it is not anticipated in the document or used in India or the world before the filing of the patent application with the specified subject matter of the invention in the Indian patent office. What must be seen to consider the invention as new is that it did not exist in the state of the art because it enables every individual in the country to access the prior existing technology or invention. The same aspect was observed in Bishwanath Prasad Radhey Shyam v. Hindustan Metal Industries (1978), that an invention must have a novelty of such a nature that it was not known in society before the date of the patent for the grant of a patent.  

Inventive step

An invention shall only be patented when it involves an ‘inventive step’. The mentioned term, in plain language, means an advancement to an invention’s technicality, which is new and different from the existing technology in the particular field. Another criterion by which an invention is considered to involve an inventive step is when it is non-obvious to a person skilled in the field. 

Let us understand this through an example. Say a person named ‘A’ works in the field of electric motor vehicles, and he has invented a system where every time a person hits the brake, the energy goes directly to the vehicle’s battery cabinet, thereby enabling the charging of the battery while in use. The said invention is patentable since it involves an inventive step of such a nature that is new from the existing technology and is non-obvious to a person skilled in the related field as no one could ever think of this system.

The Supreme Court in M/s. Bishwanath Prasad Radhey Shyam v. M/s. Hindustan Metal Industries, (1978) coined the phrase, “As per the criteria, the patent for a created invention would only be granted when the invention is of such new use in relation to technological advancement and said that some problem related to a particular field is solved because of the said creation. Moreover, it is provided that the invention must not be a mere workshop improvement, what has to be looked at is whether the technique is new or unique, which is producing new articles or new aids in the relative industry.”  

Non-obviousness

An invention is said to be non-obvious when it is different from the existing inventions present in the state of the art. For the grant of patent protection, the aspect of ‘newness’ is not enough for the invention. What has to be seen is that it also comprises elements that are undoubtedly different from the existing inventions in the relevant industry. Also, an invention must be of a nature that is not obvious or simple in its operational aspects. The person in the relevant field who is not an expert must be able to conclude that the invention sought to be patented is different from existing inventions and adds a new element that is not obvious in nature.

In Rado v. John Tye Son Ltd. (2013), it was held that “a non-obvious invention is that which is beyond the thinking of a mere person working in the field.” What is to be noted is that the invention should be something that sets the standard and technology apart from existing technical trends that are not natural and usual.

Further, in Graham v. John Deere Co. (1966), the U.S. Supreme Court provided criteria to ascertain whether something was obvious or not. Providing, the court should consider:

  1. The scope and content of prior art.
  2. The difference between the prior art and the claim of the new invention.
  3. The level of skill in the pertinent art. 
  4. The failure of others to solve the problem.
  5. Long unsolved problems related to the related field.

Industrial applications

Section 2(1)(ac) provides that the invention is said to be of industrial applicability when it is capable of being made or used in the industry. The term ‘industrial application’ refers to the use of the invention sought to be patented. The patent office explicitly looks at the uses that the invention would provide in the industry and whether it would truly be of some aid for industrial matters or not. The use of the invention is termed the ‘utility’ of a patent. If the inventor who sought his invention for a patent cannot satisfy himself as to how his invention contains the potential for industrial use, then the invention will not be patented because it is a rule that creation must have its fundamental use in the relative industry. 

For reference, in Chiron Corp v. Murex Diagnostics (1994), the industrial application was best defined. The court stated that “the phrase capable of industrial application must carry with it a meaning of trade or manufacture in the broadest sense, and there must be profit to be made since no industry would make use of something which would be useless.” 

Further, in Lakhpat Rai & Ors. v. Srikissen Dass & Ors., (1918), the Allahabad High Court termed the industrial use of the invention as its utility, where it was observed that the required invention’s use or aid does not necessarily mean improvement, as it means practicability. The utility test is based on whether the invention will do what it claims or provides to do.

Need to register a patent with the Indian patent office

The following are the essential reasons for having the invention patented in India:

Protection and possession

In this technology-ridden era where all businesses are driven by high-tech technology, it is essential for the innovators to protect their knowledge since it is the only tangible asset that is responsible for all their operations because of their created technology. So, it is essential for the running of business operations to protect this very technology from other players in the market. Apart from this, the concept of the original inventor also comes into play since what a man invents must be his asset because he is the only one who has invested his sweat, energy, time, and, most importantly, knowledge and skills in the creation of the said invention. Unfortunately, in today’s time, every other corporation, whether it’s small or giant, is indulged in the race to achieve the best that can be achieved by new inventions and ideas. Therefore, in order to protect and possess what is yours, it is essential to patent the invention.

Monetization opportunity

Once the inventor of a certain invention acquires its patent, he is open to monetizing it at his will and can thus amass a handsome amount of wealth. The patent can no doubt be a source of wealth if handled with due diligence and financial knowledge. The creator can generate wealth through the marketing of the new product, licensing it to any other corporation that provides a great monetary value, and even selling the patent for a massive amount.

Encourage innovation

In the patent registration procedure, it is provided that when a patent application is accepted and completes all its necessary requirements, the said invention is published in the patent journal to inform the world that this invention is being patented, and for the same reason, any opposition is invited. Upon the publication of the invention, the created technology is directly put out into the world with every minute detail along with its functions, and other innovators come to know of this invention. Therefore, through this, the inventor also encourages the spirit of innovation in society. Since ideas can be taken or can emerge in the minds of other innovators with the knowledge of existing inventions on the market, other aspiring inventors or creators can surely indulge in the practice of learning how to make this certain invention more advanced or how to make another invention complementary to this one that would benefit society on a greater level.

Office jurisdictions of filing patent applications

A patent application can be filed in Kolkata, Delhi, Mumbai, and Chennai either online or at the respective jurisdictional patent offices for the grant of patents. 

The above-mentioned office covers the following jurisdictions:

Patent officeState jurisdiction 
Mumbai patent officeStates of Maharashtra, Gujarat, Madhya Pradesh, Goa, Chhattisgarh and union territories of Daman & Diu & Dadra & Nagar Haveli
Chennai patent officeStates of Andhra Pradesh, Karnataka, Kerala, Tamil Nadu, and the Union Territories of Pondicherry and Lakshadweep. 
New Delhi patent officeStates of Delhi, Haryana, Himachal Pradesh, Jammu & Kashmir, Punjab, Rajasthan, Uttar Pradesh, Uttaranchal and the Union Territories of Chandigarh 
Kolkata patent officeThe rest of India.

Online patent registration process in India

The following is the detailed step-by-step procedure to file a patent in India through the online system:

Step 1:

Account log in 

Anyone who wants to file for a patent for his invention first has to visit the site, i.e., E-Filing of Patent Applications, and then has to create an account there. Through e-signing accounts can be created there. 

Patent search (discretionary/optional) 

One of the foremost and most important steps is to search the technology or invention that one has created to see whether whatever he has created does exist in the state of the art since, for the grant of a patent, one of the requirements is the novelty of the product, i.e., its newness. A patent search can benefit the inventor by allowing him to look for inventions already existing in the public domain; through this, he could find out what inventions are patented in India or around the world, whereby he can then make a decision regarding his further operations with the invention and whether to follow the patent procedure or not. Through this, he escapes from spending unnecessary fees on the patent application and other relative work. Moreover, the patent offices grant patents to those inventions that are new in the state of the art to such an extent that they did not exist in the world prior to the patent filing. 

Patent application

Section 7 of the Indian Patent Act of 1970, requires the true creator of the invention to file the application for only one invention in the patent office in the prescribed form. In accordance with the same, he is to draft a patent application in Form 1. Patent application drafting refers to the drafting of an invention in legal and technical language, wherein the patent agent mentions all about the invention with each and every specification. The motive for the drafting of the patent application is to state how the present invention is to be used by people skilled in the art, advocate how the invention created is different from others, and explain how it can be of industrial application. The most crucial step in patent filing is the drafting of patent applications.

The individual has to fill out Form 1 provided above to complete the first step of e-filing the patent. 

In this step, only Form 2 is also to be attached, which is called the patent specification form. In this, the applicant needs to specify the provisional or complete specification of the invention, stating the description, claims, and abstract for the same. The description of the invention has already been discussed above, so let’s discuss the terms “claims” and “abstract act” of the invention. 

Claims

Patent claims are the most important part of the patent specification since they act as a show book for the patent applicant. Through patent claims, the patentee states the subject matter of the patent, wherein he or she specifies the elements and boundaries of the said invention. After stating the subject matter of the same, the patentee then notifies the patent office of what he sought to protect in the invention through a patent so that no other individual can sell, manufacture, or distribute it without prior permission. 

Abstract

According to Section 10(4)(d) of the Act, an abstract must be submitted with the patent application. Rule 13(7) of the Patent Rules 2003 defines a patent abstract as a short version of the description of the application, where the applicant needs to provide a short title of the invention along with its features in not more than fifteen words. The present rule further provides that the abstract shall describe the technical field to which the invention belongs, the technical advancement of the invention as compared to existing knowledge, and the principal use of the invention, excluding any speculative use, in not more than one hundred and fifty words. In simple terms, it is said to consist of a few words about the patent subject matter as to what new technological advancements or technology the invention will introduce into the industry with the use of the same.

Drawing and figure of abstract

Rule 15(3) of the patent rules states that at least one copy of the invention’s drawing should be attached to the patent application. The patentee produces the drawing in a pdf format of the invention, followed by the production of the abstract figure in a jpg format.

Statement and undertaking 

Section 8 of the Patent Act and Rule 12 of the Patent Rules govern the provisions regarding the statements and undertakings of a patent, where Section 8(1)(a) elucidates that the patentee must provide a statement regarding any other application that he has filed outside India, providing the particulars about the same or substantially similar invention. It is necessary for the patentee to notify the patent office about the same within six months of the patent application’s filing date. 

Section 8(1)(b) further makes it mandatory for the patentee to produce an undertaking to the patent controller to give a timely update regarding the filing of any application outside India. 

Power of attorney

In Form 26, the patentee is required to give a power of attorney in case a patent agent is assigned. The power of attorney plays a crucial role in the grant of the patent since the patentee acts through this legal document and only gives authority to his agent to act on his behalf.

Declaration of inventorship 

Section 28 specifies that the person filing the patent application must be the true inventor or joint inventor of the said invention, and for the same, he is to file a declaration of inventorship in Form 5, wherein the true inventor makes a declaration that he is the original inventor or joint inventor of the invention.

Fees payment

The last step is to pay the payment fees through the payment gateway.

Step 2

Rule 24 of the patent rules talk about the publication of a patent application in an official journal which provides that after the expiration of 18 months, the patent application will be made available to the public. After the submission of all the above-stated requisite documents and forms, and after an expiration of 18 months from the date of filing of the application, the application is officially published in the journal, where the title, abstract, application no., and names of the application and inventor are mentioned.

Step 3

Rule 55 provides that after the publication of the patent application in the journal, the said application is open for any opposition by any person within 3 months from the date of publication or before the grant of a patent, along with the statement, evidence, and request for hearing of the opposition. Further, if there is opposition, the patent controller will forward the opposition to the applicant. Upon receiving the opposition from the controller, the applicant will file the statement along with supporting evidence in reply. And after having all the relevant evidence along with the statement, there will be a hearing if it is so requested. If not, then the controller will finally either reject the opposition or accept it and not grant the patent. 

Section 25(2) provides that if the same opposition is filed after the grant of the patent, it is called post-grant opposition. Here, the interested party files an opposition against the granted patent in Form 7 within one year after the grant of the patent.

Step 4

Request for examination

In order to protect the invention, as per Rule 24B, the applicant has to file a request for examination of the patent within 48 months from the date of filing the application. Section 11B of the Act states that no application for the grant of a patent will be examined unless the applicant  requests the same. Where the application is not filed within the above-stated time period, the application is treated as withdrawn by the applicant.  Therefore,  it is absolutely mandatory for the applicant to apply for examination of the patent if he truly wants his invention protected. 

First examination report

After the request for examination of the patent application, the examiner at the patent office will thereby examine the invention in order to ascertain whether the created invention fulfils the essentials for a patent, which are novelty, inventiveness, and industrial application. 

After examining the invention, the office will issue a first examination report (FER) and send it along with specifications to the applicant, highlighting the objections and suggestions contained therein. Usually, an examiner sends the report within one month.

Step 5

After receiving the first examination report (FER), the applicant gets an opportunity to submit a response to the objections raised to overcome all of them. And if the controller finds the responses submitted by the applicant satisfactory in light of the raised objections, the patent will be granted to the applicant.

Offline patent registration process in India

For the purpose of offline patent filings, there are jurisdictional patent offices in the Kolkata, Delhi, Mumbai, and Chennai regions.

The applicant can protect his invention through patent protection by filing the patent application in offline mode by visiting the office and submitting the requisite documents and doing the necessary formalities. An applicant has to submit the following documents at the counter of the jurisdictional patent office:

Step 1

Covering indicating the list of documents

At the outset of the patent application in offline mode, the applicant first needs to attach a cover indicating the list of documents. This list of documents is simply an index that primarily showcases the required documents that are attached to the application. 

Application for grant of patent

The second step is to attach the application for the grant of a patent to Form 1 in duplicate. 

Specification

The application for grant of a patent is followed by the specification of the invention, either provisional or complete. The specification refers to the description of the invention that is sought to be protected through the grant of a patent. It is important to note that the provisional specification is only optional, while the complete specification is mandatory. 

The specification also comprises a description, claims, drawings, and an abstract. which have already been discussed above under the “online patent filing” heading.

Statement and undertaking

It is mandatory for the applicant to provide a statement and undertaking for the grant of the patent for his invention. 

Power of attorney

A power of attorney is to be attached with the application in Form 26 in case a patent agent is assigned.

Declaration of inventorship

In Form 5 in duplicate, the applicant has to provide a declaration of inventorship in relation to the invention. 

Statutory fees

At last, the applicant has to pay the required statutory fee for the processing of his application for further procedures. 

Statutory fees are:

ParticularsNatural personSmall entityLarge entity
For patent filing applicationRs. 1,750Rs. 4,400Rs. 8,800
For each sheet of specificationRs. 180440880
For each claimRs. 350Rs. 880Rs. 1,760

After the above-mentioned first step, the application would then go through the same steps that were followed in the online patent filing process, i.e., the publication of the application, opposition to the application, including post-grant opposition, followed by a request for the examination, and receiving the first examination report where, after satisfying the controller through the filed statements, the applicant acquires the patent for his created invention.

Conclusion 

The concept of patent protection in Indian patent law is to limit individuals other than the inventor’s ability to use, sell, and manufacture the product or technology for their own private gain or interest. This protection enables the creator to keep the inventions created only for themselves. Whereas, it also gives the inventor the right to monetise it for further economic purposes. But, all these opportunities and protections come into play when the inventor registers the technology and invention with the patent office, either online or in person. Through registering his creations, the inventor lets his knowledge and innovative spirit shine; along with this, the innovative spirit keeps prevailing in the minds of other innovators who think, work, and innovate whatever it is to make the world better. 

Frequently asked questions (FAQs)

Who can apply for a patent in India?

Section 6 of the Indian Patent Act, 1970, provides that any person claiming to be the true and first applicant, or being the assignee of the person claiming to be the true and first inventor in respect of the right to make such an application, or being the legal representative of any deceased person who, immediately before his death, was entitled to make such an application, can apply for a patent in India.

What is the need to file a patent in India?

The paramount purpose of filing a patent is to protect the creation or invention from authoritative sale and manufacture in the market because it is the true creator who has invested his time, money, skill, and knowledge in its creation. 

Through whom can a person file a patent application?

Although Section 6 of the Act provides that any person can file a patent application in India, in most cases, the inventor does not have the required knowledge about the filing process and system. Therefore, many organisations and companies in the innovative world hire patent agents and attorneys to assist the inventor in filing a patent efficiently. 

What is the term of patent protection in India?

According to Section 53 of the Act, the term of patent protection in India is 20 years from the date of filing of the application for the patent.

References

  1. Law relating to Intellectual Property Rights by V.K Ahuja, Third Edition. 
  2. https://yourpatentteam.com/benefits-patent-india/
  3. https://patentinindia.com/
  4. https://www.mondaq.com/india/patent/1155310/term-of-a-patent-in-india-and-strategies-to-reap-maximum-benefits-from-the-patent-term

Students of Lawsikho courses regularly produce writing assignments and work on practical exercises as a part of their coursework and develop themselves in real-life practical skills.

LawSikho has created a telegram group for exchanging legal knowledge, referrals, and various opportunities. You can click on this link and join:

https://t.me/lawyerscommunity

Follow us on Instagram and subscribe to our YouTube channel for more amazing legal content.

 

 

Download Now

Capital gains tax

0

This article has been written by Oishika Banerji of Amity Law School, Kolkata. It discusses the concept of capital gains tax which is tax on profits received on the sale of a non-inventory asset.

This article has been published by Sneha Mahawar

Table of Contents

Introduction

The profit that an investor makes when they sell an investment is subject to the capital gains tax. It must be paid in the tax year when the investment is sold. Depending on the filer’s income, the long-term capital gains tax rates for the 2021 and 2022 tax years are 0%, 15%, or 20% of the profit. Every year, the income rates are modified. Any investment that is owned for more than a year will result in a long-term capital gains tax obligation for the investor. A short-term capital gains tax is imposed if the investor owns the investment for six months or less. The taxpayer’s typical income band affects the short-term rate. That is a higher tax rate than the capital gains rate for everyone who saves their best income. This article discusses the concept of capital gains tax with respect to India. 

What is capital gains tax 

The capital gains, or profits, are said to have been “realised” when stock shares or any other taxable investment assets are sold. Unsold investments and “unrealized capital gains” are exempted from getting taxed. No matter how long they are held or how much their value rises, stock shares will not be taxed until they are sold. The majority of taxpayers pay a greater rate on their income than any potential long-term capital gains. 

The term ‘capital gain tax’ refers to the tax imposed on this capital gain. For the sale that occurred the previous year, this tax is assessed under the heading of capital gains. You must pay the capital gain tax if and when:

  1. A capital asset that you have for sale falls within this category.
  2. The sale has given you a profit.
  3. The transaction took place the prior year (the year immediately before the assessment year). 

Thus, they have a financial incentive to hang onto investments for at least a year in order to benefit from the lower profit tax. Any profits made from buying and selling assets held for less than a year are not only taxed but they are also taxed at a higher rate than profits made from holding assets for a longer period of time. Day traders and other individuals who benefit from the simplicity and speed of online trading should be aware of this.

Depending on how long the asset has been in your hands, the gain from a capital asset can be divided into two categories, namely, short-term capital gains and long-term capital gains. One of the most popular investments is purchasing real estate. The main motivation is to own a home, while other people invest in order to profit from the sale of their immovable property. For taxation reasons, a residential property counts as a capital asset. You can deduct the gain or loss from the sale of a residential property on your income tax return. Similar to this, sales of various kinds of capital assets may result in capital profits or losses.

Capital gains tax in India

Simply explained, a capital gain is any profit or gain that results from the sale of a “capital asset.” Due to the fact that this gain or profit falls under the category of “income,” you must pay tax on it in the year that the capital asset is transferred. As there is no sale and only a transfer of ownership, capital gains are not taxable on inherited property. Assets obtained as gifts through inheritance or will are expressly exempt under the Income Tax Act, 1961. However, capital gains tax will be charged if the asset’s new owner decides to sell it. 

Capital gains tax calculator

Finding the difference between the price you paid for your asset or piece of property and the price you received for it at the sale is the foundation of a capital gain computation. The steps involved in calculating capital gains tax have been listed hereunder:

  1. Establish your foundation first. The purchase price plus any commissions or fees paid often constitutes this foundation. Dividends on equities that are reinvested, among other things, may also raise the basis.
  2. Calculate the amount you realised.
  3. To calculate the difference, deduct your basis (the price you paid) from the realised amount (the price you received when you sold it).
  • You get a capital gain if you sell your assets for more money than you bought for them.
  • You incur a capital loss if you sold your assets for less than you paid for them.
  1. Find out how to use capital losses to reduce your capital gains tax.
  2. To determine the tax rate that might be applicable to your capital gains, read the descriptions in the section below.

The structure of the capital gains tax calculator can be viewed here

What is a capital asset 

By definition, a capital asset includes:

  1. Any type of property that an assessee owns, whether or not it is related to their line of work or place of business.
  2. Any securities held by a Foreign Institutional Investor (FII) that invested in them in compliance with the Securities and Exchange Board of India Act (SEBI), 1992.
  3. Any Unit Linked Insurance Plans (ULIP) to which Section 10(10D) of the Act’s exemption is inapplicable due to the application of its fourth and fifth provisos.

Let us take, for example, that Mr. Kumar bought a residence in January 2021 for Rs. 8,400,000. In April 2022, he sold the residence for Rs. 90,000,000. Mr. Kumar’s residential property is a capital asset in this case; as a result, the gain of Rs. 6,00,000 from the sale of the residential property would be considered as capital gains and subject to taxation under the “capital gains” heading.

A few examples of capital assets are real estate, buildings, houses, cars, jewellery, patents, trademarks, and leasehold rights. This includes having stakes in or ties to Indian businesses. It also includes any other legal rights, such as those related to management or control. A list of things that do not come under the heading of “capital assets” has been provided hereunder: 

  1. Any inventory, supplies, or raw materials kept for commercial or professional purposes.
  2. Items held for personal use, such as clothing and furniture.
  3. Agricultural land in rural India.
  4. Deposit certificates or gold deposit bonds issued under the Gold Monetization Scheme, 2015, or the Gold Deposit Scheme, 1999, respectively.
  5. 6½% gold bonds (1977) or 7% gold bonds (1980) or National Defence gold bonds (1980) issued by the Central Government.
  6. Special Bearer Bonds (1991) is an Act to provide for certain immunities to holders of Special Bearer Bonds, 1991 and for certain exemptions from direct taxes in relation to such bonds and for matters connected therewith

The capital asset’s relationship to the taxpayer’s trade or profession may or may not exist. For instance, a bus used to convey passengers by a person involved in the passenger transport industry will be considered his capital asset.

The SEBI Act of 1992 stipulates that any securities held by an FII that made an investment in those securities in accordance with those regulations will always be regarded as capital assets; as a result, those securities cannot be regarded as stock-in-trade.

Short-term capital assets

A short-term capital asset is one that is held for 36 months or less. For immovable items, including land, buildings, and houses, starting in FY 2017–18, the requirement is 24 months. For instance, if you sell a house after owning it for 24 months, any income will be considered a long-term capital gain as long as the sale occurs after March 31, 2017. Movable items like jewellery, debt-oriented mutual funds, and other similar items are not covered by the shorter 24-month term described above. When some assets are held for 12 months or less, they are regarded as short-term capital assets. If the date of transfer is after July 10, 2014, this rule will apply (irrespective of what the date of purchase is). A list of short-term capital assets are:

  1. Equity or preferred shares in a business listed on a reputable Indian stock exchange.
  2. Government securities, debentures, bonds, and other securities are listed on an established stock exchange in India.
  3. UTI units, whether or not quoted.
  4. Equity-oriented mutual fund units, whether or not they are quoted.
  5. Zero coupon bonds, whether or not they are quoted. 

When owning shares of a corporation that is not publicly traded or an immovable asset like a piece of land, a building, or both, the holding period will be reduced from 36 to 24 months. The same applies to long-term assets as well. 

Long-term capital assets

Long-term capital assets are those that have been held for longer than 36 months. If retained for a period of time greater than 36 months, they will be categorised as long-term capital assets. If the owner keeps an asset for 24 months or longer, such as land, a building, or a house, it is termed a long-term capital asset.

When evaluating whether an asset is a short-term or long-term capital asset, it is also taken into account how long the previous owner owned the asset if it was acquired by gift, bequest, succession, or inheritance. When it comes to bonus shares or rights shares, the holding term is measured starting from the date of allotment, as appropriate.

Types of capital gains tax

A capital gain occurs when you sell a capital asset for more money than you paid for it at first. Stocks, bonds, precious metals, jewellery, and real estate are examples of capital assets. Depending on how long you had the asset before selling it, you will either pay tax on the capital gain or not. Long-term and short-term capital gains are categorised and taxed differently. 

Short-term capital gains are those that result from the sale of short-term assets, whereas long-term capital gains are those that result from the transfer of long-term assets. There are a few exceptions to this generalisation, such as the fact that gains on depreciable assets are always subject to short-term capital gains tax.

When selling an asset, it’s crucial to consider capital gains taxes, especially if you occasionally engage in online day trading. First, you must pay taxes on whatever gains you make. Second, despite what you may have heard, capital gains are not always treated more favourably than other forms of income. It depends on how long you possessed such assets before you sold them, as was already explained.  

Assets that are held for more than a year before being sold generate long-term capital gains. Long-term capital gains are subject to taxation at graduated rates of 0%, 15%, or 20% of taxable income. Most taxpayers who declare long-term capital gains pay 15% or less in taxes. Your ordinary income and short-term capital gains are both subject to taxation. In 2022, depending on your tax bracket, that may amount to 37%.

The nature of the gain, or whether it is short-term or long-term, determines whether capital gains are taxable. Therefore, capital gains must be divided into short-term and long-term categories in order to establish their taxability. In other words, there is a difference in the tax rates for long-term and short-term capital gains.

Short-term capital gains tax 

The sale of an asset that has been owned for less than a year results in a short-term capital gain. Short-term gains do not benefit from any special tax rates, despite the fact that long-term capital gains are often taxed more favourably than salaries or wages. They are liable for ordinary income taxes. Like regular income, short-term gains are taxable in accordance with your marginal income tax bracket. 

Based on your adjusted basis in an asset, net capital gains are computed. This is the purchase price of the asset, plus any fees associated with selling the asset as well as the cost of any upgrades you made. You inherit the donor’s basis if an asset is provided to you as a gift. Section 111A of the Income Tax Act, 1961, provides that short-term capital gains are subject to a 15% tax, excluding surcharge and cess. Short-term capital gains that are not covered by Section 111A are subject to tax at a rate based on the individual’s total taxable income.

Short-term capital gains are simpler to compute; to find them, simply deduct the cost of an asset’s acquisition from its sale price.

Short-term capital gains = sale cost of the asset – (expenditure incurred on the asset) – (cost of acquisition/improvement).

Application of Section 111A of the Income Tax Act, 1961

When a Securities Transaction Tax (STT) is due as a result of the transfer of equity shares, units of equity-oriented mutual funds or units of business trusts through a recognised stock exchange on or after January 10, 2004, Section 111A applies.

A mutual fund is considered equity oriented if it meets the requirements of Section 10(23D) of the Act of 1961 and invests at least 65% of its investible funds in the equity shares of domestic companies.

STCG is covered under Section 111A if the requirements of that Section are met as stated above. Such a gain is subject to tax at a rate of 15% (plus any applicable surcharge and cess).

With effect from Assessment Year 2017–18, even in cases where STT is not paid, the 15% concessional tax rate will be accessible.

  1. If the transaction is carried out on a recognised stock exchange housed in an IFSC.
  2. The consideration is received or payable in a foreign currency.

Illustrations

  1. Mr. Ghosh works for a salary. He bought 100 equity shares in X Ltd. in December 2021 from the Bombay Stock Exchange for Rs. 1,400 each share. At a price of Rs. 2,000 per share, these shares were sold on the BSE in August 2022 (securities transaction tax was paid at the time of sale). What kind of financial gain will there be in this situation?

Shares were bought in December 2021 and sold in August 2022, meaning they were sold after being held for less than a year. As a result, the gain is a short-term capital gain. When STCG arises from the transfer of equity shares, units of equity-oriented mutual funds, or units of business trusts through a recognised stock exchange on or after January 10, 2004, and such a transaction is subject to securities transaction tax, Section 111A applies. 

Shares were sold in the aforementioned example after being held for less than a year through a recognised stock exchange, and the transaction was subject to STT; as a result, the STCG can be referred to as STCG covered by Section 111A. Such STCG will be subject to a 15% tax (plus surcharge and cess as applicable).

  1. Mr. Saurabh works for a salary. He bought 100 units of the ABC Mutual Fund in December 2021 for Rs. 100 each. An equity-oriented mutual fund is the one in question. These units were offered for sale on the BSE in August 2022 for Rs. 125 each (securities transaction tax was paid at the time of sale). What kind of financial gain will there be in this situation?

Units were bought in December 2021 and sold in August 2022, meaning they were sold after being held for less than a year. As a result, the gain is a short-term capital gain. When STCG results from the transfer of equity shares, units of an equity-oriented mutual fund, or units of a business trust through a recognised stock exchange on or after January 10, 2004, and such a transaction was subject to the securities transaction tax, Section 111A applies. The STCG is referred to as the STCG covered by Section 111A if the prerequisites of that section are met. Such a gain is subject to tax at a rate of 15% (plus any applicable surcharge and cess).

Given that the mutual fund in the example is an equity-oriented mutual fund, units are sold after less than a year of ownership, they are sold through a recognised stock exchange, and the transaction is subject to STT, the STCG can be referred to as the STCG covered by Section 111A. Such STCG will be subject to tax at 15% (with the relevant surcharge and cess).

Long-term capital gains tax

When compared to selling the identical asset and realising the gain in less than a year, the tax on a long-term capital gain is virtually always cheaper. You can reduce your capital gains tax by holding onto assets for a year or more because long-term capital gains are often taxed at a more favourable rate than short-term capital gains. 

20% of long-term capital gains are typically subject to tax, cess, and surcharge, excluding capital gains tax. If certain qualifying requirements are met by taxpayers, this tax rate decreases to 10% and is applied to assets listed on a reputable stock market, UTI/mutual funds, and zero coupon bonds. Long-term capital gain is computed using the indexed cost of acquisition/improvement and is calculated as follows:

(Cost of acquisition x cost inflation index of the year of transfer of a capital asset)/(Cost inflation index of the year of acquisition)

Long-term capital gains = cost of selling a property – the indexed cost of acquisition.

Long-term capital gains arising from the sale of listed securities

With effect from Assessment Year 2019–20, a new Section 112A is included in the Finance Act, 2018. According to the new provision, capital gains from the transfer of a long-term capital asset that is an equity share in a company, a unit of an equity-oriented fund, or a unit of a business trust are subject to tax at a rate of 10% of such capital gains that exceed Rs. 100,000. This 10% concessional rate will be applicable if:

  1. Securities Transaction Tax (STT) was paid on the purchase and transfer of an equity stake in a corporation, if applicable; and
  2. If STT was paid on the transfer of a capital asset, such as a unit of an equity-oriented fund or a unit of a business trust.

Before February 1, 2018, the taxpayer’s cost of acquiring a listed equity share should be judged to be the greater of the following:

  1. The asset’s actual acquisition cost; or
  2. Lowest of the following:
  1. The shares’ fair market value as of January 31, 2018; or
  2. The actual sales compensation becomes due upon the transfer.

The highest price a listed equity share was quoted on the stock exchange as of January 31, 2018, is considered to be its fair market value. However, if there is no trading in those shares on January 31, 2018, the highest price at which that share was traded on a day immediately before January 31 will be considered the share’s fair market value.

Long-term capital gains arising from the transfer of specified asset

A taxpayer who has long-term capital gains through the transfer of any listed security, any unit of UTI, or any mutual fund (whether or not listed), and who is not otherwise exempt from Section 112A, as well as Zero Coupon Bonds, has two choices:

  1. Take advantage of the indexation benefit; the capital gains so calculated will be subject to tax at the standard rate of 20%. (plus surcharge and cess as applicable).
  2. Do not take advantage of the indexation benefit; the capital gain so calculated is subject to a 10% tax (plus surcharge and cess as applicable).

Calculating the tax liabilities of both alternatives is required before choosing one, and the option with the smaller tax liability should be chosen.

Illustrations

  1. Mr. Janak works for a salary. He bought 100 shares of X Ltd. in January 2016 from the Bombay Stock Exchange for Rs. 1,400 each share. In April 2022, these shares were sold on the BSE for Rs. 2,600 each. On January 31, 2018, X Ltd. shares were valued at a high of Rs. 1,800 per share on the stock exchange. What kind of financial gain will there be in this situation?

Shares were bought in January 2016 and sold in April 2020, meaning they were held for more than three years; as a result, the gain is a Long-term Capital Gain (LTCG). In the described situation, shares are sold after being held for more than a year, through a reputable stock exchange, and the transaction is subject to STT. As a result, Section 112A is relevant in this situation.

The cost of acquisition of X Ltd. shares shall be higher of:

  1. Cost of acquisition i.e., 1,40,000 (1,400 × 100);
  2. Lower of:
  • Highest price quoted as on 31-1-2018 i.e., 1,80,000 (1,800 × 100);
  • Sales consideration i.e., 2,60,000 (2,600 × 100).

The price to purchase the shares will therefore be Rs. 180,000. As a result, Mr. Janak would have long-term capital gains of Rs. 80,000. (i.e., 2,60,000 – 1,80,000). Since Mr. Janak’s long-term capital gains do not exceed Rs. 1,000,000, there is no tax due.

  1. Mr. Saurabh works for a salary. He bought 100 shares of XYZ Ltd. in the month of July 2017 from the Bombay Stock Exchange for Rs. 2,000 per share. In June 2022, these shares were sold on the NSE for Rs. 4,900 each. On January 31, 2018, XYX Ltd. shares reached their highest quoted price of Rs. 3,800 per share on the stock exchange. What kind of financial gain will there be in this situation?

As a result of the foregoing, the price to purchase the shares will be Rs. 3,80,000. Accordingly, Mr. Saurabh would be required to pay Rs. 1,10,000 in taxes on long-term capital gains (i.e., 4,90,000 – 3,80,000). Long-term capital gains are covered by Section 112A because they exceed Rs. 1,000,000. Mr. Saurabh will be responsible for paying 10% of any gains over $1,000 that exceed Rs. 10,000. 

The cost of acquisition of X Ltd. shares shall be higher of:

  1. Cost of acquisition i.e., 2,00,000 (2,000 × 100).
  2. Lower of:
  • Highest quoted price as on 31-1-218 i.e., 3,80,000 (3,800 × 100);
  • Sales consideration i.e., 4,90,000 (4,900 × 100)

Shares were bought in July 2017 and sold in June 2022, meaning they were held for more than a year; as a result, the gain is an LTCG. In the described situation, shares are sold after being held for more than a year, through a reputable stock exchange, and the transaction is subject to STT. As a result, Section 112A is relevant in this situation.

Tax rates (Long-term capital gains and short-term capital gains)

Long-term capital gains tax (LTCG)

Long-term capital gains are typically subject to tax at a rate of 20% (with appropriate surcharge and cess), but in some rare circumstances, the gain may be (at the taxpayer’s discretion) subject to tax at a rate of 10% (plus surcharge and cess as applicable). Only in the following circumstances is the benefit of taxing long-term capital gains at 10% applicable:

  1. Long-term capital gains exceeding Rs. 1,000,000 from the disposal of listed stocks (Section 112A);
  2. Long-term capital gains from the sale of any of the assets listed below:
  • Any security listed on an established Indian stock exchange;
  • Any UTI or mutual fund unit, whether or not they are listed (This option is only applicable to units that were sold on or before October 7, 2014); and
  • Bonds with no coupon. 

According to Section 2(h) of the Securities Contracts (Regulation) Act, 1956, the definition of “securities” typically covers government securities, other financial instruments that the Central Government may declare to be securities, rights or interests in securities, as well as shares, scrips, stocks, bonds, debentures, debenture stocks, and other marketable securities of a like nature in or of any incorporated company or other body corporate. 

Adjustment of LTCG against the basic exemption limit

The basic exemption limit is the amount of income below which a person is exempt from paying any taxes. For the fiscal year 2022–2023, each individual is entitled to the following fundamental exemptions:

  1. The exemption cap for residents who are 80 years of age or more is Rs. 5,000,000.
  2. The exemption cap for residents who are 60 years of age or older but under 80 is Rs. 3,000,000.
  3. The exemption threshold for residents under 60 years of age is Rs. 2,50,000.
  4. No matter the individual’s age, the non-exemption resident’s is limited to Rs. 2,50,000.
  5. The exemption threshold for HUF is Rs. 2,50,000.

Short-term capital gains tax (STCG)

Section 111A covers STCG, which is subject to tax at 15% (plus any relevant surcharge and cess). Standard STCG, or STCG not covered by Section 111A, is subject to tax at the normal rate of tax, which is calculated based on the taxpayer’s total taxable income. On the short-term capital gains mentioned in Section 111A, no deduction is permitted under Sections 80C to 80U. Such deductions, however, may be made from STCG in addition to those not covered by Section 111A. For the purpose of determining the tax rate, short-term capital gains are classified as follows :

  1. Short-term capital gains covered under Section 111A:
  1. Equity shares listed on a recognised stock exchange that are sold for STCG are chargeable to STT.
  2. Units of equity-oriented mutual funds traded through a recognised stock exchange may incur STCG that is subject to STT. STCG resulting from the sale of a business trust’s units
  3. When equity shares, units of an equity-oriented mutual fund, or units of a business trust are sold through a recognised stock exchange housed in an IFSC and the consideration is paid or payable in a foreign currency, even if the sale itself is not subject to securities transaction tax, STCG may result.
  4. Short-term capital gains other than those covered under Section 111A:
  1. STCG results from selling equity shares outside of a recognised stock exchange.
  2. STCG on the sale of assets other than shares or units, such as gold, silver, or real estate.
  3. STCG on government securities, bonds, and debentures.
  4. STCG results from the sale of units of mutual funds that are debt-oriented rather than equity-oriented.
  5. STCG that results from the selling of non-equity shares of stock.

Adjustment of STCG against the basic exemption limit

The basic exemption limit is the amount of income below which a person is exempt from paying any taxes. The following describes the fundamental exemption threshold that applies to an individual for the financial year 2021–2022:

  1. For resident individuals of the age of 80 years or above, the exemption limit is Rs. 5,00,000.
  2. For resident individuals of the age of 60 years or above but below 80 years, the exemption limit is Rs. 3,00,000.
  3. For HUF, the exemption limit is Rs. 2,50,000.
  4. For resident individuals of the age below 60 years, the exemption limit is Rs. 2,50,000.
  5. For non-resident individuals irrespective of their age, the exemption limit is Rs. 2,50,000.

Capital gain tax on the sale of property

  1. In the event that you decide to sell your home, you will be required to pay capital gains tax on the profit that was made after accounting for inflation and the indexed cost of acquisition. The capital gain tax on the sale of the property can, however, be avoided in a number of different ways.
  2. The process of selling a home is a massive and tiresome one in and of itself, but when you include in the fact that you will be taxed on your capital gains, you have the makings of a headache. The money you make when you sell a piece of real estate in India is referred to as capital gains.
  3. The decision to invest the earnings from the sale within the allotted time period and avoid capital gains taxation is entirely up to the person receiving the benefits of the sale.
  4. You must deduct the cost of purchasing (and maintaining/improving) the asset from its sale value in order to calculate your profit (capital gains), which is the amount you receive. These gains can be categorised as either short-term or long-term gains.
  5. Selling your land, house, or another property within three years of buying it is seen as a short-term capital gain. If you sell it after three years, you will be said to have made a long-term capital gain. The distinction between short-term and long-term capital gains is crucial because taxes are applied differently to each. When these two types of gains are reinvested, different tax rates and tax advantages apply.
  6. If certain requirements are met, long-term capital gains on real estate sales are taxed at 20% plus a 3% cess. You will still be responsible for paying capital gains tax on any property you sell that was given to you or that you inherited. Here, the cost of acquisition is computed using the cost to the prior owner and is adjusted for the year of acquisition.

How to calculate capital gains tax on the sale of land

You must pay capital gains tax on whatever property you sell, including real estate. LTCG applies to properties held for more than 36 months, while STCG applies to properties held for less than 36 months.

In the case of STCG, the earnings made from selling land are included in the owner’s taxable income, and they must pay taxes in accordance with the income tax bracket they are in at the time. The current tax rate for LTCG is 20%.

STCG- capital gains tax

You must subtract the acquisition cost, improvement cost (if any), and sale-related costs from the sale price if you are selling the land within 36 months of when you bought it. Your STCG will be this.

Let’s take, for example, 2015, when Mr. Ansari purchased land. He bought it for 10 lakh rupees. In 2016, he received Rs. 15 lakh for selling the land. In this instance, Mr. Ansari’s total income will be increased by a profit of Rs. 5 lakh. According to the tax bracket he falls within, tax will be assessed. The STCG tax calculation is simpler. The land sale’s profit is added to the household’s overall income. According to the slab rates, the income is taxed.

LTCG- capital gains tax

The indexed acquisition and improvement costs can be subtracted from the sale price in LTCG. As the expense of acquisition or upgrade increases, this assists in lowering your capital gains. The cost inflation index is a crucial factor to take into account when calculating long-term capital gains. Every year, the government releases this indicator. A key component in calculating the indexed cost of acquisition and improvement is CII. The cost inflation index is equal to the product of the index for the transfer and the index for the acquisition.

Reduction of tax by indexation

The property’s purchase price can be increased by the seller through indexation, depending on the cost inflation index. It allows the owner to adjust the property’s cost for inflation. As a result, when the purchase price is raised, the increase is subtracted from the sale price to determine long-term capital gains. As a result, it reduces taxable gains.

Let us take for example, in the year 2005, Mr. Singh spent Rs. 10 lakhs on a property. In 2015, he sold that house for Rs. 30 lakh. In the years 2005 and 2015, CII was 480 and 1024, respectively.

CII = 1024/480. CII is, therefore, 2.13.

Indexed cost of acquisition = Cost inflation index x Acquisition cost. 2.13 x 1000 000 is that.

The indexed cost of acquisition is therefore Rs. 21,30,000.

Indexed cost – Sale price equals LTCG. 3000000 – 2130000= 870000.

The LTCG tax rate is 20%.

In this case, the tax will be calculated as 20% of 8,70,000. The amount of capital gains tax due on the sale of land is Rs. 174,000. As a result, Mr. Singh is required to pay Rs. 1,74,000 in LTCG tax.

How to save capital gains on your property

  1. Setting off all of your capital gain losses is one of the best strategies to reduce your capital gains tax. You can balance your capital gains profits and losses, but you need to remember that your losses must trace back in time. Additionally, you can only put your long-term losses against long-term gains and your short-term losses solely against short-term gains. If you agree to carry the loss forward for eight years, you can file long-term losses against long-term gains. However, before the deadline, you must also submit your income tax return on time.
  2. Investing in the Capital Gains Account Scheme (CGAS) is one approach to reducing your capital gains tax. This plan is appropriate for people who are unable to purchase a new property before submitting their income tax returns. The investment period for this plan is three years. This enables you to save money in order to buy a home of your own. However, sign up for this programme before submitting your tax returns. You should be aware that only a select group of Indian banks are authorised to let their clients invest in CGAS.
  3. Bond investments made within six months of selling a home and generating gains are one strategy to reduce capital gains tax. In accordance with Section 54EC of the Income Tax Act of 1961, you are free from paying taxes on bond investments. You must keep in mind, though, that you must hold onto your investment in these bonds for at least three years. It is advised not to invest for longer than three years because you won’t receive any interest and won’t be able to transfer these bonds to anybody else.

Ways to save on capital gains tax while selling your property

According to Section 54 of the Income Tax Act of 1961, long-term capital gains on the sale of a home are excluded from taxation for individuals and Hindu Undivided Families if:

  1. The capital profits are put toward buying or building a new home.
  2. The old house is sold and the new one is bought either one or two years later.
  3. Three years after the sale of the old house, the new house was built.
  4. There is only one extra dwelling property bought/built.
  5. The property is being purchased or developed inside the boundaries of India.
  6. Three years pass after you take ownership of the new residence before you sell it.
  7. The exemption only applies proportionately if the cost of the new property is less than the proceeds from the sale. In less than six months, the leftover funds may be reinvested pursuant to Section 54EC.

Exemptions of the application of capital gains tax 

Capital gains from the sale of capital assets may result, and under the Income Tax Act, of 1961, these gains may be subject to tax. There are a few capital gains exemptions and deductions available to reduce the tax due on these capital gains. As a result, one must plan benefits while taking into account any legal relief. Allowing deductions is intended to encourage investors to invest their capital gains within a certain time frame in a new capital asset. Subject to a few restrictions, the deduction is possible in relation to the investment made in a new capital asset. In this regard, we shall examine the section-by-section deductions made possible by the Act and the different requirements that must be met in order to make a claim or qualify for the same.

Section 54 (Old asset: Residential Property, New Asset: Residential Property Capital Gains Account Scheme)

Any long-term capital gain from the sale of a residential property, whether it is for personal use or is rented out, is exempt under Section 54 to the degree that it is invested in:

  1. The acquisition of a second residential property during a period of one year or two years following the transfer of the sold property, and/or
  2. Within three years of the property’s transfer or sale, a residential building must be constructed.

As long as the newly acquired or built residential property is not transferred within three years of the date of acquisition. The cost of acquisition of this home property shall be reduced by the amount of capital gain exempt under Section 54 previously if the new property is sold within three years of the date of acquisition for the purpose of computing the capital gains on this transfer. This transfer’s capital gain will always be a short-term capital gain.

As was observed in the case of CIT v T.N. Aravinda Reddy (1979), to reiterate, it is irrelevant how many homes an individual has already purchased in order to claim an exemption under Section 54. By reinvesting the capital gains from the sale of the home in another residential property, he can still make the exemption claim. 

Quantum of deduction available under Section 54 

To the degree that capital gains are used to fund the purchase and/or building of another home, i.e.

  1. The entire capital gain shall be excluded if the capital gains amount is equal to or less than the cost of the new house.
  2. The cost of the new home shall be considered an exemption if the amount of capital gain exceeds the cost of the new home.

The possible number of the purchased house under the exemption provided by Section 54

  1. As was introduced by the Finance Act of 2014, the capital gains exemption is only valid if it is used to fund the building or purchase of a single residential home. Based on how many homes a person already owns, if he utilises the capital gain to build or buy a single residential home, he qualifies for a capital gains exemption.
  2. As an exception to the aforementioned regulation, the capital gains exemption would be permitted even if the investment was made in the acquisition or building of two residential homes in circumstances where the amount of capital gains does not exceed Rs. 2 Crores. However, you may only use this exemption once if you buy two residences for residential use. Once this exemption has been used, it cannot be used again in any other year. Investments should only be used to build or acquire one residential home throughout the remaining years (initiated pursuant to the Finance Act of 2019).
  3. It will be assumed that the property has been purchased by the release when more than one person owns a property and another co-owner or co-owners releases his or her or their respective share or interest in the property in favour of the other co-owner(s). This release also satisfies the requirement of Section 54 with regard to purchasing.

Capital gains account scheme

The capital gains on the transfer of the original house property are taxable in the year in which it was sold, even though Section 54 gives the assessee two years to buy the house property or three years to build the house property. The applicable assessment year’s income tax return for that year must be submitted on or before the deadline for submitting the return. Therefore, the assessee must make a decision regarding the purchase or construction of the residential property by the due date for filing an income tax return, or the capital gain will be taxed.

The Income Tax Act, 1961, offers a substitute in the form of a deposit under the capital gains account scheme to avoid the aforementioned circumstance. Before the due date for filing the income tax return, the assessee must deposit any capital gain funds under the capital gains account scheme that were not used for the purchase or construction of a new home. When claiming the capital gains exemption, the income tax return must include the deposit data, including the date of deposit and the amount deposited. In this scenario, the assessee will be eligible for an exemption on the money previously used for the purchase or construction of the new home.

If the assessee deposits money in the capital gains account scheme but does not use it to buy or build a home within the required time frame, the money will be charged as capital gains for the financial year in which the required three years have passed since the original asset was sold. This will be a long-term capital gain.

Section 54EC (old asset: any asset, new asset: specified bonds)

  1. If the assessee invests the capital gain within six months of the transfer’s due date in long-term specified bonds as announced by the government for a minimum of three years, the gain from the transfer of any long-term capital asset is exempt under Section 54EC.
  2. In the event that the long-term specified asset is transferred or converted into money within three years of the date of acquisition, the amount of capital gain exempt under Section 54EC will be regarded to be the long-term capital gain of the year before the transfer or conversion.
  3. The long-term designated asset will be considered to have been turned into money on the date that the loan or advance was taken by the assessee if he even accepts a loan or advance against it.
  4. The interest rate provided on these specified contracts, which are typically issued by Rural Electrification Corporation Limited (REC) and National Highways Authority of India (NHAI), is approximately 5.25%. Since the interest is not tax-free, tax must also be paid on the interest generated. These bonds aren’t tax-free bonds; they are capital gain bonds. After the lock-in period, the invested principal is no longer subject to taxation, but the interest is still taxable.
  5. The advantage of Section 54EC is only accessible on the sale of land or buildings as of the Financial Year 2018–19 (whether residential or non-residential). Previously, it applied to all assets, but it is now only relevant to land or buildings. Additionally, these bonds must be held for a minimum of 5 years starting in the Financial Year 2018–19.

Quantum of deduction under Section 54EC

  1. If capital gains are invested in the long-term defined assets within six months of the transfer date (up to a maximum of Rs. 50 lakhs), they would be free from tax.
  2. The budget for 2014 additionally included a change to Section 54EC, which states that starting in the following financial year, or AY 15-16, an assessee’s investment in a long-term defined asset made from capital gains from the transfer of one or more original assets cannot exceed Rs. 50 lakhs.

Section 54F (old asset: any asset, new asset: residential house)

If the entire net sales consideration is invested in, any gain that an individual or Hindu Undivided Family (HUF) may realise from the sale of any long-term asset other than the residential property will be completely excluded,

  1. Purchase of one residential property within one year of the transfer date or two years after that date.
  2. Within three years of the transfer date, build one residential home.

If only a portion of the sale consideration is invested and not the entire amount, a proportionate exemption will be granted, meaning,

Amount exempt = Capital gain  X   amount invested

                                                   ————————–

                                                   net sale consideration

In which cases exemptions under Section 54F are not applicable

  1. On the date of transfer of such asset, the assessee does not hold more than one residential house property, excluding the one he purchased in order to qualify for an exemption under Section 54F

(Note: Only if the assessee is requesting an exemption under Section 54F is the restriction on the number of homes already owned applicable. As previously stated, if the assessee is seeking exemption under Section 54, there is no such restriction.)

  1. Within a year of the transfer of the old asset, the assessee purchases any residential property aside from the new asset.
  2. Within three years of the old asset’s purchase date, the assessee constructs any residential home, except the new asset.
  3. A change to Section 54F was also made in Budget 2014, and it took effect in FY 2014–15. Under this change, an investment in a single residential house in India qualifies for the exemption.
  4. Investment in two homes would prevent Section 54F exemption from being granted. In Section 54, but not in Section 54F, you have the option to invest in two homes once in your lifetime.
  5. Prior to the deadline for filing an income tax return, the assessee may also deposit this sum in the capital gains account scheme described in Section 54 above.

How to avoid paying capital gains tax

  1. There are a few methods if you wish to avoid paying capital gains tax. One of the choices is to spend the full profit from the deal to buy a new house. You are not obligated to pay any tax in this situation. However, you have two years to purchase the home. By utilising the gains to build a home within three years, you can also avoid paying taxes. 
  2. If you don’t want to put your winnings into another piece of real estate, you may think about putting them into bonds issued by the NHAI and the RECL for a period of three years. However, you must purchase the bonds within six months of selling your house. However, the annual investment limit for these bonds is Rs. 50 lakhs.
  3. The long-term loss from the sale of any other asset may likewise be offset against the long-term capital gains. As a result, you can cut back on taxes. The only way to avoid paying taxes on short-term capital gains is also the only one. The short-term loss from the sale of assets like stocks, real estate, and other types of assets can be offset against short-term capital gains.

How to save capital gain tax

Capital gains taxes are levied on the proceeds from the sale of capital assets and are determined by the length of time the asset was owned as well as the actual difference between the asset’s purchase and selling price. This tax assessment applies alone if the asset is traded after a certain period of ownership.

Invest in CGAS (Capital Gains Account Scheme)

Another way to reduce capital gains tax on property sales is to invest in the capital gains account scheme. This programme is ideal for people who can’t purchase a brand-new home before completing their income tax returns. It also offers taxpayers a significant amount of relief. 

You have three years to invest in this CGAS programme, during which time you may use the capital gains to purchase or construct a home on your land. Before completing or registering an income tax return, the deposit in this CGAS account must be made, and this investment in the CGAS must then be noted in the tax return. 

Only the specified banks are permitted to open this CGAS account. Additionally, cooperative banks and regional banks are ineligible to open this account. To reduce taxes on capital gains, the deposit in this account can be made either through monthly instalments or a flat sum.

Investing in bonds

You can make additional investments in certain financial assets if you have just traded in your property and wish to reduce your tax burden. Your investment in such financial assets has the potential to protect your laboriously earned capital gains because Section 54EC of the Indian Income Tax Act, 1961, exempts long-term capital gains from taxation.

Within six months of the transfer of the money and the realisation of profits, you must invest the money gained in bonds in order to qualify for this tax break on capital gains. Additionally, a minimum lock-in period of three years must pass once the money is deposited in these bonds.

You will not earn interest and these capital gain bonds will automatically redeem if you keep your money invested in them for a longer period than the three-year lock-in period. You are also not permitted to assign, contract, or transfer these bonds while investing your capital gains from real estate sales.

Set off all capital losses

Again, this is the best strategy to reduce taxes on capital gains from the sale of your property. It permits you to offset any capital gains or earnings against any prior capital losses. However, a short-term capital loss can only be offset by short-term capital profits, and it must date from the earlier date.

Conclusion

Gains from the sale of an investment, such as stocks, bonds, or real estate, are referred to as capital gains. Because capital gains taxes are lower than regular income taxes, investors have an advantage over wage earners. Profits from the sale of a property are known as capital gains. The fact that your capital gains are taxed at a reduced rate is one of the tax advantages of real estate investing. Furthermore, one’s overall tax liability may occasionally be reduced by capital losses. Thus, to sum up, everything discussed above, the subject matter of capital gains tax holds immense importance.

References


Students of Lawsikho courses regularly produce writing assignments and work on practical exercises as a part of their coursework and develop themselves in real-life practical skills.

LawSikho has created a telegram group for exchanging legal knowledge, referrals, and various opportunities. You can click on this link and join:

https://t.me/lawyerscommunity

Follow us on Instagram and subscribe to our YouTube channel for more amazing legal content.

Download Now

Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972

0
Labour

This article is written by HEMA MODI, a second-year student of Pravin Gandhi College of Law, Mumbai and Kishita Gupta, a graduate from the Unitedworld School of Law, Karnavati University, Gandhinagar, graduate. It provides an overview of The Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 and its different provisions, along with landmark judgements.

It has been published by Rachit Garg.

Introduction

We all must have heard the term ‘gratuity’ which means “a sum of money that is paid to an employee at the end of the service.” Well, that doesn’t imply that every employee who leaves employment will receive an amount like that. So, in order to be eligible for the payment of gratuity, the minimum term of employment must be 5 years. In India, this is all governed by the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972. The Payment of Gratuity Act is a genre of statutes in India like the Minimum Wages Act of 1948, which is an extension of labour laws and it lays down the minimum benefits to be provided to the employees. It is a social security enactment providing for the welfare benefits of employees working in industries, companies, and organisations. In this article, the authors have discussed the key provisions of the Act along with the latest amendments.

Scope and objective of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972

The Act lay out its objective to guarantee a standard pattern for gratuity payments to employees across the nation in order to prevent treating employees of organisations with branches in multiple states differently when they may be required to transfer from one state to another due to service requirements.

On August 21, the Act was approved by Parliament, and it became operative on September 16 of that same year. All divisions of the central, state, and local governments, as well as the military and local governing bodies, are subject to the provisions of this Act. If certain requirements are met, private organisations may fall under its jurisdiction. It is a monetary reward given to an employee in appreciation of his work and devotion to the company.

Key provisions of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972

Applicability of the Act

Section 1 of the Act states that the Act extends to the whole of India except in cases of plantations and ports, where the state of Jammu and Kashmir was exempted before 2019, where it was amended to extend to the whole of India.

Further, the Act shall be applicable to the following:

  1. Every manufacturing unit, mine, oil field, plantation, port, and railway firm;
  2. Every business, as defined by any law currently in effect with regard to businesses and premises in a State, where ten or more people are employed or were employed on any day during the previous 12 months;
  3. Any other businesses or groups of businesses where ten or more people are employed or were employed on any day during the previous year, as the Central Government may designate in a notification.

Who is an employee under the Payment of Gratuity Act

An employee is defined in Section 2(e) as any person who is paid wages in an establishment, as defined in Section 1(3) of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972, to perform any manual, supervisory, technical, or clerical work, regardless of whether the terms of the employment are express or implied and regardless of whether the employee holds a managerial or administrative position. But the definition tends to exclude any such individual who occupies a position with the federal or state governments and is subject to another Act or any guidelines governing the payment of gratuities.

There has been a debate on considering teachers as employees. Teachers who impart students’ education were ruled not to be considered employees who avail of gratuity benefits under this Act in the case of Ahmedabad Pvt. Primary Teachers’ Association v. Administrative Officer, LLJ (2004). The Supreme Court asked the legislature to take cognizance and provide the teachers with gratuity benefits through statutes wherever necessary.

Therefore, through the 2009 Amendment Act, the term “employee” has now been expanded to include any person hired to perform any type of labour. As a result, a teacher is considered an employee for purposes of the Act. 

More recently, the Supreme Court, in the case of Independent Schools’ Federation of India (Regd.) v. Union of India (2022), upheld the Payment of Gratuity (Amendment) Act, 2009’s constitutional validity and held that the Amendment aims to bring equality and provide teachers with equitable treatment. It’s difficult to label it as an arbitrary or arrogant activity.

Notably, the aforementioned Amendment Act was introduced to extend the benefit of gratuity to teachers who had previously been denied it by incorporating them into the category of “employee”. The Court ruled that private schools “should not succeed” when asserting a vested right resulting from a flaw because acceptance would be at the expense of the teachers, who would lose the intended advantage. The Court upheld the Amendment Act’s legality and ordered private schools to pay employees and teachers within six weeks, along with interest, in accordance with the Act’s provisions. If this is not done, the employees and teachers may file a lawsuit in the appropriate forum to have the payment made in accordance with the Act’s requirements.

Continuous service

According to this Act, continuous service means uninterrupted service during the employment period. This includes leaving due to sickness, accident, layoff, strike, etc. If the interruption is for six months or one year, then the employee is not entitled to gratuity benefits. They should have worked for at least 190 days in a mine or coalfield-like establishment (where the duration of work is only 6 months) and 240 days in other areas.

Recently, a question arose before the Supreme Court of India about whether the services provided by the employees were regularised or not and whether they were entitled to a gratuity amount or not in the case of Netram Sahu v. State of Chhattisgarh (2018). The appellant employee had, in all, rendered 25 years and 3 months of service (22 years and 1 month as a daily wager and 3 years and 2 months as a regular work charge employee). However, the Appellant was not paid the gratuity amount by the State after his retirement because, out of the total period of 25 years of his service, he worked 22 years as a daily wager and only 3 years as a regular employee. The Supreme Court of India held that the state should release the gratuity amount to the employee because the Appellant had actually rendered the service for a period of 25 years. Because the services were regularised, the appellant was entitled to claim their benefit for a period of 25 years, regardless of the post and the capacity in which he worked for 22 years. This shows that whether the services were regularised or not, it is of no significance to the continuous service under the said Act. 

The different exceptions that qualify for an employee’s continuous service are described in Section 2A of the Act.

In a recent judgement, Amreli Nagarpalika v. Manubhai Ebhalbhai Dhandhal (2022), the Gujarat High Court held that after it has been regularised and taken into account for the purpose of awarding a pension, an employee is eligible for gratuity for the entire duration of continuous service. In the current case, there was no argument made to the controlling authority that the respondent had not provided continuous service as required by Section 2A of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972.

Controlling authority

The controlling authority shall be appointed by the appropriate government for the proper administration of this Act as per Section 3. The government may also appoint different controlling authorities for different areas. 

Payment of gratuity

According to Section 4 of the Act, an employee is entitled to the payment of gratuity if they have rendered five years of continuous service upon their superannuation, retirement, resignation, disablement, or death. However, five years of continuous service are not mandatory in cases where the termination is due to death or disability. A retired person is also entitled to a gratuity amount along with his pension. This was held by the Supreme Court in the case of Allahabad Bank and others v. All India Allahabad Bank Retired Employees Association (2009), where the Honourable Court held that pensionary benefits may include both pension amount and gratuity amount, but gratuity amount is a must to be paid to the employees.

Further, the Act provides for the services rendered for at least 6 months, where the gratuity amount will be calculated at the rate of fifteen days’ wages based on the rate of wages last drawn by the employee concerned, provided that the amount paid for the overtime work will not be considered.

The amount of gratuity shall not exceed Rs. 10 Lakhs.

When does gratuity become payable

A gratuity must be paid to an employee upon termination of employment if he or she has provided continuous service for five years or more, according to Section 4(1) of the Payment of Gratuity Act of 1972.

(a) It must be upon his retirement, or

(b) Upon his resignation or retirement, or

(c) Upon his demise or disability brought on by an accident or illness.

In Kothari Industrial Corporation v. Appellate Authority (1997), the Andhra Pradesh High Court held that a mere absence from work without a valid excuse does not, for the purposes of this Act, constitute a breach of continuity of service.

To whom the gratuity can be paid

  1. In the first case, the gratuity shall be paid to the employee himself.
  2. If an employee passes away, any gratuity due to him must be paid to his nominee or, if no nominee has been made, to his heirs. 
  3. If either of the above-mentioned parties is a minor, the share of the minor must be deposited with the controlling authority, who will invest it for the minor’s benefit in the bank or other financial institution specified until the minor reaches majority, or, if no nominee has been made, to the employee’s heirs.

What is the threshold limit of gratuity

The employees will benefit from the rise in the gratuity limit from 3.5 lacs to 10 lacs under Section 4(3). The gratuity cap was also enhanced from Rs. 3.5 lac to Rs. 10 lac in Section 10(10) of the Income Tax Act, 1961.

However, as of March 29, 2018, the gratuity limit for individuals covered by the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972, has risen from 10 lacs to 20 lacs through the notification S.O. 1420 (E) dated March 29, 2018.

Forfeiture of gratuity

Section 4(6) lays down two situations in which an individual’s gratuity can be forfeited:

  1. If there has been a termination of service for any act, willful omission or any negligent act by the individual which caused damage to the property of the employer, the gratuity shall be forfeited up to the extend of the damage.
  2. There can be a partial or whole forfeiture of gratuity for riotous and disorderly behaviour, any other act of violence committed by him, or any act of moral turpitude committed by him while acting in the course of his employment.   

In the case of Bharat Gold Mines Ltd. v. Regional Labour Commissioner (1986), it was determined by the Karnataka High Court that, in cases of employee theft involving moral turpitude, gratuity is wholly forfeited in accordance with Section 4(6)(b). In light of this, the employer cannot withhold the employee’s owed gratuity when service has not been terminated for any of the aforementioned reasons.

In the case of Travancore Plywood Industries v. Regional Joint Labour Corporation of Kerala (1996), it was decided that the employee’s gratuity could not be withheld just because the employer’s land had not been abandoned by the employee. Therefore, under Section 4(6) of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972, an employee’s unwillingness to turn over inhabited corporate property is not a sufficient reason to deny gratuity.

According to the Bombay High Court in the case of Air India Ltd. v. the Appellate Authority (1998), gratuities cannot be withheld from departing employees because they did not vacate their service quarters.

The question of the procedure for forfeiting gratuities has also been raised in many cases. The Allahabad High Court held in Hindalco Industries Ltd. v. Appellate Authority and Ors. (2004) that in accordance with Section 4(6)(a) of the Act, the quantum of forfeiture must be determined, necessitating an order, which can only be issued after providing the employee with an opportunity. The Karnataka High Court ruled in Canara Bank v. Appellate Authority (2012) that the decision to forfeit a gratuity may only be made after calculating the loss and giving the employee a chance to be heard. The Gujarat High Court ruled in Union Bank of India v. K.R. Ajwalia (2004) that notice and hearing are necessary steps in the forfeiture of gratuity process. The Madhya Pradesh High Court ruled in Manager, Western Coalfields Ltd. v. Prayag Modi (2018) that an employee’s gratuity may only be withheld in accordance with the Act’s established procedure. The employer does not have unrestricted authority to decide to withhold the gratuity at his whim.

In a recent judgement by the Delhi High Court, Union Bank Of India v. Sh D.C. Chaturvedi (2022), it was observed that the three requirements of notification, quantification, and hearing must all be met, according to the accepted legal view, before a gratuity can be forfeited.

Compulsory insurance

Section 4A of the Act provides compulsory insurance to every employer other than those belonging to the central government or state government through the Life Insurance Corporation or any other company. However, those employers are exempted from this provision who have an established and registered gratuity fund in their company. The government may also make rules for the enforcement of this section as and when necessary. Any violation of this provision by anyone may lead to a penalty.

Power to exempt

Section 5 of the Act provides the power to exempt the appropriate government by notification from having to declare any establishment—a factory, mine, oilfield, plantation, port, railway company, or shopexempt from gratuity if the government is of the opinion that the establishment has favourable benefits, not less than what this Act has been providing. The same law applies to any employee or class of employees. 

Nomination

When to file for nomination

A nomination under Section 6 must be submitted by an employee within 30 days of the end of their first year of employment in order to be considered under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972. This would imply that the statute mandates that an employee submit a nomination within 30 days after completing a year of service. In reality, though, this is not the case. In reality, employers demand that new recruits submit the nomination form when they first join the company. As a result, you can consult your employer if you are unsure about submitting the nomination form.

Who can be nominated

Only “family members” may be nominated by an employee, and only then may anybody else be nominated if there are no “family” members.

According to the Gratuity Act, a male member’s “family” is defined as his wife, children (married or not), dependent parents, dependent parents of his wife, and, if any, the widow and children of any predeceased sons.

For a female employee, the term “family” refers to her spouse, her children (whether they are married or not), her dependent parents, her husband’s dependent parents, and, if any, the widow and any children of her predeceased son.

The Gratuity Act does not provide a female employee with the option to remove her husband and his dependent parents from the list of nominees, in contrast to the Employees’ Provident Fund Scheme (EPF), which does. A 1987 Amendment to the Act removed the possibility of excluding the husband from the definition of family.

Remember that, unlike EPF, gratuity nominations do not end automatically upon marriage. Given that you would gain a spouse, who would then be considered “family,” if you had nominated anyone else (assuming you had no “family”), you would need to submit a new nomination after being married. However, if you designated your dependent parents before getting married, such designation will remain valid after getting married, and your company is required to give gratuity benefits to that individual in the event of your untimely death.

How to nominate

A person’s employer must receive the nomination on Form F on their behalf. If the employee did not have “family” as defined by the Gratuity Act at the time the initial nomination was filed but has since gotten married and had children, a new submission using Form G must be submitted.

Employers should insist that their staff members evaluate their gratuity nomination after getting married. The earlier nomination submitted (i.e., before gaining family) will be rendered invalid once the new submission is made.

Can a will override the beneficiary nomination

The laws governing gratuity payments in the event of an employee’s passing are generally identical to those governing the payment of EPF benefits. It is unlikely that they would be entitled to the proceeds if you will (i.e., bequeath) your EPF proceeds to anybody other than the defined “family” members because that is not what the EPF Scheme contemplates.

When a nomination is legitimately made, the nominee only retains the money on behalf of the employee’s legal heirs; as a result, the nominee is legally obligated to pay the gratuity money in accordance with a will or other succession regulations after receiving it. However, if someone nominates someone who is not “family” (as defined by the Gratuity Act), the nomination will be void, and even if the person is a beneficiary under the will, they will not be eligible to collect the gratuity proceeds.

Forms used for nomination

All types of forms are given under the Payment of Gratuity Rules of 1972.

  1. Form D – Notice for excluding Husband from family. 
  2. Form E – Notice of withdrawal of Notice excluding husband from family. 
  3. Form F – Nomination 
  4. Form G – Fresh nomination.
  5. Form H  – Notification of nomination.

According to this Act, it is necessary for the employee to prescribe the name/names of the nominee soon after completing one year of service. In the case of a family, the nominee should be one among the family members of the employee, and other nominees shall be void. Any alteration or fresh nomination must be conveyed by the employee to the employer who shall keep the same in his safe custody.

Determination of the amount of gratuity

Section 7 of the Act, lays down the rules for the determination of the amount of gratuity. The person entitled to receive the gratuity amount shall send an application in writing to the employer. The employer shall calculate the gratuity amount and provide notice in writing to the concerned employee and the controlling authority. The payment should be made within 30 days from the date it is due to the employee. Failure to pay within the prescribed limit will result in the payment of simple interest. However, if the delayed payment is because of the employee, then the employer is not entitled to pay the simple interest.

In the landmark case of Y.K. Singla v. Punjab National Bank (2012), the highest Court in India, the Supreme Court had to decide whether an employee whose gratuity has been withheld under Regulation 46 of the Punjab National Bank (Employees) Pension Regulations is entitled to get interest because of the delay after the completion of the proceeding? The Court held that even though the provisions of the 1995 Regulations are silent on the issue of payment of interest, the appellant would be entitled to interest, on account of delayed payment under the Payment of Gratuity Act for the benefit of the employee.

The disputes arising between the employee and employer shall be referred to the controlling authority, and the proceedings for their resolution presided over by the controlling authority shall be considered judicial proceedings. The controlling authority has the authority to enforce the presence of any person and examine his oath, order the production of relevant documents, and issue commissions for the examination of witnesses if required. After due inquiry and giving the parties a reasonable opportunity to be heard, the controlling authority may determine the matters and pass appropriate orders. The aggrieved party can apply for appeals to the government. 

Calculation of gratuity

The elements that are used to determine the gratuity amount are listed below. The amount also depends on how long an individual has worked for the organisation and when he was last paid.

Gratuity = Number of years * last drawn salary *15/26

For instance, if XYZ has been employed by a company for 20 years and received Rs. 25,000 as his most recent basic plus DA amount,

For XYZ, the gratuity amount is equal to 20 * 25,000 * 15/26, or Rs. 2,88,461.54.

However, a company has the option of giving an employee a larger gratuity. Additionally, for the number of months in the most recent employment year, everything over six months is rounded up to the next number, and anything under six months is rounded down to the previous lower number.

Employees not covered under the Act

The organisation may pay gratuities even if they are not covered by the Act. But for each year that has passed, a person’s half-monthly wage is used to determine how much gratuity they will receive. The pay package consists of a base salary, a commission (depending on sales), and a depreciation allowance.

For employees who are not covered by the Gratuity Act, the following formula is taken into account while calculating the gratuity amount:

(15 * last drawn salary amount * length of service) / 30 equals the gratuity amount.

For instance, if you have worked for a company for 10 years and 8 months and make Rs. 50,000, the gratuity amount is determined as follows:

Gratuity: (15 * 50,000 * 11) / 30 equals Rs. 2.75 lakh.

An employee’s tenure is counted as one year for purposes of calculation. The previous number of completed years is taken into account if the number of months worked in the most recent year is less than six months. However, the year is regarded as a full year for the purposes of calculation if the number of months completed in the most recent year of service is greater than six months. Therefore, 11 years have been determined to be the working period. The number of years of service would have been 10 years only if the service duration had been 10 years and 4 months (or anything less than 6 months).

Gratuity in case of death of an employee

Service tenure of the employee Gratuity payable upon the death
> a year 2 * basis salary of the employee
More than or equal to 1 year but less than 5 years 6 * basis salary of the employee
More than or equal to 5 years but less than 11 years 12 * basis salary of the employee
More than or equal to 11 years but less than 20 years 20 * basis salary of the employee
More than or equal to 20 years For each full six-month term, half of the base salary. It is limited to a maximum of 33 times the basic salary, though.

Inspectors appointed for the purpose of the Payment of Gratuity Act and their powers

The government may appoint an inspector or inspectors who are deemed to be public servants under Section 21 of the Indian Penal Code for the purpose of ascertaining whether any of the provisions of this Act are being violated or not complied with and taking the necessary measures to ensure the fulfilment of all the provisions of this Act.

Two additional provisions, Section 7-A and Section 7-B, dealing with the appointment of inspectors for the purposes of the Act and their powers, have been added to the original Act by the Payment of Gratuity (Amendment) Act, 1984.

The government, by notification, appoints an inspector for specific areas by designating them in particular. 

The appointed inspector has certain powers to ascertain whether the provisions of the Act are well complied with. These powers are as follows:

  1. The inspector can demand that an employer provide whatever information that he may deem necessary.
  2. He can enter and inspect the premises that come under the Act to examine the records or necessary documents.
  3. He also has a right to inspect the employees on the premises.
  4. If he believes that any offence has been committed, then he may also make copies of the necessary documents that he examined.
  5. The individuals are bound to furnish the relevant documents to the inspectors as per the relevant laws such as Sections 175 and 176 of the Indian Penal Code and Section 94 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.

Recovery of Gratuity

If the employer delays the payment of the gratuity amount under the prescribed time limit, then the controlling authority shall issue the certificate to the collector on behalf of the aggrieved party and recover the amount, including the compound interest decided by the central government, and pay the same to the person. However, these provisions are subject to two conditions, as mentioned in Section 8:

The controlling authority should give the employer a reasonable opportunity to show the cause of such an Act.

The amount of interest to be paid should not exceed the amount of gratuity under this Act.

Penalties under the Payment of Gratuity Act

Violation of the provisions of the Act shall entail certain penalties, as stated in Section 9. They are:

  1. To avoid any payment, if someone makes a false representation or false statement, it shall be punishable with imprisonment for 6 months or a fine up to Rs. 10,000 or both.
  2. Failure to comply with the provisions of this Act shall be punishable by a minimum of 3 months, which may extend up to 1 year, or a fine of Rs. 10,000, which may extend up to Rs. 20,000.
  3. Non-payment of gratuity under the Act will lead to an offence, and the employer shall be punishable with imprisonment for at least 6 months, which may extend up to 2 years unless the court provides a sufficient reason for less payment.

Exemption of employer from liability 

An employer, if charged with any offence punishable under this Act, shall be exempt from any liability under Section 10 if he provides sufficient reasons for his conduct of the act or some other person doing that act without his knowledge. The other person, if found guilty, will be charged with the same punishment as an employer will be.

The employer has to prove the following to the court in order to get exempted from liability:

  1. To prove that the other person committed the alleged offence without his knowledge, agreement, or connivance, and
  2. To prove that he exercised due diligence in enforcing the execution of this Act.

Cognizance of offences as per the Payment of Gratuity Act

As per Section 11, the court cannot take cognizance of the offences punishable under this Act unless the amount of gratuity to be paid has not been paid or recovered within 6 months from the expiration of the prescribed time. In such cases, the government shall authorise the controlling authority to make a complaint where the authority has to make a complaint to the metropolitan magistrate or judicial magistrate of first class within 15 days of the authorisation. 

Protection of action taken in good faith

The controlling authority shall not be subject to any legal proceeding if the acts done by him were done in good faith or under any rule or order under Section 12 of the Act.

Protection of gratuity

As per Section 13, no exempted gratuity that is payable under this Act to the employee by the employer shall be liable to the attachment of any order or decree by any court.

Act to override other enactments

As per Section 14, since the Payment of Gratuity Act is complete in itself, this Act has an overriding effect on all provisions, regulations, and statutes relating to gratuity. The landmark case for this provision is the University of Delhi v. Ram Prakash and Ors. (2015), which states that any provision that is more beneficial for the employees should be considered to have an overriding effect.

Power to make rules

The power to make rules under Section 14 of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1927, shall rest with the appropriate government and be declared by notification.

Validation of amendments made in this Act

The rules made have to be presented before both houses of parliament when they are in session. If both houses are in conformity with the annulments or modifications, then they shall be applicable immediately; otherwise, such modifications will have no effect.

2022 Gratuity Rules

On July 1, 2022, the new labour law went into effect for all businesses and organisations. The working hours, Provident Fund, and in-hand salary were decreased in accordance with the new labour law. This law will have the most effect on take-home salaries.

According to the new gratuity rules of 2022, employers must make sure that basic pay makes up 50% of an employee’s CTC (cost to the company) and that employee allowances, house rent, and overtime make up the remaining 50%. Additionally, any additional allowances or exemptions that the corporation grants that go beyond 50% of the CTC will be regarded as compensation.

The law restricts the highest basic pay to 50% of CTC, which raises the required gratuity bonus for employees. Based on a significant wage basis that comprises basic pay and allowances, the gratuity amount will be decided.

Further, the new rules state that when an employee works overtime, which is defined as working for 15 minutes or more, they are paid. The work capacity is capped at 48 hours, according to the government.

Tax calculation of gratuity after the latest rules

As part of their remuneration package, salaried workers are entitled to gratuities. The Payment of Gratuity Act of 1972 regulates the payment of gratuities, which are defined benefits given to employees in a lump sum upon retirement. It resembles a thank-you present given to employees as a parting gesture.

When a person has worked for an organisation for five years in a row, they are eligible for a gratuity payout. As a result, gratuity may be paid at the time of retirement or termination or to the employee’s legitimate heir in the event of death. However, the 5-year continuous rule condition is not required in cases of an employee’s death.

The Centre recently passed an amendment in 2019 that raised the gratuity cap. Since Section 10(10) of the Income Tax Act raised the previous limit of Rs 10 lakh, it is now tax-exempt up to Rs 20 lakh. The exemption limit of Rs 20 lakh will be applicable to employees in the event of retirement, death, resignation, or disability on or after March 29, 2018, according to CBDT Notification No. S.O. 1213(E), dated March 8, 2019.

According to Section 10(10) of the Income Tax Act, both government and non-government employees are entirely liable for any gratuities they receive while working. Any gratuity received during work is fully taxable in the hands of the employee. However, the government employees, the Centre, or the state, are exempt from paying tax on the gratuity amount received by the government. However, statutory corporations are not exempted. Employees who get a death-cumulative-retirement gratuity, however, can be divided into three groups. Government employees, those protected by the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972, and other employees are all included in this division.

If someone wants to know more about how to calculate income taxes in India, they can click here.

Conclusion 

The Payment of Gratuity Act, 1927, is a welfare statute provided for the welfare of the employees, who are the backbone of any organisation, company, or startup. The gratuity amount encourages the employee to work efficiently and improve productivity. Recently, by the Payment of Gratuity (Amendment) Act, 2018, the central government has tried to promote social welfare by providing leverage to female employees who are on maternity leave from ‘twelve weeks’ to ‘twenty six weeks.’ 

However, the scope of this Act is limited to large-scale companies or organisations and is not applicable to organisations where the number of employees is less than 10. Yet, the Act in its entirety is complete, and therefore it overrides other Acts and statutes in relation to gratuity. The only need of the hour is to change or modify the implementation of the Act as this Act is still not followed by many companies or corporations.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Am I entitled to a gratuity if I leave a company after 4.5 years of employment?

No, in order to receive a gratuity, you must work for a company for at least 5 years. According to a Madras High Court decision, you are eligible for gratuity if you have served 240 days in your fifth year of employment. It is better to inquire about this with your company’s HR department. However, even if they have not yet served for five years if someone passes away while still on the job, the gratuity sum will be paid to their legal heir. Additionally, a nominee’s or heir’s inheritance won’t be taxed.

Is the maximum gratuity I may earn capped?

Yes. Regardless of how many years you have worked there, a company cannot pay you a gratuity of more than Rs. 10 lakh. This restriction also applies to any gratuities you may get from several employers throughout the course of your career. If your employer wants to give you a bonus or ex-gratia payment, they may do so.

What are the new gratuity policies for employees in the private sector?

Employers are required to increase employees’ base salaries by 50% in order to comply with the new gratuity legislation. The employer’s payment on manpower gratuity, which is given to workers who have been employed by a company for more than five years, will grow if the allowance is limited to 50% of the total income.

How to report non-payment of gratuity?

When filing a complaint about not receiving gratuities, remember the following:

  1. The Payment of Gratuity Act of 1972’s Section 3 mandates that a controlling authority is responsible for handling the situation. It is allowed to arbitrate issues involving the non-payment of gratuities, according to this Section;
  2. The controlling authority provides forms that must be completed in order for both the employer and the employee to appear at the hearing on the specified date and location.
  3. The authority will continue with the employee’s hearing if the employer is not present;
  4. The employee’s claim will be rejected if they fail to show up.

References


Students of Lawsikho courses regularly produce writing assignments and work on practical exercises as a part of their coursework and develop themselves in real-life practical skills.

LawSikho has created a telegram group for exchanging legal knowledge, referrals, and various opportunities. You can click on this link and join:

https://t.me/lawyerscommunity

Follow us on Instagram and subscribe to our YouTube channel for more amazing legal content.

 

Download Now

Factories Act, 1948

0

This article is written by Michael Shriney from the Sathyabama Institute of Science and Technology. This article discusses the Factories Act of 1948. The Act defines various terms and definitions used in a factory, as well as the responsibilities of various authorities and penalties for violating the Act.

This article has been published by Sneha Mahawar

Table of Contents

Introduction

The Factories Act of 1948 was enacted to protect the welfare of workers in a factory by regulating employment conditions, working conditions, the working environment, and other welfare requirements of specific industries. The Court held in Ravi Shankar Sharma v. State of Rajasthan (1993) that the Factory Act is social legislation that covers the health, safety, welfare, and other aspects of factory workers. The Factories Act lays out guidelines and safety measures for using machinery, and with its strict compliance, it also provides owners with instructions. When factory workers were taken advantage of and exploited by paying them low wages, the Factories Act was passed. 

A factory is a building or group of buildings where people work with machinery to make goods. The primary goal of the Factories Act is to safeguard employees in a factory from industrial and occupational risks. This Act gives the owner or occupier of a factory a particular responsibility to secure and protect employees from employment in conditions harmful to their health and safety in order to safeguard workers. It is stated in the Act that the purpose of the Factories Act is to amend and consolidate the legal framework governing factory labour. The Bhopal gas tragedy case (1984) raised public awareness of factory pollution and risks, necessitating government action to allow legislation amendments.

The article is described as follows: history, objectives, some key terminology and definitions in their most basic form, application to the Factories Act, penalties for violation of the Act, facilities supplied to employees in a factory, and finally, certain case laws and new amendments to the Act. 

History of Factories Act, 1948

Evolution of factories and industries

The Factory Act has a history that goes back more than a century. Modern industrialization was introduced to India over a century after it began in the United Kingdom. The first cotton textile factory was established in Bombay in 1854. By 1870, a huge number of industries had been constructed in Bombay, Nagpur, Kanpur, and Madras. In Bihar, the first iron and steel works were established in 1873. Jute spinning mills were established at Rishra around 1855. In 1881, Bengal had 5000 power looms in operation. During the 1870s, Bally paper mills were created at Hooghly and many other tanning and leather factories were established in Kanpur, resulting in the development of factory establishments in India. The early employment of women and children, the length of the working hours, and the hazardous and unhygienic working conditions brought issues and crises to India, and due to these scenarios, legislation was established for all factories and industries. The necessity for protective labour legislation to combat working conditions, particularly for women and children, was recognised as early as 1850, but the British government did very little. The Bara Bazar organisation was founded in 1878 by Sasipad Bannerjee to promote the welfare of jute mill employees. There were strikes in 1877 at Nagpur Empress Mill, which are recorded. The production methods were changed throughout the industrial revolution that occurred in England between 1760 and 1820. The development of several mechanical innovations began, such as the steam engine, which gave humans the capability to drive powerful machines.

Factory Act of 1881

In 1875, a committee was established to look into the working conditions of Indian employees working in a factory. The first Factory Act was passed in 1881, under Lord Ripon’s leadership. The Factory Act is a central body of legislation in India. This Act was based on the terms of the Factory Act of Great Britain, which was enacted in 1937. Local governments had the power under the Factory Act of 1881 to enact rules governing the implementation of the Act’s provisions to control the employment of children, the fencing of machinery, the responsibility to notify factory workers when accidents occur, and other occupations in a factory. This Bill (1881) was amended by the Council and passed on the first day of July 1881, after receiving approval from the Viceroy. The Act was immediately codified as the Indian Factories Act of 1881. This Act was applied to the entire of British India. The Act governs the working conditions of the workforce by establishing several laws relevant to workers’ health, safety, working circumstances, and hazardous processes. If any of the Factory Act’s principles are violated, there are various penalty procedures. 

The Factory Act of 1881 included protective labour laws. The Factory Act of 1881 was the result of the efforts of philanthropic individuals, social activists in India, and Lancashire manufacturers in Great Britain. Narayan Meghaji Lokhandey, a follower of Mahatma Jyotiba Phule, was the country’s first labour leader. He worked as a storekeeper at a textile mill and spent his whole life advancing the interests of the labour movement. A memorandum signed by 5300 employees was also given by him to the Factory Commission, which was formed in 1884. The Indian government appointed the factory commission in 1890.

Important provisions of the 1881 Act

The important provisions of the 1881 Act are as follows:

  1. Children under the age of seven are not allowed to work, and they cannot work two jobs on the same day. 
  2. The working hours for children were nine hours per day. 
  3. Four holidays must be given to children each month. 
  4. Intervals must be provided to take a rest. 
  5. Care must be taken when handling machinery’s dangerous parts fence.
  6. Accidents in a factory or industry must be reported. 
  7. The Act was applicable to factories with mechanical power and 100 or more employees.

Since the Factory Act of 1881 was not enough and did not cover all aspects of the Act, there was a further amendment to the Act called the Factory Act of 1891.

Factory Act of 1891

Later, in 1885, a Factory Commission was established. In 1891, a Royal Commission on Labour was created, and it was enforced in 1892. The Act was amended, known as the Factories Act of 1891. This amendment Act of 1891 placed certain restrictions on the working hours of the factory.

Important provisions of the 1891 Act

The important provisions of the 1891 Act are as follows:

  • Registration of a factory with 50 or more employees. 
  • Local governments were obliged to report activities that employed even 20 employees in a factory. 
  • The employment of children under the age of nine was prohibited. 
  • In the case of children aged 9 to 14, seven hours of work were given.
  • In the case of women, eleven hours of work were given with a 1.5-hour break per day.
  • Women and children were not permitted to work between the hours of 8 p.m. and 8 a.m.
  • All employees must be offered weekly holidays.
  • A rest interval of at least 0.5 hours must be provided.
  • Provincial governments are empowered to enact sanitation and comfort rules.

Factory Act of 1948

The Factory (Amendment) Act of 1948 played an effective and more important role in improving India. A five-year plan was developed during the Interim Congress Regime to improve certain labour conditions in India, and it also referred to the Factory Act of 1934, the Great Britain Factory Act, and the most recent ILO Convention in matters of safety, health and welfare, working hours, industrial hygiene, medical examination of young people, and submissions of factory building plans. The first effort at cooperation between the government, employers, and workers with respect to labour took place at the conference in 1942. As a result, after Conference 1942, a Plenary Tripartite Conference and a Standing Labour Committee were established to provide the government with labour-related advice. This led to the submission of legislative measures, including the drafted bill. The factories bill was proposed on January 30, 1948, and it was approved by the Constituent Assembly on August 28, 1948. It also received the Governor-General of India’s approval on September 23, 1948, and it became effective on April 1, 1949.

The Factory Act of 1948 is longer and more exhaustive than the previous amendment, and it primarily focuses on health, safety, the welfare of factory workers, working hours, the minimum age to work, leave with pay, etc. The industry is a consistent and systematic activity that organises commerce. A factory is a place where certain operations take place. The Factories Act of 1948 controls the daily operations that take place in an enterprise. This includes Jammu and Kashmir as well as the whole of India.

The Act was then amended in 1891, 1911, 1922, 1934, 1948, 1976, and 1987. The Factories Act’s exclusive amendment was in 1948. 

Salient features of Factories Act, 1948

The important features of the 1948 Act are as follows:

  • The word “factory” has been expanded by the Factories (Amendment) Act of 1976 to include contract labour when determining whether a factory has a maximum of 10 or 20 employees.
  • The Act increased the minimum age for children to work in workplaces from 12 to 14 and reduced their daily working hours from 5 to 4 and a half.
  • The Act forbids women and children from working in factories from 7 p.m. to 6 a.m.
  • The difference between a seasonal and non-seasonal factory has been abolished by the Act.
  • The Act, which has provisions for factory registration and licencing.
  • The state government is required to make sure that all factories are registered and also have valid licences that are renewed from time to time.
  • The Act gives state governments the authority to enact rules and regulations that ask for management and employee association for the benefit of employees.
  • The state government has the authority to apply the Act’s requirements to any establishment, regardless of the number of employees inside and regardless of whether the establishment engages in manufacturing operations.
  • In Rabindra Agarwal v. State of Jharkhand (2010), the Jharkhand High Court held that the Factories Act, special legislation would prevail over the Indian Penal Code

Objectives of Factories Act, 1948

The important objectives of the 1948 Act are as follows:

  • The major goal of the Factories Act of 1948 is to establish adequate safety measures and to enhance the health and welfare of workers employed in a factory. The Act also protects workers from various industrial and occupational hazards.
    • Heath: According to the Act, all factories must be kept clean, and all essential safeguards must be taken to safeguard the health of workers. The factory must have a sufficient drainage system, adequate lighting, ventilation, temperature, etc.  There must be clean water supplies. Separate restrooms and urinals must be built in convenient locations for males and females. These must be freely accessible to employees and kept clean.
    • Safety: The Act requires that machines be properly fenced; that no young adults work on any dangerous machines in enclosed places, and also that appropriate manholes be provided so that employees may escape in an emergency. 
    • Welfare: The Act specifies that appropriate and suitable washing facilities for workers must be provided and maintained in every factory. There must be storage and drying facilities, as well as sitting areas, first-aid equipment, shelters, restrooms and lunch rooms.
  • The Act also imposes some restrictions on the employment of women, small children, and teenagers, such as working hours, intervals, holidays, etc., as well as on annual leave with pay, etc.
    • Working hours: The Act sets working hours for all workers, and no adult worker must be permitted to work in a workplace for more than 48 hours per week. Weekly holidays need to be granted.
  • The Act also imposes specific restrictions on owners, occupiers, or the manufacturer’s head in order to safeguard employees and ensure their health and safety precautions.
  • The Act protects workers from exploitation and improves working conditions and the environment within factory premises.
    • Penalties: The Act also specifies specific rules created with provisions under the Act, and written orders that are violated. It is an offence, and penalties will be imposed, imprisonment for up to a year; a fine of up to one lakh rupees; or both fine and imprisonment.  Any employee who misuses equipment related to the welfare, safety, and health of other employees, or those connected to the performance of his duties, suffers a Rs.500 fine.

Application of the Factories Act,1948

The important applications of the 1948 Act are as follows:

  • The Act also applies to the whole country of India, including Jammu and Kashmir, and covers all manufacturing processes and premises that fall under the definition of a factory as defined in Section 2(m) of the Act. It also applies to factories owned by the central or state governments, as defined in Section 116 of the Act.
  • The Act is applied and limited to factories that use power and employ 10 or more people on any working day in the preceding 12 months.
  • The Act is applied and limited to factories that do not use power and employ 20 or more people on any working day in the preceding 12 months.
  • The Act is also covered under Section 85 of the Factories Act by the state governments or Union Territories.

Definitions under the Factories Act, 1948

The important definitions under the 1948 Act are as follows:

Adult and child: An adult is defined as someone who has attained the age of eighteen, as defined in Section 2(a) of the Act.

A child is someone who has not attained the age of fifteen, as defined in Section 2(c) of the Act.

Adolescent: Adolescent is defined in Section 2(b) of the Act. An adolescent is defined as someone who has attained the age of fifteen but has not yet attained the age of eighteen. 

Calendar year: The calendar year is defined in Section 2(bb) of the Act. A calendar year is a period of twelve months commencing on January 1st of any year. 

Competent person: A competent person is defined in Section 2(ca) of the Act. A competent person is someone or a group of individuals who have been approved by the Chief Inspector to conduct tests, examinations, and inspections that must be conducted in a plant. He/she is someone who has the necessary knowledge and experience to handle the complexity of the issue. 

Hazardous process:  Hazardous process is defined in Section 2(cb) of the Act. A hazardous process is defined as any process or activity related to the industry that requires special care of raw materials that are used in it, intermediate or finished products, by-products, wastes, or effluents that would cause material impairment to the health of those engaged in or connected with it or that result in polluting the environment. 

Machinery: Machinery is defined in Section 2(j) of the Act. The term covers prime movers, transmission machinery, and any other equipment and appliances that produce, transform, transmit, or apply power. 

Power: Power is defined in Section 2(g) of the Act. Power is defined as any type of mechanically transmitted energy that is not created by a human or animal agency.

Week: Week is defined in Section 2(f) of the Act.  A week is defined as a seven-day period beginning at midnight on Saturday night or other nights that have been approved in writing for a specific area by the Chief Inspector of Factories. 

Day: Day is defined in Section 2(e) of the Act. A day is defined as a 24-hour period beginning at midnight.

Young person: Young person is defined in Section 2(d) of the Act. A young person is defined as a child or an adolescent. 

Factory: The definition of a factory is specified in Section 2(m) of the Factories Act 1948. A factory is any premises, where it has certain limits and boundaries-

  • If a manufacturing process is regularly carried out in any portion of the premises with the use of power and with ten or more workers now engaged in such activity or were engaged in such work on any day during the previous twelve months; or
  • If any element of a manufacturing process is performed inside the premises without the use of power and is regularly performed with twenty or more employees working or having worked there on any given day within the previous twelve months.

Manufacturing process: The manufacturing process definition is specified under Section 2(k). The term “manufacturing process” refers to any process for: 

  • Generating, altering, repairing, ornamenting, finishing, packing, oiling, washing, cleaning, demolishing, or otherwise treating or adapting any article or; 
  • A substance in preparation for use, sale, transportation, delivery, or disposal or;
  • Producing, transforming, or transmitting energy or;
  • Creating type for printing, letterpress printing, lithography, bookbinding, or any other similar process or;
  • Constructing, reconstructing, repairing, refitting, finishing, or breaking up ships or vessels, etc. (as defined by the 1976 Amendment Act);
  • Preserving or storing any item in cold storage.

Worker: The worker definition is specified under Section 2(l). A worker is someone who performs any job associated with a manufacturing process, whether they are employed directly or indirectly through an agency, a contractor, or any other means. This helps to maintain any equipment or facilities utilised in the manufacturing process. The worker may be hired with or without the principal employer’s knowledge and with or without compensation. 

Important provisions in the Factories Act, 1948

Getting approval, licencing and registration of factories (Section 6)

  • The state government shall make rules that require formal submission of plans of any category or description of factories, as well as the site on which the factory is located, for construction or extension must be submitted to the chief inspector or the state government.
  • This Section requires the registration and licencing of factories, as well as the payment of fees for such registration and licencing, as well as the renewal of licences.
  • No licence is issued or renewed unless the occupier gives notice to the chief inspector.
  • If the state government refuses to grant permission to the site or construction of a factory, then within 30 days of the refusal, the applicant can appeal to the central government.

Labour and welfare

The word ‘labour welfare’ refers to the services offered to employees within as well as outside the factory, such as canteens, restrooms, recreation areas, housing, and any other amenities that support employee well-being. States that take welfare measures care about the overall well-being and productivity of their workforce. Early on in the industrialization process, social programmes for manufacturing workers did not receive enough priority. In the past, industrial labour conditions in India were terrible. Due to a growth in industrial activity in the latter part of the twenty-first century, several attempts were made to improve the working conditions of the workforce through the recommendations of the Royal Commission.

After gaining knowledge about the deficiencies and limitations of the previous Act, the Factories Act of 1948 was amended. The definition of ‘factory’ was expanded to encompass any industrial facility employing 10 or more people that uses power or any industrial establishment employing more than 20 people that uses no power, which was a significant development. 

Other significant amendments included-

  • Raising the minimum age of children who can work from 12 to 14 years old.
  • Reducing the number of hours a child can work from five to four and a half.
  • Preventing the kids from working between the hours of 7 p.m. and 6 a.m.
  • The health, safety, and well-being of all types of employees are given particular attention.

Welfare measures

The three main components of welfare measures are occupational health care, appropriate working hours, and appropriate remuneration. It speaks of a person’s complete health, including their physical, mental, moral, and emotional states. The goal of welfare measures is to integrate the socio-psychological demands of the workforce, the particular technological requirements, the organisational structure and procedures, and the current socio-cultural environment. It fosters a culture of work dedication in enterprises and society at large, ensuring increased employee happiness and productivity.

Washing facilities (Section 42)

  • All factories should supply and maintain enough appropriate washing facilities for the use of the employees.
  • For male and female employees, separate, well-screened facilities must be provided; these facilities also need to be easily accessible and maintained clean.
  • The standards for appropriate and suitable facilities for washing must be set by the state government.

Facilities for storing and drying clothing (Section 43)

  • The state government has a specific authority. It specifies that the state government has the authority to give instructions to the manufacturers regarding where to store the worker’s clothing.
  • They can also provide them with instructions on how to dry the workers’ clothes. It refers to the circumstance in which workers are not dressed for work.

Facilities for sitting (Section 44)

  • All factories should provide and maintain seating arrangements in appropriate areas for all workers who are required to work in a standing position in order to take advantage of any chances for rest that may arise throughout the course of the job.
  • According to the chief inspector, workers in any factory involved in a certain manufacturing process or working in a specific room are able to perform their work effectively while seated.

First aid appliance (Section 45)

  • All factories must have first aid kits, appliances, or cupboards stocked with the required supplies during all working hours, and they must be easily accessible for all manufacturing employees to access. Accordingly, there must be more first aid boxes or cupboards than the usual ratio of one for every 150 industrial employees, which must be fewer than that.
  • The first aid box or cupboard should only include the recommended supplies.
  • Throughout the factory’s operating hours, each first aid box or cupboard should be kept under the supervision of a specific person who is accountable for it on a separate basis and must be readily available at all times during the working hours of the factory.

Canteen (Section 46)

  • A canteen must be provided and kept up by the occupier for the benefit of the workers in any specified factory where more than 250 people are usually employed, according to rules that the state government may set.
  • Food must be served, and prices must be established for it.

Shelters, restrooms and lunch rooms (Section 47)

  • Every factory with more than 150 employees must have appropriate and suitable restrooms or shelters and a lunchroom with drinking water where employees can eat food they have brought with them and that is kept for their use. If a lunchroom is available, employees should stop eating in the work area.
  • The shelters or restrooms need to be well-lighted, ventilated, kept clean, cool, and in good condition.
  • The state government sets the standards.

Creches (Section 48)

  • Every factory with more than 30 female employees must have a suitable room for the use of children under the age of six of such women.
  • Such rooms must be well furnished, well-lighted, and ventilated, and they must be kept clean and hygienic. They must also be under the care of women who have received training in child and infant care.
  • In addition, facilities for washing and changing clothes can be made available for the care of the children of female workers.
  • Any factory may be forced to provide free milk, refreshments, or both to such children.
  • Small children can be fed by their mothers in any industry at necessary intervals.

Health

Sections 11-20 of Chapter III of the Act deal with the Health of the Factories Act, 1948.

Cleanliness (Section 11)

Every factory needs to be kept clean and clear of any effluvia from drains, latrines, or other annoyances. In particular: 

  • Dirt must be cleaned daily from floors, benches, staircases, and passages by sweeping or by another method, and it must be properly disposed of.
  • The floor should be disinfectant-washed at least once a week.
  • During the manufacturing process, the floor becomes moist; this must be drained via drainage.

Disposal of wastes and effluents (Section 12)

Every factory has to have a method in place for treating wastes and effluents produced by the manufacturing process they use.

Ventilation and temperature (Section 13)

  • In order to ensure worker comfort and prevent health problems, sufficient ventilation must be created for the circulation of air in a factory, which should be maintained at a specific temperature.
  • Walls and roofing should be made of a material that is intended for a particular temperature that shouldn’t go over as much as possible.
  • Certain precautions must be taken to protect the employees in facilities where the manufacturing process requires extremely high or low temperatures.

Dust and fume (Section 14)

  • Every factory has to have efficient measures to remove or prevent any dust, fumes, or other impurities that might harm or offend the employees employed and cause inhalation and buildup in any workroom.
  • No factory may operate an internal combustion engine unless the exhaust is directed outside, and no other internal combustion engine may be used. Additionally, precautions must be made to avoid the buildup of fumes that might endanger the health of any employees inside the room.

Overcrowding (Section 16)

  • There should be no overcrowding in factories that might harm the health of the workers.
  • All employees must have ample space in a room to work in the building.

Lighting (Section 17)

  • Every area of a factory where employees are employed must have adequate natural, artificial, or both types of lighting installed and maintained.
  • All glass windows and skylights that provide lighting for the workroom in factories must be kept clean on the inside and outside.
  • The production of shadows should not cause eye strain during any manufacturing process, and all factories must have preventative measures that should not cause glare from the source of light or via reflection from a smooth or polished surface.

Drinking (Section 18)

  • All factories must have the appropriate installations in place, and maintain convenient locations with an adequate supply of clean drinking water.
  • The distance between any drinking water and any washing area, urinal, latrine, spittoon, open drain carrying sullage or effluent, or another source of contamination in the factory must be 6 metres unless the chief inspector approves a shorter distance in writing. The labelling must be legible and in a language that workers could understand.
  • In all factories with more than 250 regular employees, there needs to be a suitable method for providing cold drinking water during hot weather.

Latrines and urinals (Section 19)

  • All factories should have enough restrooms, and urinal accommodations of the required types must be offered in a location that is convenient and always accessible to workers.
  • Male and female employees must have separate enclosed rooms.
  • These locations must be thoroughly cleaned, kept in a hygienic state, and have sufficient lighting and ventilation.
  • Sweepers must be used to maintain latrines, urinals, and washing facilities clean.

Spittoons (Section 20)

  • All factories must have spittoons in easily accessible locations, and they must be kept clean and hygienic.
  • The state government specifies the number of spittoons that must be given, their placement in any factory, as well as their maintenance in a clean and hygienic manner.
  • Except for spittoons designed, for this reason, no one should spit within the premises of a factory. A notice must be posted if any violations occur, with a fine of five rupees.

Safety

Safety is covered in Chapter IV of the Act and is covered in Sections 21–41 of the Factories Act, 1948.

  • Employment of young persons on dangerous machines (Section 23): 

No young person is permitted to operate dangerous machines unless he has been adequately taught the hazards associated with the machine and the measures to be taken, and has received suitable training in working at the machine or adequate supervision by a person who has complete knowledge and experience of the equipment.

  • Prohibition of employment of women and children near cotton openers (Section 27): 

Women and children are not permitted to work in any area of a cotton pressing facility while a cotton opener is in operation. Women and children may be employed on the side of the partition where the feed-end is located if the inspector so specifies.

  • Hoists and lifts (Section 28):
    • Every hoist and lift must be of strong mechanical structure, enough strength, and sound material. They also need to be regularly maintained, completely checked by a qualified person at least once every six months, and a register kept for the mandatory exams.
    • A cage that is properly designed and installed must enclose all hoist and lift ways to prevent people from being trapped between any of the equipment.
    • No larger load should be carried; the maximum safe operating load must be marked on the hoist or lift.
    • Every hoist or lift gate must have interlocking or another effective system installed to prevent the gate from opening except during landing.
  • Protection of eyes (Section 35):

The state government may require effective screens or appropriate goggles to be provided for the protection of persons employed or in the vicinity of the process during any manufacturing process carried out in any factory that involves risk to the eyes due to exposure to excessive light or injury to the eyes from particles or fragments thrown off during the process.

  • Precautions against dangerous fumes, gases etc (Section 36):

No person shall be required or permitted to enter any chamber, tank, vat, pit, pipe, flue, or other confined space in any factory where any gas, fume, vapour, or dust is present to such a degree as to involve risk to persons being overcome, unless such chamber, tank, vat, pit, pipe, flue, or other confined space is provided with an adequate manhole or other effective means of egress.

  • Explosive or inflammable dust, gas etc (Section 37):
    • Any factory involved in manufacturing processes that produce dust, gas, fume, or vapour of a nature that could explode on ignition must take all reasonably practicable precautions to prevent any explosion through
    • The effective enclosure of the plant or machinery.
    • The removal or prevention of the accumulation of such dust, gas, fume, or vapour, etc., or
    • Otherwise by the exclusion or effective enclosure of all potential ignition sources.
  • Precautions in case of fire (Section 38):
    • In order to protect and maintain safety to allow people to escape in the case of fire, all factories should have precautionary measures in place to avoid the breakout and spread of fire, both internally and externally. The required tools and facilities for extinguishing the fire must also be made accessible.
    • All factory employees who are familiar with fire escape routes and have received sufficient training on the procedure to be followed in such circumstances must have access to appropriate measures.

Penalties of the Factories Act, 1948

In Chapter X of the Act, the penalties of the Factories Act of 1948 are covered. There are 9 Sections, from Section 92 to Section 99, that deal with penalties in certain situations. Anyone who breaches the Act or the rules established by the Act or by law is subjected to the penalty.

General Penalty for offences

Section 92 of the Factories Act, 1948 defines the general penalties for offences: 

  • If there is any infringement of the Act’s laws, the occupier and manager of the factory will be held responsible and equally liable for breaching the law. They will both face two years in imprisonment and a fine of up to Rs.2 lakhs. 
  • If they continue to commit the same offence, they will be fined Rs.10,000 every day for continued violations.

Liability of an owner of factory premises

Section 93 of the Factories Act, 1948 defines the liability of an owner of premises under special circumstances.

  • When a factory is leased to several occupiers or lessees or leaseholders, the factory’s owner is still held liable for supplying and maintaining certain services such as drainage, approach roads, water supply, power, lighting, sanitation, and so on. 
  • The chief inspector has the authority to issue an order to the owner of the premises in order to enforce the requirements.

The penalty is enhanced even after a previous conviction

Section 94 of the Factories Act, 1948 defines a penalty that is enhanced even after a previous conviction.

  • First, a person who commits a general offence in a factory and does it again faces a penalty of up to three years in jail or a fine of at least Rs. 10,000, or both.
  • Second, the managers must count the offences committed during the previous two years of the most recent offence to determine the application of this Section.

The penalty for obstructing an inspector

Section 95 of the Factories Act, 1948 defines a penalty for obstructing an inspector.

  • Any person who stops an inspector from using any powers given to him or under the Act, or if an individual fails to appear when requested by an inspector, may be made responsible and subject to a punishment of up to six months imprisonment, a fine of up to ten thousand rupees, or both.
  • This Section is also applicable when anyone stops a worker from coming before or being inspected by an inspector in a factory.

Penalty for wrongfully disclosing results of analysis

Section 96 of the Factories Act, 1948 defines a penalty for wrongfully disclosing the results of analysis under Section 91 of the Factories Act, 1948.

  • Any individual who publishes or discloses to another person the results of an analysis that is performed using samples is punishable by up to six months imprisonment. He will be liable for at least an Rs. 10,000 fine.

Penalty for the contravention of certain provisions

Section 96A of the Factories Act, 1948 defines the penalty for the contravention of certain provisions, such as Sections 41B, 41C, and 41H.

  • Anyone who disobeys or violates any of the rules or the provisions of Sections 41B, 41C, or 41H will be sentenced to 7 years in prison and a fine of Rs. 2,00,000. If the offender continues to commit the same offence, he will also be fined Rs. 5,000 every day after the conviction of the same offence.
  • If the failure or violation persists more than a year after the conviction, the offender will face a 10-year jail sentence.

Worker’s offences

Section 97 of the Factories Act, 1948 defines worker’s offences.

  • If any worker in the factory breaches the Act’s rules or provisions, causing liabilities for other workers, he or she will be fined at least Rs. 500.
  • When a worker is found guilty of a punishable offence, the owner or manager of the factory is not held responsible for the violation unless it can be proven that he failed to take reasonable precautions to prevent it.

False certificate of fitness

Section 98 of the Factories Act, 1948 defines a false certificate of fitness.

  • A fitness certificate details a person’s level of fitness for a certain job or work. This certificate is important in factories. A person who obtains a false certificate of fitness faces a minimum fine of Rs. 10,000 or a 2-month sentence in jail. He may occasionally face fines and jail terms as punishment.

Double Employment of Child

Section 99 of the Factories Act, 1948 defines the double employment of children.

  • If a child works in a factory on a day when they have already worked in another factory, their parents, guardians, or anyone else who benefits from the wages of the child faces a fine of Rs. 1000 unless the court finds that the child worked without the parents or guardian’s consent.
Offence Penalties 
Any worker in a factory who contravenes the provisions of the Act or Rules.Section 92 penalises him/her for 2 years of imprisonment or a fine of Rs.1,00,000 or both.
A continuation of contravention.Section 92 penalises him/her with a fine of Rs.1000 per day.
On contravention of Chapter IV pertaining to safety or dangerous operations.Not less than Rs.25,000 in case of death.Not less than Rs.5,000 in case of serious injuries.
Subsequent contravention of some provisions.Section 94 deals with imprisonment up to 3 years or a fine of not less than Rs.10,000 which may extend to Rs.2,00,000.
Obstructing inspectorsSection 95 deals with imprisonment up to 6 months or a fine up to Rs.10,000 or both.
Wrongful disclosing results pertaining to the results of the analysis.Section 96 deals with imprisonment of 6 months or a fine of up to Rs.10,000 or both.
For contravention of the provisions of Sections 41B, 41C and 41H pertaining to compulsory disclosure of information by occupier, specific responsibility of occupier or right of workers to work imminent danger.Section 96A deals with penalties of-Imprisonment up to 7 years with a fine up to Rs.2,00,000 and on continuation fine of Rs.4000 per day. Imprisonment for 10 years when contravention continues for one year.

Duties of various authorities under the Factories Act 

Duties of occupier

Notice given by occupier (Section 7)

  • According to Section 7 of the Act, the occupier is required to send notice to the chief inspector of everything that is stated in this Section.
  • According to Section 7(1), the occupier must give the chief inspector a written notice at least fifteen days before occupying or using any factory premises.
  • The notice should include the following information: 
    • the name and location of the factory; 
    • the occupier’s name and address; 
    • the owner’s name and address of the property or building (including its establishments) mentioned in Section 93; and 
    • the address to which communications pertaining to the factory may be sent;
    • the nature of the manufacturing process- 
      • carried out in the factory over the last 12 months in the case of factories that exist on the date of the Act’s commencement; 
      • carried out in the factory during the next 12 months in the case of all factories;
    • the name of the factory manager for the purposes of this Act;
    • the number of workers who are presently employed there and have already been employed in the factory from the date this Act was enacted;
    • the average number of workers per day employed over the previous 12 months;
  • When a new manager is appointed, the occupier must give written notice to the inspector and a copy to the chief inspector within seven days of the day, such person takes over in charge.
  • During any period when no one has been appointed as manager in the factory or when the appointed person is not managing the factory, or if no one is found, the occupier must be the factory’s manager.

General duties of the occupier (Section 7A)

  • Every occupier is responsible for the welfare, health, and safety of every worker while they are in the factory.
  • He is responsible for ensuring that the factory’s equipment is maintained in a way that is safe and poses no health hazards.
  • When utilising, handling, storing, and transporting items and chemicals, the factory’s arrangement needs to be examined to ensure safety and the absence of health dangers.
  • In order to ensure the health and safety of all employees while they are at work, he must examine the information, teaching, training, and monitoring requirements.
  • He is responsible for inspecting or supervising the maintenance of a working environment that is secure, free from health risks, and equipped with the necessary facilities and arrangements to ensure the welfare of the employees while they are at work.
  • He is required to inspect the maintenance of all work areas in the factory in a manner that is secure and free from any danger to health, as well as the maintenance of methods of access and egress; such locations must be safe and free from such risks.

Duties of manufacturers

General duties of manufacturers (Section 7B)

  • This Section states that anyone who deals with designing, manufacturing, importing, or supplying any article to use in any factory must make sure, to the extent that it is reasonably practicable, that the article is constructed so that it is safe and without risks to the health of all workers when used properly; 
  • He must also carry out and arrange for tests and examinations to ensure effective implementation;
  • He must take action to guarantee that there is sufficient information regarding the product’s usage in factories, the uses for which it was intended and tested, and the requirements that must be met to ensure that the article is used in a way that is safe and does not endanger the health of the employees;
  • It must be provided that when an article is developed or made outside India, the importer must inspect the article to ensure that it conforms to the same standards as if it were manufactured in India, or if the standards set in the country outside for the production of such article are higher than the standards adopted in India, the article must conform to much higher requirements.
  • Anyone who designs or produces a product for use in a factory is allowed to do, or arrange for the conduct of, any required research in order to determine to the extent that is reasonably possible, the removal or minimization of any hazards to the health or safety of the employees.
  • An article that is mentioned in this provision includes plant and machinery.

Case laws

Shankar Balaji Waje v. State of Maharashtra, (1961)

Facts of the case

In this case, the appellant was the proprietor of a business that produced bidis. In the factory, the petitioner and the other workers used tobacco and leave provided by the factory to roll bidis. There was no agreement or contract between the owner and the petitioner. He was not required to work in the factory for specific hours or days. He could enter or leave the factory as he wished. He is allowed to take a day off work at any time, and with the owner’s consent, he is also allowed to take a 10-day leave of absence. He wasn’t asked to roll bidis in the factory, but with the owner’s permission, he may take them home to roll bidis that were given to him. There was neither actual supervision of the work he did in the factory nor a master-servant relationship between the petitioner and the appellant. There was no minimum production requirement, and he received fixed rates based on the number of bidis, or piece prices for rolling bidis.

Issues involved

The issue involved was whether the petitioner complied with the definition of a worker under the Factories Act of 1948 or not.

Judgement of the case

In accordance with Section 2(l) of the Factories Act of 1948, the petitioner is not a worker.

Shri Suresh Kumar Jalan & Ors v. State of Bihar, (2011)

Facts of the case

In this case, the petitioners were the directors of a factory called Carbon Resources Private Limited, where a factory inspector investigated the premises and discovered numerous violations of the Factory Act. The inspector filed a prosecution report against the petitioners, who were factory directors. Under Section 92 of the Factories Act, the Chief Judicial Magistrate took charge of the offence. The petitioners filed an appeal with the High Court of Patna to quash the order of the Chief Judicial Magistrate.

Issues involved

The issue involved was whether the petitioner’s appeal with the High Court of Patna to quash the Chief Judicial Magistrate’s judgement under Section 92 of the Factories Act had merit or not.

Judgement of the case

The petitioner’s counsel was providing evidence to show that, according to Section 92 of the Factories Act, only the manager or occupier can be held responsible for violations committed in the factory. However, based on the judgement rendered by the Chief Judicial Magistrate, directors of the factory cannot be penalised under Section 92 of the Factories Act. The Chief Judicial Magistrate’s order was quashed by the High Court of Patna because directors cannot be penalised under Section 92 of the Act. It was noted from this case that directors cannot be held responsible for the Act’s violations; only the manager or occupier is responsible.

P.Trivikrama Prasad v. The State of AP by its Assistant Inspector of Factories, (2016)

Facts of the case

In this case, the deputy chief inspector of factories filed a private complaint against the petitioner for violations of Section 32(a) and Section 41 of the Factories Act, which are punishable under Section 92 of the Act. The petitioner failed to provide D-rings to the cane trally side plate to support the employees as they would safely get down from the trolley once the crane loading was complete. They also failed to provide ladders and helmets, which resulted in some unskilled workers getting hit while working and causing them to die. Since no helmet, d-rings, or ladders were provided, the occupier/managing director of the entity or the manager (i.e., the petitioner) was made responsible. Then the petitioner filed a criminal petition against the factory inspector.

Issues involved

The issue involved was whether the criminal petition filed against the accused would be rejected or allowed to proceed.

Judgement of the case

The Hyderabad High Court held that the occupier or managing director (petitioner), who neglects to provide d-rings, ladders, and helmets to the employees for their safety and fails to teach them during hazardous times, is at fault. Therefore, the criminal petition brought against the respondent is dismissed and quashed. As a result, the petitioner is responsible for his ignorance and failure to maintain the factory properly.

New Amendments of Factories Act

Amendment (1954)

When the Indian government accepted the ILO conventions prohibiting the employment of women and children in factories at night. Sections 66, 70, and 71 of the Factories Act of 1948 were amended in order to indicate this ratification. The other provisions were amended at the same time. Therefore, on December 25, 1954, the Factories (Amendment) Act, 1954 became effective and made the following significant changes:

  • Amendment to Section 4.
  • The amendment to the definition of the manufacturing process includes type composing for printing.
  • Women and young people were prohibited from cleaning, lubricating, and operating motion machinery.
  • Encasement of machinery.
  • The safety criteria for lifting equipment were explicitly stated in an amendment to Section 29. 
  • The employees may work for 6 straight hours without being required to take a rest during a 6-hour shift. 
  • Shift workers are free from overtime duties if a shift worker arrives late. 
  • Amending Chapter VIII on leave with pay to fix 240 days of attendance and increase the limit on carried forward leaves, etc. 
  • Section 93 has been rewritten to explain the responsibilities of the owner and occupier.

Amendment (1976)

After the amendments of 1948 and 1954, there was a continuation of industrial growth and a need for safety officers to advise management on concerns about industrial safety and health. The Factories (Amendment) Act 1976 was passed and came into effect on October 26, 1976, as a result of numerous judgments concerning the definition of a worker; a tendency to not include contract labour from that definition but there must be proof of master and servant relationship; and a need for amendments to many other provisions, including the penal Section.

  • The definition was amended to the terms manufacturing process, employee, factory, and occupier. The term “worker” also covered contract labour.
  • There must be an approved plan and permission for the site. 
  • There are amendments to the following provisions:
    • Section 8 deals with inspectors.
    • Section 10 deals with certifying surgeons.
    • Section 11 deals with cleanliness.
    • Section 12 deals with the disposal of waste and effluents.
    • Section 21 deals with the fencing of machinery.
    • Section 22 deals with work on or near machinery in motion.
    • Section 24 deals with striking gear and devices for cutting off power.
    • Section 31 deals with pressure plants.
    • Section 32 deals with floors, stairs, and means of access.
    • Section 36 deals with precautions against dangerous fumes.
    • Section 38 deals with precautions in case of fire.
    • Section 39 deals with specifications of defective parts.
    • Section 40 deals with the safety of buildings and machinery.
    • Section 45 deals with first aid devices.
    • Section 48 deals with creches.
    • Section 56 deals with spread over.
    • Section 59 deals with overtime wages.
    • Section 73 deals with the register of child workers.
    • Section 79 deals with taking leave with wages.
    • Section 87 deals with dangerous operations.
    • Section 88 deals with notices of accidents.
    • Section 92 deals with penalties for offences.
    • Section 101 deals with the determination of the occupier in certain cases.
    • Section 106 deals with the limitation of prosecutions and various other amendments etc.
  • Section 36A for the use of portable power lights, Section 40B for safety officials, Section 88A involves the notice of dangerous occurrences, and Section 91A regarding safety and health surveys were included as new provisions in this Amendment of 1976.
  • A new Section 40A was added, giving the authority to order the implementation of measures recommended by the Inspector for building maintenance, while Section 40B required the requirement of safety officers for firms employing 1000 or more workers.

Amendment (1987)

The Bhopal accident increased safety awareness on a worldwide level and compelled governments to impose stricter regulations on worker and public health and safety. As a result, both the central government and the state governments amended their laws and regulations as needed. On May 23, 1987, two new laws were passed: the Environment (Protection) Act of 1986 and the Factories (Amendment) Act of 1987. These laws included a new chapter IV A on hazardous procedures, numerous restrictions, and harsh fines and imprisonments for violations.

Registers required to be maintained under the Factories Act, 1948

Form 6Register of hygrometre (Humidity register)
Form 7Register of white-washing
Form 7ARegister of tight clothes provided
Form 9Register of compensatory holidays
Form 10Register of overtime for exempted workers
Form 12Register of adult workers
Form 14Register of child labour
Form 15Register of leave with wages
Form 24 & 25Muster Roll-9
Form 26Register of accident & dangerous occurrence

Acts to be done or maintained

Form 3Change of name of manager/ occupier as and when required
Form 2 Renewal of annual fees to reach to the prescribed office
Form 8Report of examination of vessels
Form 11Notice of periods of work for adult workers
Form 13Notice of periods of work for child labour
Form 18Notice of accidents and dangerous occurrences to be submitted within 24 hours by registered post.
Form 18ANotice of accident and dangerous occurrence not resulting in bodily injury.
Form 19Notice of accident and dangerous occurrence (poisoning or disease)
Form 21Annual return ending 31st December
Form 22Half-yearly return by 30th June.
Form 31Accident annual return by 1st week of February-Rule 107(4)
Form 34Monthly return only for hazardous happenings
Form 37Report of the hoist of lifts

Conclusion

In India, the Factories Act of 1948 is applied with appropriate amendments. Certain changes have been made in order to comply. All manufacturing employees are protected by the Act, but young and female workers are particularly well-protected. The Act provides certain facilities in the factory, and anyone who breaches the Act or the Rules will be subject to specific penalties. The inspector, who is chosen by the state and central governments, will conduct the inspection of the factory. The Factories Act, which benefits the factory, its employees, occupiers, and owners, has been in effect for around 37 years. As a result of the Act, their working and employment conditions have gradually improved. The Act outlines the time that employees work, their working hours, paid time off, paid overtime, their age restriction, etc. Additionally, it details how the environment, human health, and safety are protected at the factory. When it comes to occupier and manager responsibilities under the Factories Act of 1948, the government is actively working to update the Act and provide effective measures. In order to ensure the workers’ welfare, health, and safety, the employer and manager play an important role. They act as the industry’s controller. The Act’s provisions must be understood by the employees and their other representatives in order to protect their rights independently and make a defaulting employer aware of his legal responsibilities.

Frequently asked questions (FAQs)

To whom does the Factories Act apply?

The Factories Act is applicable across India, but only to factories with ten or more employees with power and twenty or more employees without power. Section 85 of the Act, applies to factories with fewer employees.

What is covered by the Factory Act?

The Factory Act covers the duty of the employer to ensure the health, safety, and welfare of the employees.

What is the maximum limit that is allowed for lifting, carrying, or moving objects with the head or by hand? 

No adult male or adult woman should lift, carry, move by hand, or use a tool that exceeds the maximum limit recommended, i.e., 75 kg for men and 30 kg for women, and no adolescent male or teenage female should lift, carry, move by hand, or use a head-mounted device that exceeds the maximum limit prescribed, i.e., 30 kg for males and 20 kg for females.

References 


Students of Lawsikho courses regularly produce writing assignments and work on practical exercises as a part of their coursework and develop themselves in real-life practical skills.

LawSikho has created a telegram group for exchanging legal knowledge, referrals, and various opportunities. You can click on this link and join:

https://t.me/lawyerscommunity

Follow us on Instagram and subscribe to our YouTube channel for more amazing legal content.

Download Now

Well-known trademark

0

This article is written by Jaya Jha of the Vivekananda Institute of Professional Studies, Delhi. This article deals with the comparative analysis of well-known trademarks and their various components.

It has been published by Rachit Garg.

Introduction 

Intellectual property is a broad category that comprises any works produced using a person’s intellect, primarily including trademarks, copyright, and patent. Industrial property and copyright are two classic divisions of Intellectual Property (IP). Before 2017, well-known trademarks could only be established through a judicial proceeding but Rule 124 of The Trade Mark Rules, 2017 introduces a new procedure by allowing a trademark owner to fill out the application form TM-M and request that the brand be considered well-known. Well-known trademarks have their goodwill and reputation protected across the country and categories of goods and services, in contrast to other trademarks whose goodwill and reputation are restricted to a set designated geographical area and a certain range of items. The Trade Mark Registry is prohibited by law from registering any mark as a trademark that is confusingly similar to one of the well-known trademarks. For instance, Alphabet Inc. has registered Google as a well-known trademark, making it the only company authorised to register the term “Google” for any product or service. Even though the service is unrelated to the Internet sector, only Alphabet Inc. is permitted to register “Google” as a trademark. 

In this article, we will analyse the definition and significance of well-known trademarks as well as the elements that make a trademark well-known and remedies available for the infringement of a well-known trademark.

What is a trademark 

Manufacturers and traders have long used trademarks to indicate the sources of their products and services and to set them apart from products and services produced or offered by others. The purpose of the trademark has traditionally been to identify the provider of products and services. In the majority of the nations in the world, trademarks are governed by national trademark laws because of their importance to the economy.

Meaning 

A ‘trademark’ is a mark that sets one business apart from another. A trademark according to Section 2(zb) of the Trademark Act, 1999 described as a mark that can distinguish the goods or services of one person from those of others and that can be represented visually and according to the Section 2(1)(zg)  of the Trade Marks Act of 1999, a well-known mark has grown to be so well-known to the significant portion of the public who uses such goods or receives such services that the use of such a mark concerning other goods or services would likely be taken as indicating a connection between those goods or services and a person using the mark with the first-mentioned goods or services in the course of trade or rendering of services.

Elements of a well-known trademark

According to the definition mentioned above, a well-known mark consists of the following elements:

i. A mark that a significant portion of the public uses specific goods or services, such as the mark “TATA” of Tata Sons Ltd.

ii. Is utilised by another party to obtain more goods or services (such as TATA jewels).

iii. Is likely to point to a relationship between TATA diamonds and Tata Sons Ltd.

Article 16.3 of the Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property (TRIPS) Agreement appears to provide the foundation for this definition. The absence of focus on “harm to the interests of the owner of the registered trademark” under the Indian Act in the Trade Marks Act of 1999’s definition of a well-known mark contrasts significantly with Article 16.3 of the TRIPS. The first legal document to acknowledge well-known trademarks as a legal notion was the Paris Convention of 1883, which contained measures to offer exceptional protection to well-known trademarks.

In the case of Daimler Benz v. Hybo Hindustan (1993), the plaintiff requested an injunction against the defendant’s use of his emblem since they were both using the word “Benz.” The court issued an injunction against the defendant’s alleged use of the plaintiff’s logo despite acknowledging it as a well-known trademark due to its international recognition and goodwill. 

When does a trademark become a well-known trademark

To protect well-known marks against infringement and misuse, WIPO adopted a Joint Resolution Concerning Provisions for the Protection of Well-Known Marks in 1999. This resolution included a list of elements that determine whether a trademark is well-known. Due to its membership in the World Trade Organization, India embraced these elements and included them in Section 11 of the Trademarks Act, clause 6. These deciding elements include:

  1. Knowledge about the mark in relevant sections of the public- The Trademarks Act 1999, Section 11(7), lists the three requirements that a mark must meet to indicate whether or not it is recognised by the relevant segment of the public. The “actual or potential consumers,” “those participating in the distribution networks,” and “the enterprises dealing with the goods and services” are some examples of these. In a different case, Rolex Sa v. Alex Jewellery Pvt. Ltd. &Ors (2009)., the plaintiff sued the defendant to stop him from using his trade name while dealing in fake jewellery because the defendant was using the trade name “Rolex” that belonged to the plaintiff. The court determined that the plaintiff’s business was in the watch industry and that the trade name Rolex is well-known among consumers of watches. If artificial jewellery is discovered with the same trade name, the same demographic may presume it came from the plaintiff’s company. For the same grounds, the court issued an injunction against the defendant’s actions, finding Rolex to be a well-known trademark.
  2. The duration, extent and geographical area in which the trademark is used.
  3. The duration, extent and geographical area in which the trademark is promoted concerning the goods and services to which it applies. In the case of Whirlpool Corporation, v Registrar of Trademark (1998) the Apex Court held that even though the company’s goods were absent from the Indian market, the mark was a well-known mark and that the product’s advertisement was sufficient to reach the relevant part of the public.
  4. Registration or application for registration of the trademark to the extent they reflect the use or recognition of the trade mark;
  5. The record of successful enforcement of the rights in that trade mark including the record stating that the trademark has been recognised as well-known by any court or Registrar.

Examples of well-known trademarks in India

 

Following are the examples of well-known trademarks in India:

Bata and Bata foam for footwear

In the case of Bata India Ltd. v Chawla boot house (2019), the Delhi High Court prohibited the defendant from using the word “power” concerning footwear and related products after finding that Bata India Limited’s trademark POWER is well known in India.

Bisleri

In the case of Acqua Minerals Limited vs Mr Pramod Borse & Anr (2001), Delhi High Court held that one of the earliest brands of bottled mineral water to be introduced was BISLERI, which is well-known in the Indian market. The defendant was detained when it was shown that he registered the domain name Bisleri intending to profit from the plaintiff’s good name and reputation.

Whirlpool

In the case, N.R. Dongre And Ors vs Whirlpool Corporation And Anr (1996) Court held that through both the import of goods and its advertising, a product and its trade name can transcend the actual borders of a particular geographic area and development of a trans-border, overseas, or extraterritorial reputation. An injunction may be granted if there is knowledge or awareness of a foreign trader’s goods and its trademark at a location where those goods are not being sold.

Intel

Intel Corporation v.CPM United Kingdom Ltd (2007). Intel corporation has various well-known trademarks under its community including a well-known trademark of the word ‘INTEL’ in the UK which is a synonym of computer processors and its services and the word mark “INTELMARK” has been registered as a trademark in the UK by CPM United Kingdom Ltd. Intel claimed that the use of the ‘INTELMARK’ mark would unfairly exploit the character or goodwill of the previous ‘INTEL’ trademark

The Court held that the mark’s use is unlikely to unfairly exploit the earlier mark’s distinctive character or reputation if the relevant part of the public has not made a “link” between the earlier and subsequent marks.

Ford

Ford Motor Company v Mrs C.R. Borman (2014). In this case, the issue was whether FORD is a well-known trademark or not, the court held that FORD is a particularly “well-known”  trademark in its sector of work and amongst the public. The extensive geographic reach of the plaintiff’s use, the length of time the mark has been in use, the general public’s awareness of the trademark “FORD” and its goodwill and reputation as a result of the plaintiffs’ extensive use of promotion, publicity, and advertising, the plaintiffs’ extensive sales in India and other countries under the mark, and the numerous registrations the mark has received all prove that the plaintiff’s mark “FORD” is in use and is a well-known trademark.

Bajaj 

In the case of Bajaj electricals, Ltd v Metals allied product (1987) Bombay High Court determined that the accused engaged in passing off by using the family name Bajaj. The plaintiff company’s reputation and goodwill were acknowledged. 

Legislations related to a well-known trademarks in India

Rule 124 of the Trade Mark Rules 2017 

This rule enables trademark owners to submit a form TM-M to the Registrar asking for the grant of a “well-known” trademark. Before the introduction of this law, a mark could only be deemed well-known after becoming the subject of proceedings, correction, and opposition before the Honourable Courts. The introduction of this rule and the associated procedure allows a trademark owner to request a well-known trademark without having to engage in any legal proceedings or corrections. Rule 124 guarantees that a trademark will receive the designation of “well-known” simply by submitting a request to the Registry.

The 1999 Trademarks Act

Protection of well-known marks in all classes (Sec-11 (2))

The protection offered to well-known trademarks is expanded under this section’s provision. This provision mandates the recognition and protection of well-known trademarks across all kinds of products and services. It says that a brand which is similar to or identical to a prior trademark and to the extent that the earlier trademark is a well-known trademark in India and the use of the later mark without justification would unfairly benefit from or harm the distinctive character or repute of the earlier trademark, it will not be registered for goods or services that are not similar to those for which the earlier trademark is registered in the name of a different proprietor.

The trademark “Kirloskar” has become well known in India, and the Bombay High Court protected it in the case of Kirloskar Diesel Recon Pvt Ltd vs. Kirloskar Proprietary Ltd (1995). If any other party uses this trademark for some other business, the public will assume that the plaintiff has only expanded its business, which will further harm the plaintiff’s company. Similar restrictions were placed on the defendant in the Benz case because the “Benz” brand was already well-known for autos.

Remedies for infringement of well-known trademarks

Following are the remedies for infringement of well-known trademarks-

1) No trademarks that are identical or misleading may be registered across all classes of products and services. If a party have been wronged and wants to ratify it party may ask for a registered trademark’s correction, cancellation, or removal from the register. The steps of ratification is being provided under the Trademark Act 

  1. Notifying the customs of the infringement to prevent using the goods that bear that trademark.
  2. By applying the Indian Customs Act, 1962.

2) Trademarks which will offend the well-known trademark shall be subject to deletion.

3) The violators will be subject to punitive damages. The Delhi High Court ruled in Time Incorporated v. Lokesh Srivastava (2005) that original owners of intellectual property should receive both punitive and compensatory damages. In the current case, the plaintiff received 5 lakh rupees in compensatory damages and an additional 5 lakh rupees in punitive damages.

4) Preventing the incorporation of any group or business connected to the original, well-known trademark from violating it. Manufacturing or owning tools for forging trademarks, using misleading trading names, and other similar actions are all violations of the Trademark Act. Three years in prison, either with or without a fine, is the maximum penalty for any of these offences. Infringement under the trademark act is considered cognizable infringement.

Conclusion 

Due to the current brand value of well-known brands, Indian law grants them exceptional protection. No matter how long a mark has been in use, massive amounts of publicity are one of the crucial traits that should be addressed. Owners of trademarks frequently use ornate names, numbers, or other attractive elements to distinguish their marks from others and so increase their level of protection.

To appropriately and sufficiently protect well-known trademarks and service marks around the world, national, regional, and international legal instruments have provided them with additional protection. This is due to a pair of factors. The first is that well-known marks are more fragile than regular ones, as previously explained, because they are easier to unfairly exploit since the illegal profit that can be made from such practices is typically higher, and because they are more vulnerable to actions like counterfeiting and dilution due to their widespread use around the world. The second factor is that well-known marks naturally differ significantly from trademarks that do not have the same level of popularity and repute in the eyes of customers.

No comparable marks are permitted for any goods or services, making a well-known trademark a valuable intellectual asset for a corporation with many benefits. To preserve these well-known trademarks’ exclusivity and legitimate status, nevertheless, it is crucial.

References

  1. https://ipindiaonline.gov.in/tmrpublicsearch/wellknownmarks.aspx
  2. https://www.mondaq.com/india/trademark/808148/all-you-need-to-know-about-well-known-trademarks
  3. https://www.intepat.com/blog/trademark/well-known-trademarks/
  4. https://www.ipandlegalfilings.com/all-you-need-to-know-about-well-known-trademarks?utm_source=Mondaq&utm_medium=syndication&utm_campaign=LinkedIn-integration

Students of Lawsikho courses regularly produce writing assignments and work on practical exercises as a part of their coursework and develop themselves in real-life practical skills.

LawSikho has created a telegram group for exchanging legal knowledge, referrals, and various opportunities. You can click on this link and join:

https://t.me/lawyerscommunity

Follow us on Instagram and subscribe to our YouTube channel for more amazing legal content.

Download Now

Order 7 Rule 1 CPC

0

This article has been written by Anindita Deb, a student from Symbiosis Law School, NOIDA. This article discusses different provisions and important aspects of Order 7 Rule 1 under the Code of Civil Procedure. 

This article has been published by Sneha Mahawar.

Introduction 

In a country with a population like India’s, you can only imagine the huge pile of case files the courts are dealing with on a daily basis. The smallest of disputes are taken to court because the populace places its faith in the legal system and believes in the justice it provides. But imagine there being no guidelines and framework to serve this justice. The judges would deliver judgments at whim, and procedural requirements would become subjective. This is where procedural statutes come in. The Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC), is the procedural law that administers and regulates civil proceedings in India. So next time you file a land dispute case or an unfair termination complaint, make sure you follow the procedure laid down therein. 

A plaint is an essential element in any civil case. Without it, the judge would be incapable of arriving at a decision. Why, you ask? What is a plaint, you wonder? Well, think no more. Keep reading to find out all about a plaint and what it should contain as per the provisions laid down under Order 7 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Code. 

What is a plaint 

The term ‘plaint’ has not been defined anywhere under the Civil Procedure Code. If one simply tries to put it down, a plaint is a document containing the pleadings or contentions that the plaintiff wishes to put forward before the court. It is a statement that specifies the cause of action of the plaintiff in coming to court and it also mentions what relief the plaintiff seeks from the court. 

The Karnataka High Court made an attempt at defining what a plaint is in the case of Girija Bai v. Thakur Das (1967):

“A plaint can be said to be a statement of claim, a document, by presentation of which the suit is instituted. Its object is to state the grounds upon which the assistance of the court is sought by the plaintiff. It is the pleading of the plaintiff.” 

Particulars of a plaint as per Order 7 Rule 1 CPC 

Order 7 of the Civil Procedure Code has eight rules which deal with different requisites and provisions relating to plaints. Rule 1 of the Order mentions the particulars which must be contained in a plaint. The following are the particulars as mentioned within Rule 1:

  1. The name of the court before which the suit has been brought. [Rule 1(a)]
  2. The name, description, and place of residence of the plaintiff. [Rule 1(b)]
  3. The name, description, and place of residence of the defendant, as far as it is possible to ascertain it. [Rule 11(c)]
  4. If the plaintiff or defendant to the suit is a minor, or of unsound mind, a statement must be attached to that effect. [Rule 1(d)] 
  5. The facts which constitute the cause of action and when it arose. [Rule 1(e)] 
  6. The facts which prove that the court to which the plaint is being submitted has the jurisdiction to hear the case. [Rule 1(f)] 
  7. The relief which the plaintiff is claiming. [Rule 1(g)] 
  8. In cases where the plaintiff has waived or allowed setoff of a portion of his claim, the amount thus waived or allowed. [Rule 1(h)] 
  9. A declaration of the value of the lawsuit’s subject matter for jurisdictional and monetary purposes, to the extent that the case permits. [Rule 1(i)] 

Important aspects of Order 7 Rule 1 CPC 

This section aims to discuss some of the above mentioned particulars in detail in order to provide a better understanding to the readers regarding the same. 

Parties to the suit 

Every suit must have two parties to it, i.e., the plaintiff and the defendant. There can be two or more plaintiffs or two or more defendants as well, but one plaintiff and one defendant must be a party to the suit for the court to hear it. Each and every particular of the plaintiff and defendant, such as name, father’s name, age, place of residence, etc., which will be used to identify the parties to the suit, has to be mentioned in the plaint. 

Cause of action 

A cause of action is a prerequisite for filing a suit. The plaint will be rejected immediately if there is no cause of action, and hence, the cause of action must be clearly mentioned in the plaint. The expression ‘cause of action’ has not been defined anywhere in the Code, but it can be defined as a bundle of essential facts that the plaintiff must necessarily prove in order to succeed. The cause of action can also be said to be that which gives the plaintiff his right to relief against the defendant. It forms the very foundation of a suit. 

However, it must be kept in mind that the cause of action does not have anything to do with what defence the defendant puts in, or with the character of the relief that the plaintiff is seeking. It is merely a medium through which the plaintiff prays to the court to deliver a judgment in his favour. The determination of whether or not the facts constitute a cause of action depends entirely on the facts of the case, and the court is supposed to consider the substance of the matter rather than the forms of action. 

It is important for the plaintiff to mention in his plaint as to when the cause of action arose. This will help the defendant as well as the court to determine from the plaint whether or not the cause of action that the plaintiff has alleged in his plaint has arisen in fact and in law.

The Supreme Court of India made the following observation with respect to cause of action in the case of Kuldeep Singh v. Ganpat Lal (1995):

“The object underlying Order 7 Rule 1(e), which requires that the plaint shall contain the particulars about the facts constituting the cause of action and when it arose, is to enable the court to find out whether the plaint discloses the cause of action because the plaint is liable to be rejected under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC if it does not disclose the cause of action. The purpose behind the requirement that the plaint should indicate when the cause of action arose is to help the court in ascertaining whether the suit is not barred by limitation. Any error on the part of the plaintiff in indicating the date on which the cause of action arose would be of little consequence if the cause of action had arisen on the date on which the suit was filed and the suit was within limitation from the said date. The error in mentioning the date on which the cause of action had arisen in the plaint in such a case would not disentitle the plaintiff from seeking relief from the court in the suit.”

For determining whether the facts mentioned by the plaintiff constitute the cause of action or not, the court has to look into whether such facts constitute the material, essential, or integral part of the cause of action. If it is, then it forms the cause of action, if not, then it does not form the cause of action. 

Jurisdiction of the court 

The plaint must contain all the information necessary to establish the court’s pecuniary and territorial jurisdiction over the dispute at hand. When a defendant challenges a court’s capacity to hear a case, the court may pose the question in that manner and decide on it before judgment on other matters. The plea of jurisdiction has to be decided on the basis of arguments in the plaint. 

Valuation

For the purpose of the court’s pecuniary jurisdiction and court fees, the plaintiff must specify in the plaint the valuation of the suit’s subject matter. When seeking to recover money, for example, the valuation of the subject matter may occasionally be the same for both reasons. However, there are situations when two assessments may be in conflict, such as in litigation for a declaration, an injunction, or the possession of the real estate. In this situation, the plaintiff must expressly identify the value of the action in order for the court to have jurisdiction over it and in order to determine court costs.

Judicial pronouncements 

Jaharlal Pagalia v. Union of India (1958) 

In this case, a request to alter the plaint was made. The High Court of Calcutta made the observation while approving the decree that the facts supporting the claim must come before the lawsuit. The cause of action must be stated under Section 80 (Notice) of the CPC. The cause of action and the date it occurred must be disclosed as provided under Order 7, Rule 1(e) even though the writing of the plaint is a procedural matter. The plaintiff lacks locus standi in the absence of a cause of action. Even though the plaintiff had shown a delay, the court permitted him to alter the plaint in accordance with Order 6 Rule 17 because the delay had not negatively impacted either of the parties. 

P.M. Diesels Ltd. v. Patel Field Marshal Industries (1995) 

In this case, the defendants protested, claiming that the court lacked the jurisdiction to hear the case. Even the plaint did not contain any information demonstrating the suit’s territorial jurisdiction. The court held that, according to Order 7 Rule 1, the plaintiff must demonstrate the court’s jurisdiction. The plaintiff in the present case did not carry out his obligations. Due to the lack of territorial and financial jurisdiction, the court declined to grant the relief of an injunction, regardless of the merits of the case.

Sh. Suresh Kumar Anand v. Sh. Sudhish C. Anand (2018) 

In this case, the plaintiff had filed a lawsuit seeking a mandatory injunction, damages, and mesne profits. The absence of a documented licensing deed was acknowledged by the court while discussing court costs. The plaintiff, the court said, had not complied with the specifics of Order 7 Rule 1(i) CPC. The market value of the subject property, which is a relevant fact, should have been disclosed.

Conclusion 

Order 7 plays an indispensable role in ensuring that the courts do not have to deal with frivolous cases and makes it easier for the plaintiff to file a plaint with ease and for the courts to determine whether or not there is a cause of action for further hearing. More importantly, the Order has also ensured that the jurisdiction of the court to try the case is proved in the plaint so that there isn’t an additional dispute about the court’s jurisdiction. So the next time you are looking to file a civil suit for damages, make sure your plaint contains all the particulars mentioned within this article so that your plaint does not get rejected by the court on grounds of not meeting the requirements mentioned under Order 7 Rule 1. 

References 


Students of Lawsikho courses regularly produce writing assignments and work on practical exercises as a part of their coursework and develop themselves in real-life practical skills.

LawSikho has created a telegram group for exchanging legal knowledge, referrals, and various opportunities. You can click on this link and join:

https://t.me/lawyerscommunity

Follow us on Instagram and subscribe to our YouTube channel for more amazing legal content.

Download Now

Right to Information Act, 2005

0
Right to Information

This article has been written by Ayush Tiwari, a student of Symbiosis Law School, NOIDA. This article aims to discuss the critical aspects of the Right to Information Act of 2005 including the Act’s objectives, the right to information and the responsibility of public authorities, the establishment of Information Commissions, their powers and activities, appeals and penalties, etc.

This article has been published by Sneha Mahawar.

Table of Contents

Introduction

Since the advent of democratic governments, interested individuals have sought information on how the administrations carry out the tasks assigned to them by law. Subjected citizens are sometimes curious about how their taxes have been utilised by competent authorities. Interested citizens also want to know how the administrators’ discretions are used and correctly executed for the benefit of society/community as a whole, or whether such discretions are used in the process of distributing benevolences from the State. Mechanisms have been developed from time to time to make administrators accountable for the use of funds designated for development projects. This level of scrutiny of administrative activity is only achievable when the opposing party in the Legislature is strong enough to reveal the Administrators/Executives’ wrongdoing. The difficulty in dissecting the flaws in government programmes arises only when the opposition is not morally powerful enough to critique government acts for obvious reasons. To conceal such wrongdoings or misdemeanours, authorities will endeavour not to reveal the actual facts to the public. In order to overcome the difficulties in obtaining information from government apparatus, information must be obtained from individuals who possess such knowledge. It really took India 82 years to get from an inaccessible governance system legitimised by the colonial Official Secrets Act to one in which citizens may demand the right to knowledge. The major goal of the Right to Information Act, 2005 in this regard is to secure information from authorities in order to expose wrongdoings or to strengthen the ability to oppose anti-people policies with legitimate grounds. The passage of the Right to Information Act in 2005 was a pivotal event in Indian democracy because more citizens have access to information, making the government more responsive to the community’s needs. 

In 2005, the United Progressive Alliance-1 (UPA) government led by Prime Minister Dr. Manmohan Singh introduced the Right to Information Act (14th Loka Sabha). The Right to Information stems from our basic right to free expression, guaranteed by Article 19 of the Constitution. We cannot create an informed view of our government or public institutions unless we have information about how they work. Citizens are at the core of governance, which is important to democracy, and press freedom is a necessary component for a democracy to flourish. As a result, it is clear that the primary reason for a free press is to keep citizens informed. As a result, it follows that the right to know is vital. The Act and its provisions provide a structure for requisitioning information, a time limit within which information must be delivered, a manner of providing the information, certain application fees, and exemptions from information that will not be provided.

Evolution of the concept of the Right to Information

The Global perspective

Sweden

On December 2, 1766, Sweden passed the world’s first Freedom of Information Act, 1766. In Sweden, this statute established press freedom, with those at stake including the government, courts, and parliament. As a result, Sweden’s constitution acknowledged that press freedom is dependent on access to information.

France 

Article 14 of the French Constitution states that “all people have the right to determine, by themselves or via their representatives, the necessity of a public tax, to voluntarily consent to it, to monitor its use, and to set its proportion, basis, collection, and duration.”

The United Kingdom

Since the olden days, democracy has been the fundamental precept of England, but secrecy rather than openness is emphasised. This is due to the legislature’s and the executive’s natural desire to enshroud policies rather than make them clear. The Freedom of Information Act of 2005 was passed in England. However, the current law is based on the Official Secrets Acts of 1911, 1920, and 1939. The English judiciary has endorsed government transparency. The House of Lords’ ruling in the case of Conway v. Rimmer, 1968, established its jurisdiction to require the publication of any document. It was also urged that a balance be maintained between the competing goals of secrecy and publicity. Lord Steyn’s statement in the case of R. v. Secretary of State for the Home Department, Ex P. Simms, (2000) demonstrates the importance of freedom of expression in English law: 

“Freedom of speech is the lifeblood of democracy.” Political discourse is informed by the free movement of information and ideas. It serves as a safety valve; individuals are more willing to accept choices that go against them if they may, in theory, try to alter them. It functions as a check on public officials’ misuse of authority. It allows the uncovering of flaws in the country’s administration and the delivery of justice…”

The United States

America is the oldest democracy in the world and hence often used interchangeably. America appears to be the torchbearer of a variety of democratic rights that should be part of a truly democratic framework. The same is true for information distribution. Antipathy toward intrinsic secrecy is thus not a characteristic displayed by Americans. According to Schwartz, “Americans genuinely believe in the beneficial benefits of exposure and have a strong aversion to the inherent secrecy of government entities.” RTI is granted by two major statutes: the Freedom of Information Act of 1966 and the Administrative Procedure Act of 1946. The right to information is not directly addressed in the United States Constitution. However, such a right is regarded as a consequence of the First Amendment freedoms. In the case of Lamont v. Post Master General (1965), the Supreme Court decided that a legislative provision constituted a restraint on the unrestricted exercise of First Amendment rights and so declared it unconstitutional. Similarly, in Stanley v. Georgia (1969), it was established that free speech safeguards the right to acquire information.

The United Nations

In 1946, the United Nations General Assembly issued a resolution on freedom of information that declared, “Freedom of information is a basic right that underpins all of the freedoms to which the United Nations is dedicated.” The right to gather, communicate, and publish news everywhere and everywhere is implied by freedom of information. As such, it is a vital aspect in any genuine endeavour to encourage the peace and growth of the world.

The Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR) is regarded as a pivotal point in human rights history. It was developed by representatives from all around the world with diverse legal and cultural backgrounds, and it embodied the spirit of oneness despite its practical variances. It was established as a shared standard of success for all peoples and nations by the United Nations General Assembly in Paris on December 10, 1948 (Resolution 217 A). Certain basic human rights that were to be uniformly guaranteed were established for the first time. The Universal Declaration of Human Rights specifically states in Article 19(2), “Everyone shall have the right to freedom of speech, which shall include the freedom to: seek, receive, and impart knowledge; regardless of boundaries – orally, in writing, or in print.”

The Indian perspective 

In India, the Right to Information (RTI) movement was launched at the grassroots level in the 1990s by an organisation called the Mazdoor Kisan Shakti Sangthan. The initiative began with the goal of increasing transparency in village accounting. It arose as a result of the demand for minimum wages in rural regions. Despite the fact that Mazdoor Kisan Shakti Sangthan was a rural poor struggle, it captured the attention and support of a cross-section of the country’s media, lawyers and jurists, academicians, and even bureaucrats and legislators, many of whom gathered to form the National Campaign on the People’s Right to Information (NCPRI). The government of India formed a working committee led by consumer rights activist H.D. Shourie to prepare laws for the government’s consideration. The Government-appointed Working Group in 1997 was known as the “Shourie Committee” since it was led by former bureaucrat and consumer rights campaigner H.D. Shourie. It broadened the scope of exclusions to allow public agencies to withhold material whose publication would be detrimental to the public interest.’ Because public authorities would thereafter be entitled to delay the publication of incriminating evidence in the name of the public interest, this one phrase effectively broke the back of the entire Act. The previously mentioned important Section, which said that only information that can be denied to parliament or the legislature can be kept from the citizen, was not included.

In July 2000, the Shourie draft was revived with significant amendments and introduced as the Freedom of Information Bill, 2000. In 2002, the Freedom of Information Act was passed. Right to Information (RTI) is an Act of the Indian Parliament that establishes the current regime of people’s right to information and supersedes the previous Freedom of Information Act of 2002. This law was enacted by Parliament on June 15, 2005, and went into effect on October 12, 2005. Subject to the provisions of this Act, all citizens have the right to information. Public authorities are required to disclose information. Public Information Officers serve as the intermediary between the information seeker and the public authority.

Need for Right to Information

Encourages people to participate

The majority of government work is done for the people, so they must be included in the planning process and be aware of how things are done. People must be well informed about the essence of the projects and programmes in order to participate in planning processes and make decisions about whether specific plans and schemes are beneficial to them. This will allow them to provide their feedback well in advance of any desired updates or alterations. This will significantly lower project expenditures while increasing project outputs.

Transparency

There is an assumption that everything done by the government is done for the public good—that is, it is done to serve the goal of public well-being, it is done honestly, and to maximise the advantages of the money utilised. However, as we all know, abuse, misappropriation, and reckless use of public funds have weakened this presumption significantly. To counteract this, it is critical that all public interactions are completely transparent. This is bound to result in more cautious use and allocation of funds. Transparency will also assist individuals in holding authorities responsible for misusing public time and money.         

Limiting the discretionary powers granted to officials

Officials have the ability to misuse their discretion in order to serve multiple political or some other private interests, in addition, to misappropriating funds. In the lack of legislation governing the right to information, they are often kept secret. Although it is feasible to seek judicial action to force the disclosure of this information, impoverished individuals or villagers are unable to do so due to the expense, distance, and delays in the process. Another issue is the lack of openness in the selection process for public officers. The hiring of ineffective government officials contributes to the government’s inefficiencies and problems. As a result, the right to knowledge is critical to preventing the abuse of administrative discretion and ensuring a fair process.

Ensures the principle of accountability

India has a democratic system of governance in which the government is administered for the benefit of the general public rather than for the advantage of one or a few individuals. As a result, the government from the rural level to the national level must be accountable to the citizens. Citizens have a right to know what the government is up to. A Right to Information would guarantee that individuals can hold public authorities responsible on a regular basis, rather than putting the whole responsibility on their elected representatives, who are frequently unable to obtain the information sought while having all the tools at their disposal.

Increases the effectiveness of media

Even if the government guarantees the right to information, residents rely on media like newspapers, radio, and television for day-to-day information on government activities. The media serves as a conduit between citizens and their government. As a result, it is critical that the media have access to information. The right to information from the media is not a separate right, but rather a component of the public’s right to know. The media has several challenges as a result of their lack of access to government information. When main sources of information are suppressed, balanced reporting becomes impossible. They deliver biassed news, hiding or distorting facts in the lack of precise information. By granting the right to information, the media and the general public would work together to hold the government more accountable.

Appropriate and efficient implementation of government schemes

The national and state governments conduct several projects in rural regions to provide food, shelter, work, and education. These programmes are intended for the poorest of the poor in rural regions. Many people believe that these resources have been consistently misappropriated or mishandled on a large scale. Most individuals are unaware of the existence of these programmes, even if they are aware that they do not get their entitlements under the scheme, allowing them to take less than their allotment. Furthermore, since no one outside of the administration has access to these documents, they are frequently tampered with. Making all this information on these plans available to the public would hold the administration more responsible.

Safeguards civil liberties

The right to information is critical for defending people’s freedoms by making it simpler for civil society organisations to monitor wrongdoings such as custodial deaths and the abuse of legislation on preventative detention. Custodial institutions are among the least transparent places in the country.  Deaths in custody, holding prisoners in jail after they have finished their sentences, and harassment of women are all examples of violations in custody. Access to information is required for effective community oversight of these institutions. Some governments even considered officially granting the right to information with respect to jails.

Restrictions on the Right to Information

  • Several elements of restrictive law, such as the Official Secrets Act of 1923, are included in the legislative framework.
  • The bureaucracy’s widespread culture of secrecy and arrogance; and
  • Low levels of rights awareness among Indians. The fundamental strength of RTI is that it allows individual individuals to request information. As a result, without the need for pressure on organisations or alliances, it places power directly in the hands of the core of democracy- the citizens.

Right to Information as a fundamental right 

The right to information is now a well-established basic right derived from Article 19(1)(a) of the Constitution. The Supreme Court has constantly ruled in favour of citizens’ right to know throughout the years. The essence of this privilege, as well as its limitations, has been considered by the Supreme Court in a number of cases:

Following a careful examination, it can be confidently argued that the path toward the fulfillment of RTI within the constitutional scope began with the decision in Hamdard Dawakhana v. Union of India (1959). In Bennett Coleman v. Union of India (1972), the Supreme Court determined the Right to Information to be part of Article 19(1)(a), holding that the Newsprint Control Order of 1972-1973 issued under the Essential Commodities Act, 1955 was ultra vires Article 19(1)(a). In the majority opinion, Chief Justice A.N. Ray stated, “It is unarguable that freedom of the press means the right of all people to discuss, publish, and express their opinions.” The freedom of the press represents the people’s right to know. What is referred to as the “right of the people to read” in this context refers to the readers’ right to obtain information.

The best interpretation in this respect came from Justice K. K. Mathew in State of U. P. v. Raj Narain,(1975), who emphasised that in a “government of responsibility like ours,” where all agents of the public must be held accountable for their actions, “there can be but a few secrets.” The citizens of our country have a right to know about every public act, performed by public servants.” The facts of this case were that Raj Narain, who contested the legitimacy of Indira Gandhi’s victory in the Lok Sabha elections, demanded the release of Blue Books containing the trip itinerary and security arrangements undertaken for the PM. Though disclosure was not permitted, Mathew, J. found that the people of the country have a right to know the specifics of every public transaction.

The Supreme Court made a significant breakthrough in S. P. Gupta v. Union of India, (1981) when it granted the Right to Information constitutional validity. The point of contention, in this case, was once again with regard to the government of India’s claim for privilege in relation to the disclosure of certain documents, including correspondence between the Chief Justice of India and the Chief Justice of the High Court of Delhi in linkage with the confirmation of Justice Kumar, an additional Judge of the Delhi High Court. In his ever-humanistic tone, Justice Bhagwati embraced the notion of open government, claiming it to be a direct emanation of the right of access to information, which appears to be implied in the right to free speech and expression provided by Article 19(1)(a) of the Constitution. The learned judge concluded that the right to information, or access to information, is important for an ideal democratic way of life. As a result, it is critical that transparency in government operations be the rule, with secrecy justified only when the strictest criterion of public interest requires it.

In a landmark ruling in Union of India v. Association for Democratic Reforms, (2002), the Supreme Court went on to establish the right of voters to know the antecedents of candidates. The scope of Article 19(1)(a) was expanded, and it was confirmed that the right to know the candidate running for election to a House of Parliament, a state legislature, a panchayat, or a municipal corporation is a prerequisite for exercising a citizen’s right to vote. People have a fundamental right to know the backgrounds of people running for a position of great importance in a democracy. Later, the government issued an ordinance, followed by an act, to negate the judgment’s implications. The Supreme Court ruled in People’s Union of Civil Liberties v. UOI, 1996, that the Act was unconstitutional. The Court made a significant observation: “the fundamental rights entrenched in the Constitution… have no set meanings.” “From time to time, this court has infused the skeleton with soul and blood, bringing it to life.”

We can conclude that the Court decisions have played a significant part in awarding constitutional validity to the right to information via interpretation of Article 19 (1)(a) and absorption of the spirit with which the Constitution’s authors devoted it to the people of India. The right to information, which is the cornerstone of democracy, flourishes under democracy.

Provisions of the Right to Information Act

Section 2 defines various important terms given in the Act 

Section 2 of the RTI Act, 2005 defines various important terms, some of which are dealt with as follows:

Appropriate Government [Section 2(a)]

The definition of “appropriate government” is provided in Section 2(a) of the Act. The appropriate government refers to the government’s relationship with a public authority concerned with the right to information. The Central Government, union territory administrations, or state governments establish, constitute, possess, manage, or fund such power.

Thus, the relevant government is the “Central Government” in the event of a public authority affiliated with the central government/union territory administration in the aforementioned way. Whereas the appropriate government is the “State Government” in the event of a public authority affiliated with the state government in the ways specified above.

Competent authority [Section 2(e)]

Section 2(e) of the Act defines “competent authority.” The competent authority is the authority in control of the autonomous institutions that operate in accordance with the requirements of the Constitution. This authority is ultimately responsible for enforcing the RTI Act at those institutions. In the instance of the Supreme Court of India, for example, the Chief Justice of India is the competent authority. Competent authority entails the following:

  • Lok Sabha Speaker
  • Rajya Sabha Chairman
  • State/UT Legislative Assembly Speaker
  • State Legislative Council Chairman
  • Chief Justice of India 
  • Chief Justice of a High Court
  • President or the Governor, as the case may be, in the case of other authorities established or constituted by or under the Constitution
  • Article 239 of the Constitution provides for the appointment of an administrator.

Information [Section 2(f)] 

Section 2(f) specifies the kind of information that can be obtained under the right to information. The term “information” refers to any content in any form, including:

  • Records (written information including any map, image etc. of any act, policy or judgment belonging to a governmental body) 
  • Documents (a portion of a record or a separate document or a piece of information giving specifics on a specific topic or decision of governmental authority) 
  • Memos (they may be in the form of a letter or a note on a particular subject) 
  • E-mails
  • Opinions (opinions of a government agency or government personnel transmitted in official affairs as part of the official record) 
  • Advice (advice on official affairs constituting part of the official record) 
  • Publications in the press (press briefings or press notes on official matters when released in an official capacity)
  • Circulars (government/public authority circulars disseminated in an official capacity informing a certain decision or policy)
  • Orders (any order issued by governmental authority in an official capacity) 
  • Logbooks (documents containing information, observations, and statistics of a particular project of public authority) 
  • Contracts (official contracts entered into by the public authority and the specifics thereof) 
  • Reports (reports about official issues including test results, inquiry reports, and expert reports on a certain subject) 
  • Papers (papers discussing proceedings) 
  • Samples (samples of items to be purchased/consumed for governmental purposes)
  • Models (models of programmes and projects to be done) 
  • Data maintained in any electronic format (data stored in computer, pen drives, CDs)
  • Information on any private organisation that a public authority can obtain under any other law is now in effect.

Public authority [Section 2(h)] 

The term “public authority” is defined under Section 2(h). A public authority is a self-governing authority, body, or organisation that is directly or indirectly linked to the government. Such authority may be linked to the government in the following ways:

  • It is founded by or, created by, under the Constitution.
  • It is established by an Act of Parliament.
  • It is established by a State Legislature Act.
  • It is founded or formed by a notice or order issued by the appropriate government.
  • Anybody owned, managed, or substantially financed by the appropriate government; 
  • Anybody owned, managed, or substantially financed by the appropriate government; 

Record [Section 2(i)]

A record, as defined in Section 2(i) of the Act, may include any of the following:

  • Document: It can refer to any piece of information or a collection of documents giving information on a certain subject.
  • Manuscript: A handwritten text, map, or sketch in its original form.
  • File: A collection of papers or related documents on a certain subject.
  • Digital documents in the form of microfilm, microfiche, and facsimile copy.
  • Electronic documents are reproduced in the form of images.
  • Any additional content created or generated by a computer or other device

Right to information [Section 2(j)]

The term “right to information” is defined in Section 2(j). It refers to the right to get information available under the RTI Act that is held or controlled by any public authority. These rights include:

Right of inspection

This refers to the right to examine and scrutinise papers, works, and records. In this case, no document or copy of a document is obtained, and the information is just observed and scrutinised.

Right to take notes, extracts, and so forth.

Taking notes or extracts refers to jotting down specific information from papers. Important information from the papers is set down here, and authentic excerpts from the documents can also be copied.

Right to get verified material samples

A citizen has the right to acquire verified samples of government-purchased materials or materials used by the government.

Right to acquire information in an electronic format

When the information requested is recorded on a computer or other electronic device, the Right to Information Act allows citizens to acquire it in electronic forms, such as tapes, video cassettes, floppy discs, diskettes, printouts, and so on.

Section 4: Obligations of public authorities 

Section 4(1) states the following duties of public authorities:

Maintaining records: Every public authority is obligated to keep all of its records properly classified and indexed. To ease access to its data, the public authority must ensure that all records that are acceptable for computerisation are computerised and linked across the country on multiple systems within a reasonable time period and according to accessibility.

Publication of specified matters: Every public authority is obligated to publish certain particulars, some of which are listed below:

  • The details of its organisation, activities, and responsibilities;
  • The authority and responsibilities of its officials and staff;
  • The process followed in making decisions, including channels of monitoring and responsibility;
  • The particulars of any arrangement for public participation or public consultation in matters of policy formation or policy execution by a public authority;
  • Such public authority’s employee directory
  • Monthly salary paid to employees and officers
  • Details of Budget allocations for its agencies
  • Details on how subsidy programmes are implemented
  • Details about information stored in electronic form
  • Particulars of information-gathering facilities available to citizens
  • Information of the Public Information Officers, including their names and position held.

Publication of details: A public body must publicise all relevant details about major policies or decisions that affect the public when they are formulated.

Publication of decisions: Every public authority must explain its judicial or administrative decisions to individuals who are affected by them.

Suo moto disclosure of information: Section 4 (2)

Section 4(2) requires public authorities to make efforts to convey information to the public at regular intervals using various channels of communication.

Information dissemination: Sections 4(3) and 4(4)

Section 4(3) calls for the widespread distribution of information that is freely available to the public.

Section 4(4) requires that information be disseminated after taking the following elements into account:

  • cost-effectiveness,
  • a region’s native language, and
  • the most efficient mode of communication in a specific geographical location

Section 5: Designation of Public Information Officers

Section 5(1) requires every public authority to appoint Central Public Information Officers (CPIOs) and State Public Information Officers (SPIOs) within 100 days of the Act’s commencement. Such officers are required by the Act to furnish the requested information.

Section 5(2) establishes a Central Assistant Public Information Officer or a State Assistant Public Information Officer at each sub-divisional or other sub-district levels. Such officials shall accept applications for information or appeals under the Act and send them to the CPIO/SPIO or the senior officer indicated in Section 19(1), the Central Information Commission, or the State Information Commission, as applicable.

Responsibilities and functions of Public information officers

Section 5(3) assigns CPIOs and SPIOs the following responsibilities: 

  • to respond to requests for information from the person requesting information, and
  • To offer appropriate help to the individual requesting information.

Section 6: Request for obtaining information

A citizen who wishes to acquire information under the Act shall submit a written request to the Public Information Officer of the relevant public authority in English, Hindi, or the official language of the region in which the request is made. The application should be specific and precise. He must pay the application fee as specified in the Fee Rules when submitting the application. The applicant may submit the application via mail, electronic means, or in person at the public authorities’ office. The application may also be submitted via an Assistant Public Information Officer. The applicant should apply to the appropriate public authority. It is recommended that he make every effort to determine which public authority is in charge of the information and submit an application to the public information officer with that public authority.

The applicant may also be asked to pay an additional charge to cover the cost of supplying the information, the details of which must be communicated to the applicant by the Public Information Officer. The fee can be paid in the same manner as the application fee. If the applicant falls within the below-poverty line category, then he/she is exempted from paying any fees. He must, however, provide evidence to substantiate his claim of being below the poverty line. An application that is not supported by the necessary application fee or proof that the applicant falls below the poverty line, as the case may be, is not a legitimate application under the Act. There is no set application format for requesting information. The application can be completed on plain paper. However, the applicant’s name and complete postal address must be included in the application. If a person is unable to submit a written request, he may request the aid of the public information officer in making his application, and the public information officer must provide reasonable assistance.

Section 7: Disposal of request

Transferring an application or a part of one should be done as quickly as possible and, in any event, within five days of receiving the application. If a public information officer moves an application after five days from receipt, he is accountable for the delay in disposing of the application up to the number of days he takes in moving the application beyond five days.

The responding public information officer should determine whether the information sought, or a part of it is exempted from disclosure under Sections 8 or 9 of the Act. The part of the application that is exempt may be denied, and the remainder of the information should be delivered promptly or after receipt of additional fees, as applicable.

When a request for information is denied, the public information officer shall notify the individual who made the request:

  • the grounds for the refusal;
  • the time limit for filing an appeal against such refusal; and
  • the details of the agency to whom an appeal may be filed.

If the applicant is obliged to pay an extra charge as specified in the Fee and Cost Rules, the Public Information Officer should notify the applicant:

  • the details of any additional payments that must be paid;
  • the calculations used to arrive at the fee amount requested;
  • the applicant’s entitlement to file an appeal about the amount of fees requested;
  • the designation of the authority to whom such an appeal may be made; and
  • the deadline by which the appeal must be filed

Sections 8, 9, 11 and 24: Exemptions from the disclosure of information

Section 8

Section 8 states that the public information officer is not required to offer the following:

  • information, the publication of which would jeopardise India’s sovereignty and integrity, the State’s security, strategic, technological, or economic interests, relations with other states, or lead to the instigation of an offence; (Article 19(2))
  • information that has been explicitly barred by any court of law or tribunal from being published, or the revelation of which may constitute contempt of court; (Article 19(2))
  • information, whose publication would violate the privileges of Parliament or the State Legislature;
  • information, including commercial confidence, trade secrets, or intellectual property, the publication of which might impair a third party’s market advantage, unless the competent authority is convinced that the revelation of such information is in the broader public interest;
  • information available to a person in his fiduciary relationship, unless the relevant authority is convinced that publication of such information is in the broader public interest;
  • confidential information acquired from a foreign government; (Article 19(2))
  • information that, if disclosed, would jeopardise the life or physical safety of any individual or determine the source of confidential information or assistance provided for law enforcement or security reasons;
  • information that might obstruct the process of investigating, apprehending, or prosecuting offenders;

A public body may provide access to material if the public interest in disclosure outweighs the harm to protected interests, regardless of anything in the Official Secrets Act of 1923 or the allowed exclusions under sub-section (1).

Section 9

Section 9 states that a CPIO/SPIO may refuse a request for information if doing so would result in infringement of copyright owned by someone other than the State.

Section 11

According to Section 11, when a Central Public Information Officer or a State Public Information Officer, as the situation may be, intends to disclose any information or record, or part thereof, in response to a request made under this Act that relates to or was supplied by a third party, and has been treated as confidential by that third party. The Central Public Information Officer or State Public Information Officer, as applicable, shall then provide written notice to a third party of the request and the fact that the Central Public Information Officer or State Public Information Officer, as applicable, intends to share the information or record, or a part thereof, within five days of receiving the request. The authorities should also allow the third party to submit a written or oral statement on whether the information should be revealed, and such input should be considered when making a judgment about the disclosure of information.

Section 24

According to Section 24, nothing in this Act shall apply to the intelligence and security organisations listed in the Second Schedule, which are created by the Central Government, or to any information provided by such organisations to the Central Government. Provided, however, that material concerning allegations of corruption and human rights breaches is not excluded under this sub-section.  Furthermore, if the information sought is in relation to claims of human rights violations, the information shall only be released following the permission of the Central Information Commission, and notwithstanding anything stated in Section 7, such information shall be delivered within forty-five days of the date of the request being received.

Chapter III, IV and V : The Central Information Commission, the State Information Commission and their powers and functions

The statute establishes the Central Information Commission and the State Information Commission. Each commission will be led by a chief information commissioner and will consist of up to 10 additional information officers. Persons of eminence in public life with extensive knowledge and experience in law, management, journalism, mass media, or administration and governance will be appointed to these positions. Section 12 states that the President will appoint the Chief Information Commissioner and information commissioners on the recommendation of a committee comprised of the Prime Minister, who will chair the committee; the Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha; and a Union Cabinet Minister to be nominated by the Prime Minister.

According to Section 15, the Governor shall appoint the State Chief Information Commissioner and the State Information Commissioners on the recommendation of a committee comprised of the Chief Minister, who shall serve as Chairman of the committee; the Leader of the Opposition in the Legislative Assembly; and a Cabinet Minister to be nominated by the Chief Minister.  The Chief Information Information Commissioner or the state chief information commissioner, or the Information Commissioner, must not be a Member of Parliament or a Member of the Legislature of any state or union territory, hold any other office of profit, or be connected with any political party, or carry on any business or pursue any profession.

 A public information officer is appointed for a five-year term beginning on the date he takes office and ending when he reaches the age of 65, whichever comes first, and is not eligible for reappointment. However, provided that upon resigning his office under this subsection, every Information Commissioner shall be eligible for appointment as Chief Information Commissioner in the manner indicated in subsection (3) of Section 12. Furthermore, if the Information Commissioner is appointed as the Chief Information Commissioner, his total term of service as the Information Commissioner and the Chief Information Commissioner should not exceed five years.

The federal and state information commissions have been granted the authority to investigate complaints submitted by offended parties. Aggrieved people include anyone 

  • who has been unable to make a request to a Central Public Information Officer or State Public Information Officer, as the case may be, either because no such officer has been appointed under this Act, or 
  • who the Central Assistant Public Information Officer or State Assistant Public Information Officer, as the case may be, has declined to accept his/her application for information or appeal under this Act; or 
  • who has been denied access to information who has been asked to pay an unreasonable charge; 
  • who feels that he or she has been given incomplete, misleading, or inaccurate information under this Act; and in respect of any other issue pertaining to seeking or receiving access to data under this Act

While investigating any issue under this section, the Central Information Commission or State Information Commission, as the case may be, shall be given the same authority as a civil court while trying an action under the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, in respect of the following matters, namely:

  • calling and compelling people to appear and forcing them to provide oral or written testimony under oath and produce documents or items;
  • necessitating the discovery and scrutiny of documents;
  • receiving evidence on affidavit;
  • obtaining a public document or copies of a public record from any court or office;
  • issuing summons for witnesses or documents to be examined; and
  • any additional matters that may be prescribed

Section 20: Penalties

The CIC/SIC has the authority to impose sanctions on the CPIO/SPIO for purposeful violations of the Act when resolving a complaint or an appeal under the Act. Before any decision regarding the application of a penalty is made, the CPIO/SPIO in question must be given a reasonable opportunity to be heard. The burden of proving that he behaved reasonably and diligently is solely on the concerned CPIO/SPIO.

In Section 20(1) of the Act, several grounds are mentioned according to which a penalty is imposed at the rate of Rs. 250 per day till the application is received or information is furnished. However, the total amount of the penalty shall not exceed Rs. 25,000. Those grounds are:

  • unreasonable refusal to receive an application for information, or
  • information not provided within the time period specified in Section 7(1), or
  • malafidely rejected the information request, or
  • knowingly provided false, incomplete, or misleading information, or
  • the applicant’s requested information was destroyed, or
  • obstructed in any way in providing the information, or

Similarly, in Section 20(2) of the Act, several grounds are mentioned on which a commission shall recommend that disciplinary action be taken against the concerned CPIO/SPIO under the service rules applicable to him. The grounds are related to the persistent default/failure of the CPIO/SPIO in:

  • receiving an application for information or has not furnished information within the time specified under sub-section (1) of Section 7, or
  • malafidely denying the request for information or knowingly giving incorrect, incomplete or misleading information, or
  • destroying information that was the subject of the request, or 
  • obstructing in any manner in furnishing the information.

Impact of the Right to Information Act

The Right to Information Act of 2005 fosters peaceful coexistence between citizens and their governments. Previously, when a problem arose, public officers were more superior-oriented rather than service-oriented, because there were no checks on their services. However, the RTI Act provides a straitjacket solution for making public servants more service-oriented. People now have the right to get information from public authorities under the RTI Act, which causes a fear of exposure in the minds of public servants, affecting their attitude toward their tasks and obligations. The Right to Information Act of 2005 plays an important role in good governance since it improves accountability and government performance. The Act creates a method for the public to get information from public offices. Any administrative action or quasi-judicial judgment rendered by any public authority must be documented in minute detail. The general public or concerned parties can obtain this information from public offices at any time. The Act also values citizen engagement in the decision-making process. NGOs, cooperation, institutions, or the general public have the right to obtain information about various yojana, plans, schemes, and allotments of funds and resources by the government in rural and urban areas. With the aid of data from NGOs and social welfare institutions, the institution gains an understanding of society’s problems and their remedies. The Act gives assistance to prevent corruption in public offices; today, public officers are not using funds for personal gain and are not abusing their public power.

Criticism of Right to Information Act

The Act has been criticised for a number of reasons. It gives information on demand but does not emphasise information on food, water, the environment, and other necessities that must be provided proactively, or suo motu, by public authorities. The Act places little emphasis on active action in educating the people about their right to information, which is critical in a nation with high levels of illiteracy and poverty, or on promoting an open culture within official organisations. Without extensive education and knowledge of the new Act’s prospects, it may remain on paper. The Act further strengthens the controlling role of the government official, who has broad discretion to withhold information. The most vehement criticism of the bill has come from those who point to the broad exclusions it allows. Information on security, foreign policy, defence, law enforcement, and public safety is often restricted. Furthermore, under the Right to Information Act, cabinet materials, including records of the council of ministers, secretaries, and other officials, are exempted, essentially shielding the whole decision-making process from required publication. Another harsh criticism of the Act is the recent revision that was to be made, allowing for the exclusion of files other than those pertaining to social and development initiatives from the Act’s scope. When it comes to government policymaking, file notes are quite essential. These notes provide the reasoning behind actions or policy changes, why a particular contract was awarded, or why the punishment was withheld in order to pursue a corrupt person. As a result, the government’s proposal to exclude file notings from the Act has been met with harsh criticism. 

Also, logical grounds for rejecting requests for information are not supplied, as required by Section 7(8) of the Act. Furthermore, the exemption clause in Section 8 of the Act is being abused to conceal wrongdoing in the guise of national security, integrity, and so on. Although the addition of a public interest override is a significant step forward, the fact that the exemptions only feature a low-level injury test requiring that relevant interests be “harmed” or “prejudicially impacted” might be used to deny a large number of applications at the outset. Applicants have often complained that information is not supplied to them in their regional language. This is contrary to the legislative spirit expressed in Section 6(1) of the Act, which states that information must be supplied in Hindi, English, or the official language of the region in which the application is filed.

Issues and suggestions for effective implementation of Right to Information Act

The following recommendations are made to ensure that the Act is effectively implemented:

  • The technical aspects of submitting an RTI application should be simplified. Rural India has a low literacy rate, making it difficult for them to comply with the regulations.
  • The applicability and impact of the RTI should be popularised through public awareness efforts, particularly for the poor and disadvantaged, who are more harmed than the rest. The contribution of non-governmental organisations and the media in this regard is greatly expected.
  • There is an urgent need to safeguard whistleblowers who are readily targeted or attacked. 
  • Children are seen as resources for a nation’s future health. As a result, the RTI Act should be included in the school curriculum to kindle children’s interest in RTI at the grassroots level.
  • It may be practical, but the provision for charging fees for revealing information appears to be contrary to both the spirit of the right and the Act. It is rather odd that a person must pay to obtain knowledge. As a socially motivated policy, it strikes the wrong chord here by creating a division between individuals on an economic basis. The wealthy classes have easy access to information, whereas students and the poor strata of society do not.
  • Although the Act empowers the CIC and SIC to levy fines ranging from Rs. 250 to Rs. 25000 on erring employees who engage in unjustified no disclosure of information. However, it does not have the same deterring impact on powerful officials. However, while recommending disciplinary action appears to be successful, it is insufficient for rigorous compliance with the RTI Act of 2005. The absence of such teeth, which may bite officials via the rigours of the law allows for the formation of an accountable and transparent government.

Conclusion

Without a doubt, the Right to Information Act is momentous, with the potential to forever change the balance of power in India, disempowering governments and other powerful institutions and transferring power to the people. To change the nation from a representational democracy to a participatory democracy, in which governments and their functionaries at all levels are directly accountable to the people for their acts and inactions, thereby strengthening the basic foundations of the world’s largest democracy. Realising this promise will require a far more determined effort in the coming years. When it comes to power and control, there is simply no time to waste. Those in authority will exploit people’s weaknesses if they do not stick together and continue their attempts to reclaim the power that is rightly theirs. By implementing the Right to Information Act, India has transitioned from an opaque and arbitrary system of governance to the start of a new age of more openness and a system in which the public is empowered and the genuine centre of power. Only by empowering ordinary citizens can a nation grow toward greatness, and India has made a significant step towards that objective by implementing the Right to Information Act 2005. The true Swaraj will be achieved not via the acquisition of authority by a few, but through the development of the capacity by all to reject authority when it is misused. Thus, by passing this Act, India has taken a significant step toward achieving true Swaraj. However, if this potential is to be realised, a far more determined attempt to develop the RTI regime in the coming years is required. There is no time to spend on basic conflicts like those for power and control. 

References


Students of Lawsikho courses regularly produce writing assignments and work on practical exercises as a part of their coursework and develop themselves in real-life practical skills.

LawSikho has created a telegram group for exchanging legal knowledge, referrals, and various opportunities. You can click on this link and join:

https://t.me/lawyerscommunity

Follow us on Instagram and subscribe to our YouTube channel for more amazing legal content.

Download Now

Arms Act, 1959

0

This article is written by Nikara Liesha Fernandez and Pragya Agrahari. Through this article, the author carries out an in-depth analysis of the development of the Arms Act, 1959 as well as the provisions of the same and the amendments made to it by the Arms (Amendment) Bill, 2019. It also provides a detailed analysis of the Arms Act, 1959, consisting of its objectives, important definitions, provisions for licensing of weapons, appeals, and offences under the Act.

This article has been published by Sneha Mahawar.

Introduction

The Arms Act, 1959 was enacted by the Indian Parliament with the sole purpose of consolidating and amending the laws relating to arms and ammunition. This was the need of the hour in order to curb the menace caused by individuals holding illegal weapons which could be potentially used to perpetrate violence in society through criminal activities. The Act aims to be as extensive as possible to cover all aspects relating to the acquisition, possession, manufacture, sale, import, export and transport of arms and ammunition as stated explicitly in Chapter II of the same. Further, Chapter IV of the Act elaborates upon the powers and procedures exercisable by the government and other officials in regulating the use and possession of arms and ammunition in India including provisions for arrest, search, seizure and detention orders. 

History of the Arms Act

The very first instance involving the use of guns by the Indian people which caused alarm among the then individuals in power- the British, was the sepoy mutiny of 1857. This unsettling event during colonial times involved the introduction of the infamous Enfield rifle by the British for use by the Indian sepoys. In order to use the rifle, however, the sepoys had to bite off the lubricated cartridges which were greased with a mixture of pig and cow lard. This was a tactic to insult the religious sentiments of the Muslims and Hindus respectively and caused mass violence and discontent among the Indian sepoys. This gave momentum to the sepoys to unite and cause a violent uprising against the British officials. 

The British, on realizing the rapidity with which the Indians were able to put their differences aside and join hands to fight against their oppression decided that the only way to prevent any future mass uprisings against them was to establish an Act that restricted the Indians from possessing any arms. This gave rise to the Indian Arms Act, 1878. According to this Act, only those Indians who had prior permission or a proper license were allowed to possess arms. This Act further regulated the manufacture, sale, possession and carrying of firearms and was implemented during the tenure of the then Viceroy of India, Lord Lytton. 

The hypocrisy of this Act was evident as Europeans were conveniently exempted from the provisions of the same while strict penalties and punishments were put forward for Indians if they were found owning any type of weapon. 

After independence, the Government of India passed the Indian Arms Act, 1959 which recognised the necessity for certain law-abiding citizens to possess and use firearms for the purposes of sports, crop protection and self-defence. This Act was followed by the Arms Rules of 1962. 

Objectives and scope of the Arms Act, 1959

As per the preamble, this Act aims ‘to consolidate and amend the law relating to arms and ammunitions.’ The main objective of this Act is to regulate and restrict the circulation of arms and ammunition, which were illegal. It provides the procedure for obtaining licences for some categories of arms or ammunition and restricts dangerous weapons so that they will not be available to civilians. This Act applies to the whole of India. 

Moreover, through this Act, the people’s right to keep and bear arms has been recognised as a legal right. It was realised that in some situations, like self-defence, or in circumstances where there is a serious threat to life and property, it is necessary to allow them to possess and use certain arms and ammunition.

Important definitions under Arms Act, 1959

Ammunition

“Ammunition” means objects used to shoot firearms. As per the definition provided under Section 2(b) of this Act, “ammunition” includes:

  1. rockets, bombs, grenades, shells or missiles,
  2. articles used in torpedo service and submarine mining,
  3. articles used to contain any explosives, fulminating or fissionable material or any noxious liquid or gas or any other things which can or cannot be used with firearms,
  4. charges for firearms and their accessories,
  5. fuses or friction tubes,
  6. manufacturing machinery or parts of ammunition,
  7. any other ingredients specified by the Central government.

Arms

As per the definition of “arms” provided in Section 2(c), arms means articles that are designed as weapons for offence or defence. It includes firearms, any other sharpened or deadly weapons, and manufacturing machinery and parts of arms. But it does not include the following:

  1. Articles designed solely for domestic or agricultural purposes, like lathi or walking stick, or
  2. Weapons that can only be used as toys or are incapable of being converted into serviceable weapons.

Firearms

According to the definition of “firearms” provided under Section 2(e), it means arms that are designed to discharge a projectile(s) through an explosion or any other form of energy. It includes:

  1. Artillery, hand grenades, riot pistols or weapons designed to discharge noxious liquid or gas,
  2. Accessories for firearms used to diminish the noise or flash caused by such firearms,
  3. Manufacturing machinery or parts of firearms,
  4. Carriages, platforms and appliances for transporting firearms.

Provision for licenses

The process of obtaining an arms license is no easy task. Unlike the United States of America, where the right to bear arms is constitutionally recognized, the Indian firearm laws are one of the strictest in the world. Obtaining a license to possess a firearm can take a minimum of one whole year due to the number of procedures that one has to undergo in order to satisfy the authorities that he/she is eligible to possess a firearm. 

Section 3 of the Act states that only those individuals who possess a valid license issued in accordance with the provisions of the Act are entitled to possess any firearm or ammunition. The 1959 act permits individuals to possess a maximum of three firearms. The excess, if any, is to be deposited at the nearest police station within 90 days of the commencement of the Act. 

Applications for the grant of an arms license are required to be made to the appropriate licensing authority in the proper form with the required documents and fees. The minimum age that an individual needs to be in order to be eligible to possess a firearm is 21 years. In the case of a ‘junior target shooter’, however, an individual of 16 years of age is allowed to possess a firearm. 

An individual’s application for a license must be accompanied by documents such as identity proof, address proof, proof of age and education, four passport size photographs, income tax returns for the last three years and a character certificate as well as physical and mental health certificates. 

For a self-defence license, it is mandatory that the individual proves that he/she faces an impending threat to life. This can, however, includes the threat of wild animals. 

Following the application, the police carries out a background check of the individual, spanning a time period of two months which consists of an interview period of the individual’s family and neighbours in order to assess his/her nature- whether he/she is aggressive or suppressive, has any criminal history of domestic violence or aggression, etc. 

The reports made by the police are stored with the Police Criminal Branch of the National Crime Record Bureau and finally, the licensing authorities interview the applicant and decide whether they want to grant or reject the application for the license. 

If the license is granted, the applicant is mandatorily made to participate in an ‘arms handling’ course to ensure he/she handles the firearm in a safe and responsible manner. Arms licenses are valid for a period of three years.

The Central Government has the final say on the confiscation of licenses and weapons of individuals at any point in time. They also hold a monopoly over the manufacture, import, export and sale of such arms and ammunition. 

The licensing authority has the power to deny an individual the license to possess arms under the following conditions (Section 14 of the Act) –

  1. If the individual is already prohibited under the provisions of this Act or under any other law currently in force from possessing any arms and ammunition, or
  2. If the individual is found to be of unsound mind or age of minority.

Licence for manufacture and sale of arms

Section 5 of the Act clearly prohibits any person from using, manufacturing, selling, transferring, converting, repairing, or testing any arms or ammunition without having been issued a licence. But a person is allowed to sell or transfer arms and ammunition that he legally possesses for his own private use to another person who is not prohibited by this Act from possessing such arms or ammunition. In the case of firearms for which a licence is required, the person selling or transferring such firearms should inform the district magistrate having jurisdiction or the officer of the nearest police station about:

  1. The sale or transfer of such firearms, and
  2. Name and address of the person to whom he intends to transfer or sell.

It should be noted that the person who is selling or transferring such firearms should sell or transfer them within 45 days of providing such information. 

Licence for import/export of arms

Section 10 of the Act clearly states that unless a person is holding a licence, they are not allowed to take any arms or ammunition out of India, either by land, air, or water. But there are some exceptions to this rule:

  1. A person who is entitled by this Act or any other Act, or a person who is not prohibited under this Act, can take such arms or ammunitions in reasonable quantities, out of India, without any licence and such arms or ammunitions should be for his own private use.
  2. A person who is a bona fide tourist can bring into India arms or ammunition in reasonable quantities for the purposes of the sport only. Such a person should belong to the country as specified by the Central Government in the Official Gazette and is not prohibited by the laws of that country to possess any arms or ammunition.

Moreover, the Commissioner of Customs, empowered by the Central Government, has extensive powers to detain arms or ammunition until he gets an order from the Central Government.

Duration of licence

Section 15 of the Act specifies that the duration of the licence is for a period of 3 years from the date on which it was granted. However, it can be granted for a shorter period if the person desires so or if the licensing authority considers so, due to any reasons which need to be recorded. Every licence is renewable in the same way as it was granted under Sections 13 and 14, unless the licensing authority decides otherwise for reasons that are to be recorded.

Suspension of licence

Section 17(3) of the Act provides for the suspension or revocation of the licence under the following circumstances:

  1. If the licensing authority is satisfied that the person is prohibited under this Act or any other Act to acquire or possess arms or ammunition, or if the person is of unsound mind, or if the person is unfit due to any reasons for grant of licence under this Act,
  2. If it licensing authority deems it necessary for public safety to revoke the licence,
  3. If the licence was obtained on the basis of wrong information or by suppressing material information,
  4. If any conditions for the grant of the licence were not fulfilled,
  5. If the licence holder fails to comply with the notice under Section 17(1) of the Act,
  6. If the licence-holder applies for such revocation.

The licensing authority should provide the licence holder with a brief written statement consisting of the reasons for such a revocation.

Types of arms

The Act categorises under Section 2, the firearms which an individual can possess into two main categories:

  1. Prohibited Bores (PB), which can be used only by the Army, Central Paramilitary forces or the State police.
  2. Non- Prohibited Bores (NPB), which can be used by all individuals who hold a valid arms license.

The primary basis of the distinction between the two is on the measurements of the bore, which is the thickness or diameter of the bullet. 

The 2008 Mumbai terror attacks saw a change in gun ownership norms. Prior to the attack, prohibited bore firearms were allowed to be used by both defence forces personnel and family heirlooms. Post the attacks, however, only those individuals who face ‘serious and imminent threat’ to their own person or family members as a result of being residents of terrorist-prone areas, or are potential targets of terrorists as a result of the nature of the jobs, are allowed to possess PB firearms. The PB licenses can only be granted by the Central Government. 

Prohibitions

Section 2(1)(h) of the Act contains a list of ‘prohibited ammunition’ which includes any ammunition containing any noxious liquid, gas or any other such thing and includes rockets, bombs, grenades, shells, missiles and articles designed for torpedo service and submarine mining. 

Further, the prohibited arms enumerated in Section 2(1)(i) of the act include adapted firearms that provide a continuous discharge of missiles on applying pressure to the trigger or until the magazine containing the missiles is empty as well as any weapons designed to discharge noxious liquids and gases. The list also includes artillery, anti-aircraft and anti-tank firearms. 

Section 7 of the act prohibits the possession, acquisition, manufacture, or sale of the prohibited arms and ammunition as stated above. Section 9 of the act further prohibits the acquisition and possession, whether by sale or transfer of the firearms to young persons (those individuals who have not completed 21 years of age). Sections 24A and B of the act prohibit the possession of notified arms in disturbed areas and the carrying of notified arms in or through public places in disturbed areas respectively. 

Deposition of unlawful arms

Section 21 of the Act states that an individual is required to deposit the arms in his/her possession without any delay to the appropriate officer of a police station, in the event of his/her license getting expired, revoked, or suspended such that further possession of the arms by the individual becomes unlawful. 

Who can possess arms

Though the Act does not specifically provide who can possess certain arms and ammunition, Sections 9 and 14 consists of persons who are prohibited from acquiring or possessing such firearms. Section 9(a) states that persons who are not eligible to possess or acquire any firearms and ammunition who:

  1. Is below the age of 21 years, or
  2. Has been convicted and sentenced of any offence related to violence or moral turpitude, during a period of 5 years after the expiration of sentence, or
  3. Has been ordered by the court to execute a bond for keeping the peace or good behaviour under the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, during a period of that bond.

Section 14(b)(i) states that where a licensing authority has reason to believe that the person is

  1. Prohibited by any provisions under the Act or by any other law applicable at that time, for acquiring, possessing or carrying any arms or ammunition, or
  2. Of an unsound mind, or
  3. Due to any reason, is unfit for a licence under the Act.

Powers of the central government

The Central Government may, by notification in the Official Gazette, take the following actions:

  1. Prohibit the import or export of certain arms or ammunitions (Section 11), 
  2. Restrict the transportation of arms or ammunition over India or in any part of it (Section 12),
  3. Suspend or revoke or direct the licensing authority to suspend or revoke anyone’s licence issued under this Act (Section 17(9)),
  4. Exempt or exclude any person or class of persons in relation to specified arms or ammunitions, from the operation of certain provisions or the entire provisions of this Act (Section 41),
  5. Direct a census of firearms in any area and empower any officer to conduct such census (Section 42),
  6. Delegate its powers or functions to any officer subordinate to the Central Government or State Government (Section 43),
  7. Make rules for carrying out any functions under this Act (Section 44). 

Appeal and appellate authority

Any person who is aggrieved by the order of the licensing authority can appeal to the appellate authority against such order within a prescribed period as per the Indian Limitation Act, 1908. But if the order is made by the government or under the directions of the government, no appeal shall lie against such an order.

This appeal should be made through a petition in writing along with a brief statement of reasons for appealing against the order. It should also be accompanied by the prescribed fees. In disposing of such an appeal, the appellate authority should provide the appellant with a reasonable opportunity to be heard. The order against which the appeal was filed shall remain in force until and unless the appellate authority directs otherwise. The order of the appellate authority, whether to modify, confirm, or reverse the order, shall be final.

Penalties for offences (more content for existing heading) 

SectionOffencePunishment
Section 25(1)Manufacture, sale, etc of arms and ammunition without licence/ shortening of guns or conversion of imitation firearms into firearms/ import and export of arms after the prohibition of Government, etc.Minimum imprisonment of 3 years which may extend to 7 years and fine.
Section 25(1A)Acquiring or possessing prohibited arms or ammunitionMinimum imprisonment of 5 years which may extend to 10 years and fine.
Section 25(1AA)Manufacturer, sale, transfer, etc/ keeping in possession for sale, transfer, etc any prohibited arms or ammunitionsMinimum imprisonment of 7 years which may extend to life imprisonment and fine.
Section 25(1AAA)Possessing/ carrying notified arms or ammunitions in disturbed areas (Section 24A, 24B)Minimum imprisonment of 3 years which may extend to 7 years and fine.
Section 25(1B)Acquiring, possessing, carrying firearms or ammunition without a licence,  Acquiring, possessing, or carrying firearms or ammunition without a licence in notified places, Selling, and transferring firearms with no identification marks- the name of the maker or manufacturer’s number, etc, Carrying or possessing arms or ammunitions by persons who are prohibited- A convicted person for an offence related to violence or moral turpitude and during the period of 5 years after the expiration of his sentence, orA person who has executed a bond for keeping good behaviour and during the period of his bond. Selling, transferring to, or converting, repairing, etc for prohibited persons or persons of unsound mind, Importing or exporting arms or ammunition, Transporting arms or ammunition despite of Government’s notification, Failing to deposit arms if it is exceeding the limit of three within 90 days or if it has been suspended, revoked or in any kind become unlawful, Failure to maintain records, false entry or obstructing inspection of records, etc by manufacturer or dealer in arms or ammunition.Minimum imprisonment of 1 year which may extend to 3 years and a fine.
Section 25(IC)Committing any offence punishable under this section in the disturbed area.Minimum imprisonment of 3 years which may extend to 7 years and fine.
Section 25(2)Acquiring, possessing, or carrying arms or ammunition by a person who has not completed the age of 21 years.Imprisonment for a term that may extend to 1 year or a fine or both.
Section 25(3)Selling or transferring arms or ammunition without informing the District Magistrate or officer of the nearest police station.Imprisonment for a term that may extend to 6 months or a fine that may extend to 500 rupees or both.
Section 25(4)Failing to deliver up a licence or failing to surrender a licence after suspension or revocation.Imprisonment for a term that may extend to 6 months or a fine that may extend to 500 rupees or both.
Section 25(5)Refusing to furnish name and address when required or giving a false name or address.Imprisonment for a term which may extend to 6 months or fine which may extend to 500 rupees or both

Non-application of the Arms Act, 1959 in certain cases

The provisions of this Act would not apply in certain cases, which are as follows:

  1. If such arms or ammunition is on board on sea-going vessel or aircraft and is a part of the ordinary armament or equipment of such vessel or aircraft,
  2. Acquisition, possession, manufacturer, repair, sale, transfer, import, export, transport, etc of arms or ammunition
    1. If it is done under the orders of the Central Government,
    2. If it is done by a public servant in the course of his duty,
    3. If it is done by 
      1. a member of the National Cadet Corps under the National Cadet Corps Act, 1948,
      2. an officer or an enrolled person of the Territorial Army under the Territorial Army Act, 1948,
      3. a member of other forces under any Central Act or in accordance with a Central Government’s notification in the Official Gazette,
  3. Obsolete weapon of antiquarian value not capable of being used as a firearm without repair,
  4. Acquisition, possession, and carrying of minor parts of arms or ammunition not intended to be used with complementary parts.

Relevant case laws in the context of the Arms Act

Right to possess arms and ammunition as a fundamental right under Article 21

In the case of Ganesh Chandra Bhatt v. Distt Magistrate, Almora & Ors. (1993), the issue was whether the right to bear arms formed a part of the right to self-defence, which is a facet of the right to life and liberty under Article 21 of the Constitution. In this case, the Court observed the following:

  • The right to bear arms did indeed fall within the ambit of Article 21, under the right to self-defence. 
  • If despite the applicant has followed the due procedure to obtain the license for a non-prohibited firearm, he/she still receives no communication from the authorities at the conclusion of three months, the license is deemed to have been granted by the government. 
  • The custom of worshipping firearms during the festivals of Dussehra and Diwali, which finds its roots in the Mahabharata is linked with the self-respect and dignity of a citizen which was essential for him/her to enjoy their right to life granted under Article 21. 

This decision, however, was consequently overturned in the aftermath of the 1993 Bombay bomb blasts, as a result of which the constitutional protection granted to the right to bear arms was abolished and the right to bear arms has henceforth been governed solely according to the provisions of the Arms Act and is recognized as a legal right under the same. 

‘Conscious possession’ as a core ingredient to establish guilt for an offence punishable under Section 25 of the Arms Act

In the case of Hari Kishan v. State (NCT Of Delhi) (2019), the issue was with regard to the interpretation of the word ‘possession’ under Section 25 of the Arms Act which dealt with the offences and penalties for individuals which resulted in imprisonment for a minimum period of three years, extendable to seven years with a fine. 

The petitioner, in this case, was found to be in the alleged possession of a live cartridge in the side pocket of his bag which was detected by officials who were conducting the baggage check at the Saket metro station. The petitioner, as a result of this finding, was immediately charge-sheeted under Section 25 of the Arms Act. 

The petitioner claimed that he was utterly shocked and surprised as he did not have any knowledge of the presence of the live cartridge in his bag’s side pocket and instead he was framed for the same. The petitioner had a clean record. It was also proven that there was no firearm or any weapon at all in his possession. Further, he had no knowledge of the presence of the live cartridge, or in other words, he was definitely not in conscious possession of the live cartridge. 

He stated that Section 25 of the act covered conscious possession and that mere custody without the awareness of the nature of such possession could not constitute an offence under the Act. The petitioner further drew the Court’s notice to the fact that the provisions of the Act could not apply in the present case as according to Section 45 of the act itself, ‘the acquisition, possession or carrying by a person of minor parts of arms or ammunition which are not intended to be used along with complementary parts acquired or possessed by them of any other person’ does not fall under the commission of an offence. 

The Court agreed with the petitioner’s arguments and in the fact that there was not a “whisper of averment in the First Information Report (FIR) as averred in the charge sheet that the petitioner was aware of being in alleged conscious and knowledgeable possession of the ammunition in question, the FIR against the petitioner as well as the proceedings emanating therefrom were quashed”.

The facts of the above case are similar to the case of Rachelle Joel Oseran v. The State of Maharashtra and Others (2018), which dealt with the issue of ‘conscious possession’ and the Court in this case as well held the same verdict as stated above. 

The Arms (Amendment) Bill, 2019

The main feature of the Arms (Amendment) Bill, 2019 was the modification of the definition of ‘arms’ to include firearms, swords and anti-aircraft missiles. Despite the attempts made by the previous act to curb the nexus of illegal firearms and criminal activity, the use of illegal firearms in the commission of offences was still rife in society. Additionally, the validity period of the arms license was extended from three to five years and the number of arms permissible to be within an individual’s possession (provided he/she is carrying a valid license) was reduced from three to two. This included arms passed on by way of a family heirloom. Under the list of prohibitions, the obtaining or procuring of unlicensed firearms was added as well as the conversion of one category of firearm to another without a valid license, which included modifications done to increase the efficiency of performance of the firearm. 

One of the concerns raised with regard to the limitation of the number of arms permitted for possession was by the competitors of professional shooting as a sport in India. In order to address these concerns, the Ministry of Home Affairs, via a notification posted on the 24th of February, 2020, permitted an increase in the number of firearms that could be kept by professional shooters, as well as an enhancement in the quantity of ammunition which was to be used for their practice. 

Penalties for offences

The quantum of punishment according to the Arms (Amendment) Bill, 2019 has almost doubled as compared to the Arms Act of 1959. For example, the punishment under Section 25 (1AA) of the 1959 Act which dealt with the manufacturing, selling, repairing and possessing prohibited arms, was a minimum of seven years of imprisonment which could be extended to a maximum of 10 years. The new amendment, however, extends the minimum period of imprisonment to a period of 14 years and the maximum term can extend to imprisonment for life.

Conclusion 

The latest plan of the Ministry of Home Affairs is to maintain a National Database of Arms Licenses, which is to serve as an official record of the holders of arms licenses, in order to regulate the same and keep illegal activities at a minimum. As of January 2021, statistics show that despite the efforts of the legislature to curb the menace of illegal firearm crimes, India continues to have the 2nd highest number of deaths due to the use of guns, most of which are unregistered and illegal. India cannot be compared to the USA with regard to gun control as the latter is a developed nation, with a higher level of literacy and a lower crime rate than India. The government is more efficient in the USA in regulating the flow of arms in the country and conducting investigations of the arms applicants. India, though moving in the same direction, still has a long way to go. 

The question of whether guns can ever gain constitutional protection in India has been argued by many individuals for a long time right from our very own famous freedom fighters. According to Mahatma Gandhi, “Among the many misdeeds of the British rule in India, history will look upon the Act depriving a whole nation of arms as the blackest. If we want the Arms Act to be repealed, if we want to learn the use of arms, here is a golden opportunity. If the middle classes render voluntary help to the Government in the hour of its trial, distrust will disappear, and the ban on possessing arms will be withdrawn.”

Dr. B. R. Ambedkar’s views on firearms, on the other hand, were completely opposite as can be inferred from his statement, “I personally myself cannot conceive how it would be possible for the State to carry on its administration if every individual had the right to go into the market and purchase all sorts of instruments of attack without any let or hindrance from the State.”

FAQs

Can a person be punished for possession of arms without his knowledge?

In the case of Rachelle Joel Oseran v. the State of Maharashtra (2018), it was held by the Bombay High Court that mere possession of arms without his/her knowledge is not punishable. This judgment relied on the interpretation of the word “possession” given by the Supreme Court in the case of Sanjay Dutt v. State through C.B.I. Bombay (1994), where it was held that ‘possession’ means possession with a requisite mental element or conscious possession and not mere custody without knowledge of such possession.

What are “disturbed areas” under Arms Act, 1959?

Under Sections 24A and 24B, this Act contains special provisions applicable to disturbed areas, that is, areas, where there is a disturbance of public peace and tranquility or there, is apprehension of imminent danger, which also involves the use of arms or ammunition. In this case, it becomes necessary to restrict arms or ammunition over such an area and authorise the officers, who are subordinate to the central or state government, to take several actions.

Can a person be punished for carrying a toy gun in public?

In the case of Maroju Vaikunta Balaji v. State of AP. (2022), where a petitioner posed with an air gun in a cinema theater, the case was filed under Sections 290 and 506(2) of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) and Section 25 of the Arms Act. The Andhra Pradesh High Court observed that these offences under the IPC are bailable in nature, and, with regard to Section 25 of the Arms Act, the pistol used was an air gun, which is a toy gun. Hence, prima facie, this Section will not attract. 

Is it illegal to fire a gun in the air?

In the case of Shyam Sunder Kaushal v. the Union of India (2017), where a girl died as a result of celebratory firing during a marriage ceremony, the Delhi High Court issued several directions to the government to frame stringent policies to curb this obnoxious practice.

References



Students of Lawsikho courses regularly produce writing assignments and work on practical exercises as a part of their coursework and develop themselves in real-life practical skills.

LawSikho has created a telegram group for exchanging legal knowledge, referrals, and various opportunities. You can click on this link and join:

https://t.me/lawyerscommunity

Follow us on Instagram and subscribe to our YouTube channel for more amazing legal content.

Download Now
logo
FREE & ONLINE 3-Day Bootcamp (LIVE only) on

How Can Experienced Professionals Become Independent Directors

calender
28th, 29th Mar, 2026, 2 - 5pm (IST) &
30th Mar, 2026, 7 - 10pm (IST).
Bootcamp starting in
Days
HRS
MIN
SEC
Abhyuday AgarwalCOO & CO-Founder, LawSikho

Register now

Abhyuday AgarwalCOO & CO-Founder, LawSikho